Heracles as a Paradox in Women of Trachis Essay

Heracles as a Paradox in Women of Trachis Essay

Length: 1546 words (4.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Heracles as a Paradox in Women of Trachis


Using the portrayal of Hercules in Sophocles' tragedy Women of Trachis, a puzzling image of the Greek hero emerges. Most of the myths of Heracles portray him as a fierce warrior, tamer of beasts and a master of everything he attempts. This myth however, shows honorable traits juxtaposed with very negative aspects of the same man. Heracles is a paradox because even though he is a very great man and ideal hero, in some ways he is savage, highly emotional and even vulnerable.

Sophocles' version of Heracles' life, or at least part of it, made Heracles look less like a Greek hero and more like an ordinary Greek warrior. There are a few exceptions though. For one, Zeus was his father. Not many of the children of gods were thought of as ordinary. All of them had some terrific power or ability like Hercules. Secondly, his ability to fulfill his assigned tasks in the way in which he does shows in no uncertain terms, he is more than a common man is. Lastly, Hercules is granted immortality as a reward for impressing the gods on Mount Olympus. This final item is of special importance because it itself is a paradox. Was Hercules a Greek hero or was he a God? These things all lead me to see Hercules the man clearly but his relationships to things outside his heroic motif are a puzzle.

Let us start by identifying the purpose of identifying Hercules as a hero. There are eight identifiable traits that must be present in order to declare somebody a Greek hero. The first point is divine birth. Hercules being a son of Zeus meets this requirement. He is threatened almost immediately by a jealous Hera but saved by his own strength and fearless valor. His up bringing was by an outsider, actually ...


... middle of paper ...


...ignity but Heracles refused to admit his end was coming. All the times he left for a task he went in search of fame but "not to die." (Sophocles, Women, l 159-60) Then why did he think to leave his will with Deianira? It was obvious the tablet described the way his land should be divided up amongst his children so why was he still not ready for his fate? It is because Heracles thought of himself as a hero and could not imagine the gods fate him to death.

All these contradicting sides of Heracles makes him a more interesting figure in ancient texts but they also create quite confusion. Why after all the evil, horrid things he did would the gods make him immortal? Heracles truly is a paradox.

Works Cited:

Sophocles. The Women of Trachis. Trans. Michael Jameson. Sophocles II. Ed. David Grene and Richmond Lattimore. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1957.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Paradox Of The Liar Paradox Essay example

- Traced all the way back to six centuries before christ, the Liar Paradox is an argument that arrives at a contradiction when assuming the principle of bivalence. The principle of bivalence states that a declarative statement must have only one truth value; the declarative statement is either true or false, not both (Bernecker). The classical liar paradox is composed of paradoxical statements, like: “This sentence is false,” and “L1 : L1 is false” (Bernecker). If the statement “L1 is false” is true, then “L1” is false, because the first premise says, “L1 is false” (Bernecker)....   [tags: Truth, Logic, Liar paradox, Paradox]

Powerful Essays
1497 words (4.3 pages)

Essay on Analysis Of The Movie ' Heracles Vs Hercules '

- Heracles VS Hercules The legend of Hercules has been told and retold thousands of times; it is by far one of the best known Greek myths of all time. In fact, it was so well known that Disney made it into a movie. Like any story that’s adapted into a movie there are some differences and similarities between the myth and the movie. This paper will go over the main differences and similarities between the two versions of the same myth. The first comparisons between mythology and the Disney film are ones pertaining to the nature of Hercules character....   [tags: Greek mythology, Zeus, Hero, Heracles]

Powerful Essays
903 words (2.6 pages)

Is Jason And Heracles The Worst Hero? Essay

- Final Exam Arveen Mayordomo CLAS 2520 D01 Student Number: 7695759 Although Jason and Heracles both accomplished amazing feats, the way they treated women would make them the worst heroes in Greece because they besmirched the sanctity of marriage and disrespected women. Jason abandoned Medea, who loved him and sacrificed many things for his success, and Heracles was unfaithful and defiled many women in Greece, using them for his own pleasure. Although Odysseus had an affair with two other women, he can still be considered the best hero as he treated women with respect and relentlessly attempted to return home to his wife in Ithaca....   [tags: Odyssey, Greek mythology, Odysseus, Hera]

