On her way to work, a nurse is assaulted while racial slurs are yelled at her. The same route that she has taken to work for the last ten years without a problem, now leads her to violence (Hornblower36). Instances of discrimination and racism such as this one, have increased since the passing of Proposition 187 in California. For years, the border states of this nation have faced a steady increase in the costs they are forced to pay for providing benefits to illegal immigrants. California alone is home to over half of the nation's illegal immigrants. This has cost the state close to $2 billion every year in education and $400 million in emergency medical services (DeGeorge34). The extreme burden this placed on the state and local governments is what led to Proposition 187. It is obvious that some sort of action must be taken to control the problem of illegal immigrants. However, creating initiatives such as Proposition 187 that deny all state-funded benefits to illegal immigrants, save emergency medical services, may not be the answer. The state-funded benefits that illegals have been receiving should not be denied because it does more harm than good. What this plan of action does has a negative effect on the medical community, punishes the helpless children, and spurs discrimination.
Although the states and local governments that deal heavily with illegal immigrants have a huge economic burden, it could be alleviated without the use of a proposition such as this one. This burden is on the states and local governments because of federal policies. The federal government could take some responsibility for this national problem and grant more funding to the s...
... middle of paper ...
...nswer. The illegal immigrants should not be denied the benefits Proposition 187 does because it does more harm than good. There are other solutions that do not threaten the public health, punish children, or spur discrimination.
Cowley, Geoffrey. "Good Politics, Bad Medicine." Newsweek 5 Dec. 1994: 31.
DeGeorge, Gail, Richard S. Dunham, and Catherine Yang. "Who Picks up the Tab for Aliens?" Business Week 28 Mar. 1994: 34.
Gwynne, S.C. "The Unwelcome Mat." Time 28 Nov. 1994: 35-36.
Hornblower, Margot. "Hot Lines and Hot Tempers." Time 28 Nov. 1994: 36.
Impoco, Jim, and Mike Tharp. "Closing the Golden Gate?" U.S. News & World Report 21 Nov. 1994:42 .
Miller, Susan. "We Don't Even Try to Get Across Anymore." Newsweek 5 Dec. 1994: 34.
Rosen, Jeffrey. "Washington Diarist: Citizens." The New Republic 21 Nov. 1994: 42.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- When discussing American policing, one of the biggest issues confronting the police force today is the issue of illegal immigration and subsequently, deportation. Police officers are constantly confronted with dealing with illegal immigrants, many times in the form of college students or the military. In April of 2011, seven activists, who declared themselves illegal immigrants, were arrested for blocking downtown Atlanta traffic during a protest. They were demonstrating against a ban on illegal immigrants attending some Georgia colleges (Burns 12).... [tags: Immigration to the United States, Immigration]
930 words (2.7 pages)
- Immigration in the United States The immigration patterns of the United States have fluctuated over the years, some years having little while others see a rising amount of immigrants, both legal and illegal, looking for opportunities to improve their lives. The amount of illegal immigration is a problem since many take advantage of the social services provided by the government without contributing towards the country since they are not citizens and many people see these illegal immigrants as a threat to their employment.... [tags: Illegal Immigration]
1890 words (5.4 pages)
- Tony crossed the Mexican border with his family when he was eight years old because his family wanted a better life financially and educationally. Tony, who graduated from high school with a 3.8 grade point average, has missed several chances on scholarships because of his status as an illegal immigrant. Along with financial difficulties, his family has to live without their father because his father came earlier to earn money for their crossing which caused him to get deported from the United States.... [tags: Illegal Immigration]
1550 words (4.4 pages)
- Like with many other issues, one of the biggest obstacles on the way of creating strict legislation to crack down illegal immigration is a political one. The influx of illegal immigrants creates the economic “winners” and “losers”. Agriculture, construction, retail and hospitality industries significantly benefit from availability of cheap undocumented labor. Illegal immigrants themselves, in spite of working for low wages are still making much more that they would make in their home countries and are able to send remittances to support their families.... [tags: Immigration to the United States]
1321 words (3.8 pages)
- The United States government has always had immigration issues. Medicaid expenses for illegal immigrants cost taxpayers millions of dollars each and every year. Welfare benefits also create the same issues that Medicaid does for taxpayers in the United States. Policies need to be changed so that the birth of children in the United States to illegal immigrants can be stopped. The United States needs to take a deeper look into amnesty and ask themselves if this is truly the right answer for the illegal immigration problem at this time.... [tags: Immigration to the United States]
1601 words (4.6 pages)
- Illegal immigration has always been a hot topic for presidential candidates, but in recent years the controversy of undocumented immigrants immigrating into the states has peeked national interest. There are approximately eleven million undocumented immigrants, including children, currently residing in the United States as of 2014. Many of the undocumented children who were brought here for a shot at a better future now attend public school and its brought a great deal of controversy whether it is unconstitutional to restrict basic education to these undocumented minors.... [tags: Immigration to the United States]
922 words (2.6 pages)
- The United States is known as the land of great opportunities. People from all around the world traveled to America in hopes of finding a better life for them and their family. Harvard’s Oscar Handlin wrote, “Once I thought to write a history of the immigrants in America. Then I discovered that the immigrants were American history,” (Daniels). Over the years, the population of these immigrants has grown immensely and some of these immigrants become illegal, leading to immigration reform. Immigration reform is a commonly used term for improving the laws regarding illegal immigration.... [tags: Immigration to the United States]
1020 words (2.9 pages)
- There are many, many issues when it comes to immigration and migration. Nothing is just black and white, and there is always at least two sides to a story, usually more than that. I’m going to tell my side, or at least the side that I see the most of living in Arizona, a border state to Mexico. Being that the issue of immigration is so broad, I’ve narrowed it down to the most important question to me, living in the southwest, concerning Mexican/American border issues.... [tags: Cons of Illegal Immigration, Immigrants]
1720 words (4.9 pages)
- The Debate in the United States over Immigration Immigration plays a huge role in the population of the United States. The U.S. is looked at as a place for a new start and a place to begin a new life. This country gives people the opportunity to make their own choices and have their own freedom, who are we to decide who can have these rights or not. Should Americans really have to right to deny another human being the right to live in this beautiful country. America is a wonderful place to live, so should immigration become legalized, meaning as soon as a foreigner steps on U.S soil should they be considered a U.S citizen or should immigration stay illegal for those who do not go thro... [tags: Immigration Emigration Migration Essays]
1304 words (3.7 pages)
- Immigration Open the book You asked about...immigration and citizenship. Turn to page 2. "Immigration Canada aims to contribute to a stronger nation by: ... protecting refugees at home and abroad" (Immigration and Citizenship 2). Turn to page 5. "Immigration assesses immigrants...standards that do not discriminate on the basis of race, national or ethnic origin, colour, religion or sex" (Immigration and Citizenship 5). Disturbed. Turn to page 28. "Canada encourages the admission of business immigrants...that contribute to the nation’s economic and cultural well-being, and create job opportunities" (Immigration and Citizenship 28).... [tags: essays research papers fc]
2403 words (6.9 pages)