Comparing two poems - Binsey Poplar by Hopkins and I wandered lonely Essay

Comparing two poems - Binsey Poplar by Hopkins and I wandered lonely Essay

Length: 937 words (2.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Comparing two poems - Binsey Poplar by Hopkins and I wandered lonely
as a cloud' by Wordsworth.

Compare the two poems and comment on:

- The overall feelings of the poem

- How they use language effectively

- What the poems suggest about the characters of the authors.

The two poems 'Binsey Poplars' by Hopkins and 'I wandered lonely as a
cloud' by Wordsworth both contain very strong, emotive feelings.
However, the feelings that they contain are very different.

The 'Binsey Poplars' poem has an overall feeling of anger. Hopkins is
openly enraged by the removal of the trees which is clearly seen in
the poem as it stresses the sudden shock that Hopkins experiences as
he sees his trees have gone. There is also a great feeling of sadness
as Hopkinshas clearly lost something he cared for.

'My aspens dear'

The opening word of 'my' tells us that Hopkins thinks of the trees as
his own which show his care for them and the attention he must have
given them. They were clearly very important to him which explains his
protectiveness over them and also why he used the 'my' and 'dear.

On the other hand, the Wordsworth poem is more joyful. It has an
overall feeling of happiness which is seen from the word 'dance'. This
word is repeated in every stanza of the poem to continually remind the
reader of the joyous feeling throughout the poem. The poem also comes
across as carefree which can be seen by the description of the
jubilant mood the author is in:

'on my couch I lie in a vacant or in pensive mood'

Wordsworth writes that he 'lies' on his couch it immediately shows the
calm and peaceful state he is in. There is then confirmation on his
carefree state of mind when he describes himself in a 'vacant or ...

... middle of paper ...

...rates the number of plants as well
as the fact that the daffodils are 'stretched in never-ending line'

The 'Binsey Poplars' poem contains a lot of anger and rage, this
reflects on the author, Hopkins. So, from this poem we can see that
the character of Hopkins can be very hot-tempered and vengeful.
However, the fact that he acted in this outraged fashion means that he
cared for the trees very much and therefore we see a loving and caring
side to Hopkins. On the other hand, Wordsworth does not show any anger
in his poem but only positive feelings such as happiness and elation.

In conclusion, we can see that the two poems differ greatly in the
feelings they project through mood and literacy devices. However, the
poems do have one thing in common in that they both portray the same
sentient of concern over plants that the authors clearly care a lot

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

A Comparison of The Poplar Field by William Cowper and Binsey Poplars Felled 1879 by Gerard Manley Hopkins

- A Comparison of The Poplar Field by William Cowper and Binsey Poplars Felled 1879 by Gerard Manley Hopkins The first thing that is noticeable is that both the poems are about a group of trees alongside a river. The other general similarity between the poems is that they are then later cut down and so the writers are now deprived of their enjoyment in the "cool colonnade". However there are many differences between the poems. Firstly we notice that Hopkins uses far more complex rhyming schemes to capture the reader....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
906 words (2.6 pages)

Carrion Comfort by Gerard Manley Hopkins Essay

- Carrion Comfort by Gerard Manley Hopkins Gerard Manley Hopkins was a talented poet, and he was also extremely devoted to his faith. He used his poetry as an avenue in which to express his love and praise to his Creator, and many of his poems are beautiful hymns of adoration. “Carrion Comfort,” however, is one of his “terrible sonnets.” Hopkins not only wrote about the beautiful part of faith, but also the questioning and suffering that inevitably comes during a person’s spiritual journey. The Petrarchan or Italian sonnet was one of Hopkins’s favorite forms of poetry and one that he employed frequently in his writing....   [tags: Carrion Comfort Hopkins Essays]

Better Essays
3427 words (9.8 pages)

Essay about Poem Structure of God's Grandeur by Hopkins

- Poem Structure of "God's Grandeur" by Hopkins "God's Grandeur" is one of the few poems written by Hopkins during his service as a Roman Catholic priest. The poem shows Hopkins' love towards God and his love of sound. "God's Grandeur" is a sonnet that contains three quatrains and a couplet. This sonnet is reminiscent of the Italian sonnet in that it contains one octave and one sestet. In "God's Grandeur", the octet describes the way in which humans are destroying the world by not attending to the greatness that surrounds them....   [tags: Poetry God's Grandeur Hopkins Essays Poet]

Better Essays
787 words (2.2 pages)

Compare and Contrast of‘‘Binsey Poplars’’ by Gerard Manley Hopkins and ‘‘The Trees’’ by Philip Larkin

