The Stem Cell Debate is Not About Medical Benefits Essay

The Stem Cell Debate is Not About Medical Benefits Essay

Length: 2601 words (7.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In the final analysis, the debate about embryonic stem cell research is not primarily about medical benefits.

In his great novel The Brothers Karamazov, Dostoevsky raised the question whether it would be right to build a world without human suffering if "it was essential and inevitable to torture to death one tiny creature" such as an innocent child to achieve that end. Each of us must answer that ultimate question in the depths of his or her own conscience. The claim that destructive embryo research will achieve such a utopian end is, we believe, a hollow promise. In the meantime, however, the killing will be quite real.

We hope that you will consider these reflections and  agree that our government should not support research that relies on the destruction of innocent human beings.

Most Christians have grave concerns on this critically important issue of embryonic stem cell research. In our view, conducting research that relies on deliberate destruction of human embryos for their stem cells is illegal, immoral and unnecessary.

It is illegal because it violates an appropriations rider (the Dickey amendment) passed every year since 1995 by Congress. That provision forbids funding "research in which" human embryos (whether initially created for research purposes or not) are harmed or destroyed outside the womb.(1) National Institutes of Health guidelines approved by the Clinton Administration nonetheless give researchers detailed instructions on how to obtain human embryos for destructive cell harvesting, if they wish to qualify for federal grants in "human pluripotent stem cell research."(2) Clearly, obtaining and destroying embryos is an integral part of this project, even if the specific act of destroying emb...

... middle of paper ...

...eficiency (SCID)-X1 Disease," 288 Science 669-72 (28 April 2000).

16. K. Foss, "Paraplegic regains movement after cell procedure," The Globe and Mail (Toronto), June 15, 2001 at A1.

17. E. Ryan et al., "Glycemic Outcome Post Islet Transplantation," Abstract #33-LB, Annual Meeting of the American Diabetes Association, June 24, 2001. See:

18. M. McCullough, "Islet transplants offer hope that diabetes can be cured," Philadelphia Inquirer, June 22, 2001 at A1.

19. D. Woodbury et al., "Adult Rat and Human Bone Marrow Stromal Cells Differentiate Into Neurons," 61 J. of Neuroscience Research 364-70 (2000) at 364 (emphasis added).

20. D. Prockop, "Stem Cell Research Has Only Just Begun" (Letter), 293 Science 211-2 (13 July 2001)(citations omitted).

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on The Debate Over Stem Cell Research

- The Opposing Sides of Stem Cell Research No matter what one person says in favor of a topic, there will always be someone, somewhere who disagrees with them. Scientific research has had a fair share of debates over the course of its existence. For the most part, science has been questioned over the morality of certain research, but stem cell research has recently taken the brunt of the accusations over the moral status of the human embryos used. Whether a stem cell from an aborted human embryo is considered human life or not, people will continually argue that stem cells should not be used to modify the human genome even if it can create life-altering cures to complex diseases....   [tags: Stem cell, Embryonic stem cell]

Strong Essays
1989 words (5.7 pages)

Essay on The Debate Over Stem Cell Research

- In the world of medicine there are many different arguments and stances taken regarding the ethics behind medicine. Before medical physicians and others are able to actually work in the field they must take an oath to always remember the ethics that they are taught. Controversy comes up in many different subjects though. On major subject where controversy is prevalent is with stem cell research, both adult and embryonic. The two main sides taken on this topic are either for or against it. On both sides, there are well made arguments and much evidence to offer support....   [tags: Stem cell, Embryonic stem cell]

Strong Essays
1490 words (4.3 pages)

The Debate Over Stem Cell Research Essay

- Stem cell research has been one of the most controversial focuses in the biomedical community. A stem cell is an undifferentiated cell that can alter itself into a specialized cell which can replace many types of damaged cells. Nonetheless, there is only one cell that can replace any type of damaged cell, an embryonic stem cell. Fortunately, this method is already available in the medical world, but it is limited to permitting countries. Working with embryonic stem cells is also met heated debate, as the only way to extract the cells is from an embryo, ultimately ceasing potential human life....   [tags: Stem cell, Embryonic stem cell]

