A Comparison of Two Film Adaptations of Hamlet Essay

A Comparison of Two Film Adaptations of Hamlet Essay

Length: 749 words (2.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Good Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

"I was raped," the girl said to me overtaken with tears. I was taken by surprise and was at a complete loss for words. She had just taken one of the darkest secrets of her life and brought it out to the splendid light for just me to gaze upon. A little apprehensive, I responded, "I'm sorry." What is one to say at the revelation of such a horrid thing? Anything else I thought of saying sounded stupid and insensitive, so I opted for silence and hugged her to comfort her to the best of my ability. A few months later the girl came to me and thanked me. She said that my gesture meant more to her than anything anyone else had said about the rape. I then realized that sometimes, if not most of the time, actions can speak louder than words. The parts of us that are less vocal, such as our clothing, gestures, facial expressions, etc. can be more impacting than words.

Shakespeare's Hamlet has been adopted to the screen many times, each with its own interpretation of the dialogue. The directors Kenneth Branagh and Michael Almereyda both bring the words of Shakespeare to life with vivid and original settings, costumes, and personalities. Of course they both attempt to convey different moods and tones. Branagh's on-screen version is very traditional as it is set in the 1800's and every word of Shakespeare's is included verbatim. On the other hand, Almereyda presents the world a completely modern version of the famous play complete with cell phones, laptops, guns, and your mundane company take-over!

Both use the words of Shakespeare but are strikingly distinct due to rendition of the words and the environment which provides a different feel.

The setting of Kenneth Branagh's Hamlet is winter and all is blue and carries a feel of eer...

... middle of paper ...

...ative sense the movie carries about.

As these movies show, the behavior, tone of voice, and clothing are really what gives presence to a film and not necessarily just the words. The words of Shakespeare, while very poetic and beautiful, are dead without the emotion of an actor. The acting of the characters in Hamlet is what gave animation to the cinematic versions of Hamlet and that clearly shows that actions can be much stronger than just mere words.

Works Cited

Ebert, Roger. Review of Branagh's Hamlet. Writing and Reading Across the Curriculum, Eight Edition. Eds. Laurence Behrens, Leanard F. Rosen. Boston: Longman. 787-790

Marshall, Alexandra. Review of Almereyda's Hamlet: The Prince is Dead, Long Live the Prince. Writing and Reading Across the Curriculum, Eight Edition. Eds. Laurence Behrens, Leanard F. Rosen. Boston: Longman. 829-832

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Movie Essays - Oedipal Hamlet in Film

- Oedipal Hamlet on Film        It has commonly been suggested by such disciples of Sigmund Freud as Ernest Jones that Shakespeare's character of Hamlet is the victim of an Oedipus complex. While any reading of the play Hamlet, Prince of Denmark that focuses on the text and not the psychoanalytical fads of the current age disproves any notion of Hamlet's oedipal nature, many film artists have followed popular psychology and have adopted this theory for the screen. Whether out of precedent, pressure, or some need to discover some complex in Hamlet, this has become a very popular trend for filmmakers....   [tags: Movie Film comparison compare contrast]

Good Essays
1715 words (4.9 pages)

Essay on Shakespearean Adaptations for Children

- Undeniably, the works of William Shakespeare have inspired contemporary adaptations that can appeal to audiences who have never read the Bard’s plays. But how appropriate is it to present to children, who lack the life experience and maturity to understand the depth of the works, the dark side of Shakespeare—the death of Juliet, the seductive nature of Caliban in The Tempest, and the violent struggles in Hamlet. There is no simple answer. In appropriating Shakespeare's works for young audiences, producers often alter elements that are deemed inappropriate for children—namely death, sex, and violence—but nonetheless play significant roles in the plays....   [tags: Appropriation, Original Significance]

Good Essays
890 words (2.5 pages)

Compare and Contrast: Two Film Adaptations of Macbeth Essay

- April, 2 2014 Perspectives As far as we’re aware, Shakespeare wrote Macbeth in 1606, making it roughly 400 years old and in desperate need of a revival. While setting an adaptation of the play in modern day Melbourne in the midst of a gangland war may have seemed comical a decade ago, with corpses piled high from St Kilda to Sunshine in the real gang war of the Victorian city, it now seems 100% plausible. The difficulty of course, is finding a way to accurately transform noble lords of Scotland into underworld gangsters and still maintain Shakespeare’s true intentions....   [tags: Shakespeare, Play, Adaptations]

Good Essays
1398 words (4 pages)