- Choose two of the poems given in the handout . Compare and contrast these two poems (‘‘Binsey Poplars’’ by Gerard Manley Hopkins and ‘‘The Trees’’ by Philip Larkin), paying close attention to their language and form. In a recent article in The Guardian, Billy Mills writes, ‘Trees have been putting down roots in poetry for centuries’, and indeed there are as many poems about trees as there are species of trees themselves. As someone who grew up surrounded by trees and as a lover of poetry, it was a natural choice for me to use this assignment to explore two poems that are ostensibly about trees; Philip Larkin’s ‘The Trees’ and G.M....   [tags: Life, Hope, Patterns]

Better Essays
1714 words (4.9 pages)

Essay on Victorian Poetry: Rosetti and Hopkins

- The themes present in both “Goblin Market” by Rossetti and “Spring and Fall” by Hopkins are rife with seeming contradictions of audience. In both works, the author ostensibly addresses issues typically found in a children's poem, however under the surface there are other elements in play which give the reader reason to examine the overt themes in a light more befitting something much deeper than a poem written specifically for children. In examining both works through the lens thus described it will be possible to draw ties between the two works which otherwise may not have been easily connected, as well as tease apart the hidden meaning in both works from the overt message presented at the...   [tags: literary analysis]

Better Essays
1668 words (4.8 pages)

Essay about God’s Grandeur by Gerard Manly Hopkins

- “God’s Grandeur” by Gerard Manly Hopkins As a Jesuit priest, Gerard Manly Hopkins devoted many years of his life to spiritual study and instruction. As seen in his poem “God’s Grandeur”, Hopkins translated his intense spirituality into poems that explore the relationship between humans and the natural world as an expression of God’s divinity. In the poem, Hopkins presents the Victorian fixation on progress and change not as an improvement, but rather as a regression from a constructive communion with God’s glory as found in the natural world....   [tags: Gerard Hopkins God's Grandeur Essays]

Better Essays
1365 words (3.9 pages)

The Anglo-Saxon poems, The Wanderer, The Seafarer, and The Wife’s Lament

- The Anglo-Saxon poems, “The Wanderer,” “The Seafarer,” and “The Wife’s Lament” The Old English, or Anglo-Saxon, era of England lasted from about 450-1066 A.D. The tribes from Germany that conquered Britain in the fifth century carried with them both the Old English language and a detailed poetic tradition. The tradition included alliteration, stressed and unstressed syllables, but more importantly, the poetry was usually mournful, reflecting on suffering and loss.1These sorrowful poems from the Anglo Saxon time period are mimetic to the Anglo-Saxons themselves; they reflect the often burdened and miserable lives and times of the people who created them....   [tags: Wanderer Essays]

Better Essays
3461 words (9.9 pages)

Life's Simple Pleasures in William Wordsworth's I Wandered Lonely as a Cloud

- Life's Simple Pleasures in William Wordsworth's I Wandered Lonely as a Cloud Edna St. Vincent Millay once wrote, "And all the loveliest things there be come simply, so it seems to me." This aphorism clearly accents the meaning of William Wordsworth's poem "I Wandered Lonely as a Cloud." In his work, the speaker reminisces about a past experience in which he saw a beautiful multitude of daffodils swaying in the breeze. As he recollects this scene, the speaker gradually realizes the true beauty he had found that day....   [tags: Wandered Lonely as a Cloud]

Better Essays
1922 words (5.5 pages)

A Rhetorical Analysis of Lockdown by Evans D. Hopkins Essay

- A Rhetorical Analysis of Lockdown by Evans D. Hopkins According to the Webster Dictionary, rhetoric is defined as the art of speaking or writing effectively. Rhetoric is made up of three separate appeals that can be used individually or collectively in an attempt to persuade a reader. Ethos is the credibility and qualifications of the speaker or author. Pathos is the author's use of emotions and sympathy to urge the audience to agree with his or her standpoint. And lastly, logos is applying sound reasoning (logic) to attract the typical ideas of the audience and to prove the author's point of view....   [tags: Hopkins Lockdown Analysis]

Better Essays
1085 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on Poems

- Poems Change Certain things vary everyday, tides lap various portions of sandy gold and land is illuminated and darkened with clock like accuracy. Like cammilions, hills and land periodically display their transient colors with no regard to its inhabitants needs, preferences or even life. Everyday change, insignificant, expected and unshoking when it occurs, no emotional distress or even flickers of eye lids. Those firecrackers of life, however, sting with flaming relentless pain as if being attached by legions of jelly fish intent on wreaking havoc....   [tags: Poems]

Free Essays
456 words (1.3 pages)