Strong Essays
1135 words (3.2 pages)

The Debate Over Stem Cell Research Essay

- The capacity of certain cells, known as stem cells, to self-regenerate and give rise to different kinds of specialised adult cell has been the subject of scientific and medical interest for decades. Stem cells can be found in many locations throughout the adult human body, allowing for tissue regeneration. Blood, for example, is constantly being renewed with new blood cells from stem cells in the bone marrow (Holland, Lebacqz and Zoloth, 2001). Most of these cells are multipotent - they can only give rise to certain types of cells....   [tags: Stem cell, Cellular differentiation]

Strong Essays
1570 words (4.5 pages)

Essay on The Debate Of Stem Cell Research

- The topic of stem cell research has been brought to the attention of the public recently by the video put out by the Center for Medical Progress claiming to expose the gruesome truth: that Planned Parenthood has been selling baby parts to make a profit on the side for years. This is a misrepresentation of what is going on, however, as in the entire interview, which was over 100 minutes of footage shortened to just a nine minute video, the representative for Planned Parenthood referred to the donation with full parental consent of the embryos that would otherwise be disposed of....   [tags: Stem cell, Embryonic stem cell]

Strong Essays
1279 words (3.7 pages)

The Debate Over Human Embryonic Stem Cell Research Essay

- On August 9th 2011, President George W. Bush stated his support for the federal funding of Human Embryonic Stem-Cell research (hESCR). This proposal evoked a heated debate questioning the morality of using human embryos for researching stem-cells. The potential results of this open-ended debate directly affects whether or not the government will financially support the research involved with human embryonic stem-cells. Those against hESCR argue that the destruction of the embryo during research is equivalent to taking the life of a fully developed human-being, while those supporting hESCR counterbalance the sacrifice of a group of cells with the benefits of the research done with them....   [tags: Stem cell, Embryonic stem cell, Cell]

Strong Essays
1427 words (4.1 pages)

The Debate Over Stem Cell Research Essay

- Human nature is to survive and get better, the instinct for parents to try to give their children a better chance at life is undeniable. What better way can parents do that then to try and put an end to chronic and life threatening diseases. This can happen if stem cell research continues to expand and becomes better funded. The benefits range from re-growing body parts to curing genetic disorders. Stem cell research has been a controversial topic from the start. Many people say it is wrong based on the facts that it can use embryonic stem cells....   [tags: Stem cell, Embryonic stem cell]

Strong Essays
2004 words (5.7 pages)

The Debate Over Stem Cell Therapy Essay

- Stem cell therapy has often been surrounded in controversy. Many view the issues of stem cell therapy and stem cell research as crimes against humanity and morally wrong; while others may feel the study of stem cells could be the next step in modern science. While the latter outlook comes from the progress made in treating or preventing many conditions or diseases the former, on the other hand, stems from the idea that stem cell research is unethical since it requires the destruction of embryos during their early stages of development....   [tags: Stem cell, Cellular differentiation]

Strong Essays
954 words (2.7 pages)

Stem Cell Research Needs to Be Funded Essay

- A mother has developed Alzheimer’s, preventing her from having a normal relationship with her family. A newly born baby girl has a spinal cord issue, making for many years of rehabilitation ahead her. A diabetic wife struggles to take care of her household duties because of constantly having to monitor her blood sugar and deal with insulin shots. With the development of stem cell research, and the more controversial embryonic stem cell research, every one of these instances could not only be cured, but prevented, within the next half century....   [tags: Stem Cell Research, medical,]

Strong Essays
1546 words (4.4 pages)

The Debate Over Embryonic Stem Cell Research Essay

- Stem cells were first discovered in the early 1900s and are unspecialized cells that have the potential to develop into a number of different cells in the body. They can treat a wide variety of diseases and ailments, from diabetes to ALS. Embryonic stem cell research, in particular, has been the main source of ethical and scientific controversy since they were first successfully cultured in a laboratory in 1998. Embryonic stem cells are derived from fertilized embryos, which are destroyed in the research process....   [tags: Stem cell, Embryonic stem cell, Human]

Strong Essays
1319 words (3.8 pages)