Man's Relationship with Nature in Hughes and Wordsworth's Poetry Essay

Man's Relationship with Nature in Hughes and Wordsworth's Poetry Essay

Length: 1932 words (5.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Man's Relationship with Nature in Hughes and Wordsworth's Poetry

Concentrating on one Poem by each Poet, Compare and Contrast the ways
in which Hughes and Wordsworth Present Man’s Relationship with Nature

Both Hughes and Wordsworth have beliefs about man’s relationship with
nature, but I feel that they see the relationship between the two in
different ways. Hughes has a more pessimistic and negative approach,
feeling that nature must protect herself from man’s destructive
nature, while Wordsworth believes that nature is a teacher and
nurtures you. Wordsworth uses a more optimistic and positive approach
in his poetry. Wordsworth sees nature in a romantic and spiritual
sense that protects and is constantly feeding and inspiring man’s mind
and helping it to grow. On the other hand Hughes sees man as
interfering and destructive towards nature and is excluded from its
harmony. Hughes personality is much more complicated and hard to deal
with, so to speak, than Wordsworth’s; this is reflected in his
attitude towards nature because he thinks that nature is a violent and
brutal enemy towards man and even itself. From this you can tell that
he is quite a brooding and depressive man. I have chosen to compare
‘Work and Play’ by Hughes and by Wordsworth I have chosen
‘Expostulation and Reply’ and ‘The Tables Turned’ which are poems on
the same subject but ‘The Tables Turned’ is set later on in the day
and is the ‘Companion-Piece’ to ‘Expostulation and Reply’. I chose to
study these two poems because I think that it is very interesting how
the beliefs of Hughes and Wordsworth are presented, showing that they
both have an admiration for the beauty of nature and its power, and
how Hughes believes that in comparison m...

... middle of paper ...

... the relationship between man and
nature. This is because Wordsworth lived in a period in time that was
called the romantic era, this is reflected in his views and the ways
he writes as a poet. Whereas Hughes who lived in the 20th century, had
quite different views about man’s relationship with nature. I think
that this is because the period of time that you live in influences
you very heavily in the way you write or express anything. This is
because public attitudes change along with what is accepted and what
is not, or what the public will find most popular. I think that if
Hughes had lived in Wordsworth’s time his style of writing would not
have been as popular as it is today, this is because Hughes style of
writing has a more dramatic and dark edge to it whilst Wordsworth’s
poetry is more romantic so to speak and has a gentler way of putting

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

William Wordsworth 's Romanticism Of The Common Man And Nature Essay

- British poet, William Wordsworth exemplifies romanticism in his poems to portray his sympathy for the life, to depict the troubles and speech of the common man and to eradicate war. William Wordsworth lived through the French revolution, and this awakened his romanticism poems. Romanticism was a movement of the love of common man and nature. People valued love, nature, childhood and imagination extensively during this movement. William was one of the major british poets of his time that exemplified romanticism in his poems....   [tags: William Wordsworth, Romanticism, Romantic poetry]

Powerful Essays
1112 words (3.2 pages)

Nature Explored in the Poems of William Wordsworth Essay

- As time passes it is said that the human race becomes less aware of nature around them and more consumed with the things produced by man. The romantic poet William Wordsworth saw the cultural decline and as the literary critic Harold Bloom stated, “The fear of mortality haunts much of Wordsworth’s best poetry, especially in regard to the premature mortality of the imagination and the loss of creative joy.” This statement greatly reflects the views of Wordsworth, whose poetry conveys the warning of a man asking those enveloped in the world to step back and recognize the beauty and miracles of nature....   [tags: literary analysis, william wordsworth]

Powerful Essays
1347 words (3.8 pages)

Relationship Between Literature And The Environment Essay

- The relationship between literature and the environment is known as ecocriticism. This relationship, however, is symbiotic. This means that only one side is being benefited. In this case, the environment is at a disadvantage. Ecocritics turn away from social constructivism, but it would seem that nature is a social construct. It is a symbol that is given power and meaning by those who create it. Literature is also a man-made concept. My aim in this paper is to critique two poems (Leslie Marmon Silko’s “Where Mountain Lion Lay Down with Deer”, and Ted Hughes’ “Hawk Roosting”) through an ecocriticism viewpoint, and try to answer the question, is there any true environment left....   [tags: Natural environment, Nature, Human, Ecology]

Powerful Essays
1086 words (3.1 pages)

