Compare and Contrast Remember and A Birthday by Christina Rossetti Essay

Compare and Contrast Remember and A Birthday by Christina Rossetti Essay

Length: 1905 words (5.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Compare and Contrast Remember and A Birthday by Christina Rossetti

Christina Rossetti was born in Victorian England and grew up in the
pre-Raphaelite era. Coming from a well educated family she drew
influence for her poems from her surroundings and experiences. In ‘A
Birthday’, she looks at the celebration of finding new love. She is
overjoyed because her love is reciprocated and wants to make a new
beginning with this man spending the rest of her life with him raising
a family. A Birthday is filled with joy, happiness and anticipation of
what life will be like with her new love. Whereas ‘Remember’ is very
different; she must prepare her lifelong lover/husband for her death.
The tone of joy is therefore replaced by a much sadder tone reflecting
her struggle and unhappiness.

Both poems are carefully structured. ‘A birthday’ is written in two
verses. The first verse contains three similes and a comparative and
the second uses three imperatives (raise me, carve it, work it) and in
the final lines of both verses the reason for the joy and making of
the room are given. Whereas ‘Remember’ is a petrarchan sonnet. It
consists of many short phrases and gentle words which further
illustrates the feeling of tiredness. The punctuation and lines mirror
her difficulties to speak throughout the poem.

In ‘A Birthday’ repletion of the phrase ‘my heart’ is used, this is to
illustrate the feelings in her heart of joy, happiness and excitement
that her love has been reciprocated by the one she loves. It gives the
idea that her heart is the most important thing at this moment and it
is affecting the actions of the rest of her body. In contrast in
‘Remember’ the word ‘remember’ is repeated to emphasise the idea that
when...


... middle of paper ...


...ws at first he will spend every moment thinking and grieving for
her but with the gradual progression of time he may forget her from
time to time; and for this he ma feel guilty. She is thinking ahead to
the time when he won’t think of her in the natural flow of time which
is imperceptible to him. The fact he has now accepted she is going to
die she can give him instructions and talk about death and the grave
in a real way. Such as the idea of darkness in the grave and how the
body will decompose. She asks him to hold her in his heart and record
her in his everlasting memories this compares with the idea of
responsibility that comes with love which is described in ‘A
Birthday’. She finally reassure him that if he does forget her he
won’t be a traitor to her because she wants him to be happy and
doesn’t want her death to be the end of his happiness forever.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Christina Rossetti’s "A Birthday" Essay

- Christina Rossetti’s A Birthday, is a poem that express the trials a woman goes through during a relationship. This poem relates to women who resemble the same experience. Searching for true love and encountering relationships are few of the reasons why Rossetti writes this poem (The Life of Christina Rossetti). In the poem, there are words that show her feelings about her life now that she has found her true love (A Reading of A Birthday). At the end of the poem, she is capable of celebrating her happiness because her heart is restored....   [tags: Poetic Themes]

Powerful Essays
1116 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on The Day I forgot My Birthday

- It was a beautiful sunny morning; you could hear the birds singing in the background. I just woke up after a long sleep. It was now 11am and everyone was awake whizzing all around the house and I wondered what all the havoc was about. I came across my mum and asked, “What was going on”. I got no reply. It was like my mum didn’t even see me if I was invisible. After that I could not be bothered to ask because it looked like another busy Sunday morning. Later on the day I was getting bored and nothing was on the skinny TV of ours....   [tags: birthday,]

Powerful Essays
723 words (2.1 pages)

Essay on Creation Described in Pied Beauty and A Birthday

- ‘Pied Beauty’ and ‘A Birthday’ are two poems that explore creation through the author’s portrayal of creation. Hopkins is a religious man, who sees things as God’s creations and its inner and outer beauty, where as Rossetti sees creation as life and love, and how they affect her. Hopkins appreciates and bows down to God for all of His beautiful and striking creations that God has spread all over the world. It is as if he is depicting God as an artist and His creations as a painted canvas board on which he can draw beauty and simple things....   [tags: Gerard Hopkins and Christina Rossetti]

Powerful Essays
817 words (2.3 pages)