Essay on Comparison Between The Film And The Book Frankenstein

- Frankenstein is a fictional story written by Mary Shelly. It was later adapted into a movie version directed by James Whales. There are more differences than similarities between the book and the movie. This is because, the movie is mainly based on the 1920’s play, other than the original Mary Shelly’s book Frankenstein. A text has to be altered in one way or the other while making a movie due to a number of obvious factors. A lot of details from the book were missing in the movie, but the changes made by Whales were effective as they made the movie interesting, and successful....   [tags: adaptations, monster, human]

Good Essays
746 words (2.1 pages)

Essay on The Mad Trapper: Film and Book Adaptations

- This paper seeks to show the comparison and the scrutiny of “"The Mad Trapper"” as a novel and its adaptation as a film. Both as a book and as a film it provides a good fiction which attracts an affluent legacy of folks, fables and myths. Rudy Wiebe’s recent novel The Mad Trapper (1980), the legend, presents a basis for the frame. Further than any distress with chronological events, the writer categorically depicts legendary dimensions to intertwine his fiction into conflict. Weibe’s argument, nevertheless, is not merely involving thermo and Albert Johnson; his contention lies amid the impending desires of self independence and reliability and the problem of multifaceted and distant progres...   [tags: Movie and Story Analysis, Summary]

Good Essays
873 words (2.5 pages)

Essay about A Comparison of the Revenge of Fortinbras and Hamlet

- In Hamlet, Shakespeare introduces us to Fortinbras and Hamlet. Both characters are bent on avenging the death of their fathers who were murdered. In Act I, two different revenge plots by these two men are revealed, and while Fortinbras is very open and bold about killing Claudius, Hamlet is sly and quiet about his plan. Fortinbras is also dead set on attacking Denmark no matter what but Hamlet is indecisive about killing Claudius. Fortinbras plans to lead an army to attack Denmark while Hamlet’s plan of attack is to act crazy....   [tags: Hamlet Essays]

Good Essays
908 words (2.6 pages)

Comparison of Ethan Hawke and Kenneth Branagh's Versions of Hamlet Essay

- Comparison of Ethan Hawke and Kenneth Branagh's Versions of Hamlet Modern day directors use a variety of methods to hold ones interest. Ethan Hawke and Kenneth Branagh’s created versions of Hamlet that shared some similarities, but ultimately had many differences in respects to an audience’s appeal. An appealing movie is one that has an alluring ambiance and an intellectual stimulus. With these two movie versions, a setting and a mood forced an audience to acquire specific emotions, but Ethan Hawke’s version generated emotions more strongly and effectively....   [tags: Directors Hamlet Movies Film Essays]

Good Essays
1045 words (3 pages)

Essay on Franco Zefferelli's film Hamlet

- Franco Zefferelli's film Hamlet Franco Zefferelli’s film, Hamlet, adapted from Shakespeare’s text, Mel Gibson’s Hamlet, struts and frets his life in Denmark, convincing almost everyone that he is “mad.” The film bases the question of whether or not Hamlet is actually insane almost solely on Gibson’s acting interpretations, but Zefferelli’s editing choices assist in making the point that Hamlet is not insane, but either in a fog of confusion and anger from his grief, or pretending to be mad to manipulate others....   [tags: Film Movie Hamlet Zefferelli Essays]

Good Essays
949 words (2.7 pages)

Hamlet Film Response Essay

- Hamlet, one of the most intricate and influential plays by Shakespeare, debatably of all time. It has inspired not only appreciative readers and writing critiques but continuous generations of people. The inspiration led to the fabrication of many great movies, which wasn’t achievable until the 20th century. Before cinema was the prevalent method of sharing appreciation and spilling emotion for a specific subject, art portrayed what would fly through our minds such as the many interpretations of Ophelia’s death....   [tags: Film Review]

Good Essays
1225 words (3.5 pages)

A Comparison of Olivier and Branagh's Adaptations of Henry V Essay

- A Comparison of Olivier and Branagh's Adaptations of Henry V Media Comparative Essay: (in the medium of film) concerning the 2 well known film versions of Shakespeare’s Henry V of Olivier (1944) and Branagh (1989) in the specific scenes of “A Little Touch of Harry in the Night” and “The Crispin Crispian Speech” A comparison of these scenes in the two film versions of Henry V indicated above in a discussion of all the major cinematic issues in integrating a story like Shakespeare’s and to include some discussion of the relative success in conveying to a cinema audience the director’s message....   [tags: Papers]

Good Essays
2702 words (7.7 pages)