Powerful Essays
1526 words (4.4 pages)

Steinbeck's Paradox and Dreams Essay

- The structure of the american paradox is complex. The dreams set through decades upon decades of generations have consumed the americans way of living. this paradox and dream is what we have come to not just base our entire lives around but build are morals, standards, and expectations for overall existence. “Paradox and Dream “ isn't like Steinbecks normal pieces of literature. Steinbeck's “Paradox and Dreams” is a sarcastic and criticism filled outlook on the self made paradox created by americans and based on their way of living....   [tags: American Paradox and Dreams]

Free Essays
1178 words (3.4 pages)

Essay on The Naked Men And The Paradox Of Sexual Freedom

- People have many expectations they are expected to fulfill by a lot of different people, but these standards are not always followed. People act as they want rather than by the principles set by others by doing so they are discovering their own identity. Identities define what kind of person we are to other people. Others can learn about one another by studying how someone performs. Performance is exemplified through our actions. The way we present our self to others is by performing to their expectations or going against them....   [tags: Woman, Expected value, Women, Expectation]

Powerful Essays
1683 words (4.8 pages)

Essay on The Humanization of Heracles

- Through recent human history, there have been many plays in different aspects of literature. In Greek Mythology, the myth of Heracles can be inspected as to whether he is a hero or a murderer. One Greek writer, Euripides, writes about the tragic story of Heracles. It is a story about tragedy, madness, humanization of a hero and psychological natures. The story explores the interplay between if Heracles is sane or insane, and how he falls from all his glory and emerges from the dark, ember ashes as a changed, humble man through the phenomenon of friendship....   [tags: Greek Mythology, Play Analysis, Literature]

Powerful Essays
861 words (2.5 pages)

Women 's Rights : Women And The Paradox Of Sexual Freedom By Leslie Bell

- Nowadays, more people tend to care about and work on social justice. Women’s rights, as one of the topics, draws people’s attention. The society and female-selves have rethought the meaning of being women in the 21st century. Therefore, nowadays twenty-something girls start to behave differently from early generation. One of the behaviors becomes ambiguous, which is female sexuality. In “Selections from Hard to Get: Twenty-Something Women and the Paradox of Sexual Freedom”, Leslie Bell argues that neither contradictory directing nor expectation from others is the main reason that causes female sexuality....   [tags: Woman, Female, Sexual intercourse, Want]

Powerful Essays
1357 words (3.9 pages)

The Destruction and Rebuilding of Heracles Essay

- The ancient Greeks were a civilization to whom respect was very important. They believed in serving guests no matter who they were; before even asking the guest their name, the host would clean their feet, offer them water and a place to rest. Strangers to a house are regarded with the utmost respect so a friendship to the Greeks would be a bond as strong as blood. In Euripides’ Heracles, Theseus poetically describes their friendship to Heracles in an attempt to pull him out of his distress. Friendship has a redemptive power that blood does not because family is expected to care for you....   [tags: Ancient Greeks, Civilixzation, History]

Powerful Essays
998 words (2.9 pages)

Marginal Utility: The Missing Link in the Diamond-Water Paradox Essay example

- Marginal Utility: The Missing Link in the Diamond-Water Paradox. American Heritage Dictionary describes a paradox as “a seemingly contradictory statement that may nonetheless be true”. I feel this definition applies to “The Diamond-Water Paradox”. Water is of immeasurable value to human survival, however it has virtually little or no monetary or trade value. While this seems to be a contradiction, it is in fact the absolute truth. On the other hand a diamond has no real value of use to mankind, however it is one of the most sought after and expensive items in the world....   [tags: Diamond-Water Paradox]

Free Essays
1196 words (3.4 pages)

Problems With Heracles Essays

- Problems With Heracles When we talk about something that is problematic, it is usually to do with time. Tales passed through time are often adapted for the societies to which they are being told. This could be in terms of added moral value or just generally adapted to suit the tastes of different cultures. Romans changed the name Heracles to ‘Hercules’ and altered some of his adventures, whereas in Greek the name ‘Heracles’ is often translated to mean ‘glory of Hera’....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
1198 words (3.4 pages)