Essay about Shopping for Birthday Sheds

- All I wanted for my birthday was two brand new plastic storage sheds. One was needed for the yard tools and one for the kids' outdoor toys. I figured it would be safer to store them separately, because I did not really want the children poking around hedge clippers and hatchets just to find a toy. My husband came through and got me the sheds I wanted. I made it a game for the kids to put the toys away: They would open the door and try to throw the toys in from different points in the yard. That works well as long as they remember to shut the door....   [tags: Birthdays, ]

Powerful Essays
744 words (2.1 pages)

Essay about Comparison of Remember and Sonnet

- Comparison of Remember and Sonnet Many parallels can be drawn between 'Remember' by Christina Rossetti and 'Sonnet' by Elizabeth Barrett Browning, however at the same time there are distinct contrasts apparent. The title 'Sonnet' -or often commonly known as 'How do I love thee'- obviously introduces the piece in sonnet form. A sonnet is a fourteen-line poem in iambic pentameter with a carefully patterned rhyme scheme. The Italian or Petrarchan sonnet, named after Francesco Petrarch, an Italian poet from the thirteenth century was introduced into English poetry in the early sixteenth century and has been widely used ever since....   [tags: Christina Rossetti Elizabeth Browning Essays]

Powerful Essays
3208 words (9.2 pages)

Christina Rossetti's Goblin Market Essay

- Christina Rossetti's Goblin Market One of the strongest emotions inherent in us as humans is desire. The majority of the time, we are unable to control what we crave; however, with practice, we learn not all things we want are necessary. As a result of this mature understanding, we are able to ease our feelings and sometimes even suppress our desires. Something even more mature is understanding that when we give in to our desires, we become vulnerable. In a harsh, brutal world, vulnerability will not work to our advantage....   [tags: Christina Rossetti Goblin market Essays]

Powerful Essays
1672 words (4.8 pages)

Happy Birthday Chase Essay

- Happy Birthday Chase Life moves by quickly, but from the start of life to the end there are a special days where you celebrate the day of your birth. There are also particular birthdays that you show more special interest to than others. Some of which being, when you finally become a teenager, turning sixteen so you're finally able to drive, turning eighteen signifies you as an adult, turning twenty-one means you can buy alcohol, and if you're lucky enough turning a hundred means you've lived to be just plain old....   [tags: Descriptive Personal Narrative Birthday]

Free Essays
830 words (2.4 pages)

Themes Presented in Goblin Market by Christina Rossetti Essay

- Themes Presented in Goblin Market by Christina Rossetti Christina Rossetti's used her poetry to express herself; her work exhibits many autobiographical elements and from it the reader can discern Rossetti's emotions, beliefs and her comments on the society she lived in. As a female poet it would have been improper for Rossetti to deal directly with these issues though and so her ideas are masked through appearing to be children's poetry and having simple meanings. 'Goblin Market' superficially appears to a moral story about two sisters one of whom gives way to the temptation of the goblins forbidden fruits but through her poetic techniques Rossetti manages to embody her fears and desires....   [tags: Goblin Market Christina Rossetti Essays]

Powerful Essays
1177 words (3.4 pages)

A Walk to Remember - The Human Heart Essay

- A Walk to Remember - The Human Heart A Walk to Remember, by Nicholas Sparks take you on a whirl wind journey into the depths of the human heart, and leads Landon, one of the main characters, to a decision so stunning it would lead him irrevocably on the  road to manhood. Landon the most popular boy in Beuford High and fall's > unexpectedly in love with Jamie, and unpopular, bible-bearing girl. It was  kismet that brought these two together, and an incurable disease that would  tear them apart....   [tags: Walk to Remember Essays]

Free Essays
686 words (2 pages)

Essay on Remember by Rossetti

- Remember by Rossetti The opening two lines of Rossetti’s sonnet "Remember" introduce the idea of separation, but whether the speaker’s eminent departure is because she has chosen to leave her lover or because she is dying is not immediately clear. As the poem unfolds, the reader understands that death will divide the couple, and the initial hint of that is the phrase "silent land" to describe the place the speaker is going. The words seem to define a cemetery or individual grave more than heaven, and "silent," in particular, implies a dormant state—an existence and a place that are neither joyous nor painful, pleasant nor sad....   [tags: Remember Rossetti Sonnets Love Essays]

Powerful Essays
490 words (1.4 pages)