A German Victory in 1918
When the treaty of Versailles was signed June 28 1919 the whole world celebrated an allied victory, more importantly they celebrated victory over an evil empire set to destroy the world. This is the viewpoint taught to any American child who studies World War One. To suggest anything to the contrary could be construed as treason, after all the United States and Great Britain are good nations full of good people run by good democracies that fight the good fight and win the good fight and make our world a better place. Perhaps this too is a fallacy, the same kind of fallacy that said World War One was a war to end all wars and that victory would mean a long and lasting peace for generations to enjoy.
The good intention of the allied nations could be contested by their harsh, unyielding and downright hypocritical terms reached in the treaty of Versailles. Woodrow Wilson wanted a more easy and comprehensive peace which he clearly stated during his suggestion of the Fourteen Points. France however wanted spoils of war and thus France demanded and received its harsh demands that only further lead to increased hatred of France by the German people. Territory itself was a major French objective and they received several German lands the German's had held for quite some time and were populated by German speaking people such as Alsace-Lorraine. French revanchism of the time lead them to further demand that Germany's military would only be a shadow of its former self. Further insult was done to Germany by demanding that they would have to pay 132 billion marks to the allied powers and thus make the German economy impotent.
These harsh reparations had an effect unforeseen that would have dire consequenc...
... middle of paper ...
...ance, and to a lesser extent the United States would enjoy far less power. France and Britain would at least initially suffer serious economic problems following a German victory. However unless power is your only goal I feel that the reason people don't oppose this argument is due to it being difficult for any person to assert that World War II would be any less cataclysmic for both Britain and France. The United States would almost certainly feel that that allowing the rise of the USSR via World War I was not worth a Cold War or Cuban Missile Crisis. The argument I make is based upon events very profound to our current culture and the sheer amount of variables and their consequences is simply a staggering a sobering experience to try and undertake, this inevitably leads to my argument to being novel and profound while making an opposition less likely to develop.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Paris spring 1919, Europe has just lived through the desolation of the First World War, and the French people embraced the men who had helped them win victory. At the peace conference, that lead to the formation of the treaty of Versailles, the most puissant of the triumphant nations, were represented by the big three: Woodrow Wilson President of the United States of America, Clemenceau the President of France and Lloyd George the Prime Minister of Britain. Europe was “racked by hatred, fear, nationalism and hunger,” (Nicolson 1945, pgx) and it was their mission to recover her stability.... [tags: Treaty of Versailles, World War I, Woodrow Wilson]
1303 words (3.7 pages)
- The best example of something that ultimately led to World War II is the treaty of Versailles. To examine the treaty, we must look back to the end of 1918. After the U.S. had joined the war, fresh U.S troops helped the allies defeat Germany in the battle of Meuse-Argonne. The end of the battle was marked by German officials contacting President Wilson to arrange a cease fire along the western front. On November 11th, 1918 Germany unofficially surrendered to the Allies. Germany surrendered in hopes that Europe would follow Woodrow Wilson’s 14 Point Plan when constructing a peace agreement.... [tags: World War I, Treaty of Versailles, World War II]
1889 words (5.4 pages)
- Why Germany lost the War in 1918 After four years of monotonous stalemate the war was finally over. In October the German Chancellor appealed to the USA and by 11th November the armistice was signed in a railway carriage in the French forest of CompiAgne. An end to the war, which had cost so many lives, was the only option for a crumbling Germany. This defeat was inevitable from the outset of 1918 for a number of reasons. They can be split into three categories; the first being the strikes, rebellions and general chaos within a tired, hungry Germany, the second are the gains, losses and mistakes of Germanys military force and the third being the arrival of the... [tags: Papers]
1456 words (4.2 pages)
- Opposition of the Versailles Treaty in Germany Many people believe that the Versailles Treaty was to blame for the long term undermining of the Weimar Republic. There would have been no way that the German people would have accepted the treaty unless the Allies hadn't threatened to continue the war and dismember Germany. This was because German propaganda had shielded the people from what was really happening on the fronts. One of the main reasons the German people rejected the treaty so much was because they would have had no idea what was happening at the front apart from what they would read in biased German newspapers.... [tags: Papers]
956 words (2.7 pages)
- Hitler’s regime in Germany is commonly referred to as Nazism, and is identified in the theories of both Sternhell and Payne, which they conclude to be completely divergent from Italian fascism. If this is the case, then Paxton’s five stages of fascism are proven to be invalid; as, like Mussolini in Italy, Hitler’s regime in Germany shows direct resemblance to these stages, as the latter parts of this chapter will show. With the signing of the armistice, that formally ended World War One, on November 11 1918, Germany respectively lost the war.... [tags: German History ]
1430 words (4.1 pages)
- Hitler's Rise Due to Treaty of Versailles The Treaty of Versailles contributed to Hitler's rise by being the most hated treaty ever brought about. The Treaty ruined any chance of Germany regaining dignity after World War One. The German people didn't believe they had lost the war or should be blamed for the war, so when the Treaty gave them a term they had to agree with e.g. You must take the blame for starting the war, they felt the terms were unfair. Also what was unfair the German's were not there when the terms where drawn up, so this made them unhappy but they also felt the terms were hypocritical and unjust.... [tags: Papers]
1088 words (3.1 pages)
- The Most Important Aim of the Foreign Policy 1933-36 was to Overthrow the Treaty of Versailles The Weimar Republic was declared on 9th November 1918, although its first elections were on the 19th January of 1919 out of the defeat of the First World War and lasted until Hitler abused Article 48 of the Weimar constitution in 1933 to turn Germany into a totalitarian state. The republic faced unpopularity right from the beginning. In June 1919, the German delegates were forced to sign the humiliating treaty of Versailles in which Germany was forced to accept full responsibility for the First World War (Article 231) and to pay ?6.6 billion in reparation because they could... [tags: Papers]
535 words (1.5 pages)
Analysis of the Part Played by the Land Fronts Other than the Western Front in the Allies' Victory in World War
- Analysis of the Part Played by the Land Fronts Other than the Western Front in the Allies' Victory in World War There were two main alliances in World War One. These were the Triple Alliance consisting of Italy, Austria Hungry and Germany and the Triple Entente, which consisted of Britain, France and Russia. This gave Germany a huge problem as three powerful enemies surrounded them. In order to try and avoid this Germany made some assumptions and put forward a plan, the Schlieffen plan.... [tags: Papers]
438 words (1.3 pages)
- The time period was the early Twentieth century. The first war of the world has been raging for nearly two and a half years. The United States was fresh off the Spanish-American War and the Philippine–American War. Looking to settle down and get back to normalcy, the American people had had enough. The last thing they were out looking for was ways to get involved in another. That attitude is what Incumbent President Woodrow Wilson ran his campaign on. And is exactly what got him in office. Although it was a close race, Wilson would edge out his Republican counterpart Charles Hughes by three percentage points in the popular vote and by twenty three electoral votes.... [tags: World War I, Woodrow Wilson, Treaty of Versailles]
1311 words (3.7 pages)
- Ryder argues ‘the shock of defeat [in the First World War] caused the collapse of the Hohenzollern regime, which hitherto had appeared almost impregnable. The collapse made the German revolution possible’ as it placed Germany into an isolated position lasting until the signing of the peace treaty. The collapse of the German empire was not as inevitable as that of Russia or Austria-Hungary; nationalism was not as serious a problem, with ninety two percent of citizens speaking German as of the 1900 census and a strong economy following rapid industrialisation in the 1850s.... [tags: World War I, German Empire, Austria–Hungary]
1215 words (3.5 pages)