The Nature Of William Wordsworth Essay

- The Nature of William Wordsworth William Wordsworth’s contributions to literature have been instrumental to the development of what poetry is today. One of his most popular contributions was a poem in the Lyrical Ballads called “I Wandered Lonely as a Cloud”. This poem embodied the spirit of the Romantic Era. While many draw different thoughts and images when reading this poem, there is an underlying tone when describing nature. Analyzing the stanzas will unveil the true spiritual intent and beauty of the poem....   [tags: Romanticism, William Wordsworth, Poetry]

Powerful Essays
941 words (2.7 pages)

Law of Nature - Wordsworth Essay

- Nature is freedom, it knows no boundaries. Bronislaw Malinowski wrote, "Freedom is a symbol which stands for a sublime and powerful ideal.” The state of nature is a term in political philosophy that describes a circumstance prior to the state and society's establishment. John Locke, whose work influenced the American Declaration of Independence, believes that the state of nature is the state where are individuals are completely equal, natural law regulates, and every human being has the executive power of the natural law....   [tags: William Wordsworth]

Powerful Essays
508 words (1.5 pages)

Comparison of the Portrayal of Nature in Blake and Wordsworth Essay

- Comparison of the Portrayal of Nature in Blake and Wordsworth One of the most popular themes for Romantic poetry in England was nature and an appreciation for natural beauty. The English Romantic poets were generally concerned with the human imagination as a counter to the rise of science. The growing intellectual movement of the 18th and 19th centuries placed scientific thought in the forefront of all knowledge, basing reality in material objects. The Romantics found this form of world view to be restrictive....   [tags: Poetry Compare Contrast Blake Wordsworth Essays]

Powerful Essays
1525 words (4.4 pages)


- COMPARE AND CONTRAST THE WAY WORDSWORTH AND HUGHES WRITE ABOUT NATURE IN THEIR POEMS DAFFODILS AND THISTLES Hughes wrote the poem “Thistles” which is about how these plants are. He speaks about them as if they were a sign of violence, and violent creatures. He views them as a symbol of vengeance, pain and threat. The thistles are spiky and can hurt anyone. They are dull, immortal, green, rough, and produce a big amount of chaos, written in???????. Wordsworth on the other hand, wrote about “Daffodils” which are small golden flowers....   [tags: English Literature]

Powerful Essays
893 words (2.6 pages)

Radcliffe and Wordsworth: Nature, Travel, and Memory Essay

- Radcliffe and Wordsworth: Nature, Travel, and Memory In preparation for my presentation on the character of M. St. Aubert in Radcliffe's The Mysteries of Udolpho, I examined various passages from the novel's first few chapters which described St. Aubert's responses to nature in terms of the picturesque, the sublime, and sensibility. One passage which especially attracted my attention, but which ultimately fell outside the coverage of our group's presentation, is Radcliffe's account of St. Aubert's feelings about the "small estate in Gascony" (Radcliffe 6) where he and his family lived: To this spot he had been attached from his infancy....   [tags: Traveling Wordsworth Radcliffe Essays Papers]

Powerful Essays
1272 words (3.6 pages)

Wordsworth and Vaughan Essay

- Wordsworth and Vaughan When reading T.S. Eliot’s critical comment, “It is to be observed that the language of these poets is as a rule simple and pure,” one might assume that he was referring to the Romantics (Eliot 2328). Specifically, we could apply this statement to poets the ilk of Wordsworth, who eschewed poetic affectations and “tricked out” language for sentiments that originated and flowed naturally (Wordsworth 270). Yet Eliot hadn’t focused his critical eye there, this time. Rather, he squinted a century back to a lesser-referenced literary group, the Metaphysical poets (Eliot 2328)....   [tags: Poetry Wordsworth Vaughan Essays]

Powerful Essays
2062 words (5.9 pages)

William Wordsworth Essay

- William Wordsworth William Wordsworth was born April 7, 1770, at Cockermouth in Cumberland, England. His poetry, and especially his poems on solitude, must have been heavily influenced by the death of his mother and the splitting up of his family when he was only eight (Kilvert 1). At that time, fate sent him to live in Hawkshead, England, where his teacher started him writing poetry. Wordsworth got his higher education at Cambridge, his memories of which play a part in his later poetry (Noyes 201)....   [tags: Poet Poetry Wordsworth Papers]

Powerful Essays
1186 words (3.4 pages)