A Critical Evaluation of Assisi by Norman MacCaig Essay

A Critical Evaluation of Assisi by Norman MacCaig Essay

Length: 1475 words (4.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

A Critical Evaluation of Assisi

Q: Choose a poem in which the poet has put across a definite
point of view. By close reference to the poetic techniques used, show
how successful the poet has been in making you share his/ her point of
view.

“Assisi” by Norman MacCaig is an intriguing and thought-provoking
poem, which has put across a definite point of view to me which I
believe is that all people should be treated equally and we should try
to help those less fortunate than ourselves. In this essay I will
show how successful the poet has been in making me share his point of
view, with the help of literary techniques such as language, word –
choice and imagery.

Norman MacCaig has put across a definite point of view for me and has
been successful in making me share this view by using thoughtful and
intense language. The first aspect of language, which he uses is
metaphor in the beginning of the poem when he is describing the dwarf
sitting outside the church. He uses metaphor as he says,

“The dwarf with his hands on backwards

Sat, slumped like a half – filled sack

On tiny twisted legs from which

Sawdust might run.”

The metaphor here of the dwarf sitting like a ‘half filled sack’ is
describing the dwarf and how he has a deformed body. He is being
compared to looking like a sack, which is slumped and half empty.
This is effective as it seems as though the dwarf cannot help himself
and he is sitting there waiting for help. MacCaig tells us that he is
a dwarf therefore he will be very short and “hands on backwards” and
“tiny twisted legs” portrays his deformity as I can envisage his legs
dangling from his body. Also as he is sitting like a “half –filled
sack” it seems to me that he cannot do an...


... middle of paper ...


...ered after him as he scattered

The grain of the Word.”

This shows me MacCaig is comparing the tourists to the birds and the
Priest to the sower. He does not approve of the actions as it is
compared to the parable of the sower of when he scatters the grain and
the birds flutter after it. He does not approve of the tourists
fluttering after the word and ignoring the poor dwarf, when in actual
fact they should be helping him.

In conclusion, “Assisi” by Norman MacCaig is an intriguing and
though-provoking poem, which has put across a definite point of view
for me, which I believe is that all people should be treated equally
and that we should help those less fortunate than ourselves. In this
I essay I have shown how successful the poet was in making me share
this view by using his thoughtful and intense language, word-choice
and imagery techniques.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Critical Analysis And Evaluation Of An Issue Essay

- Critical thinking is the objective analysis and evaluation of an issue in order to form a judgement. It has the quality to skillfully analyze, assess, and reconstruct. It is a “self” way of thinking because of the formations of opinions backed by facts and knowledge. Everything stems from critical thinking because it is something that is done every second. Levels of Inquiry is a part of the two types of reasoning, more specifically deductive reasoning. It is also how we go about performing critical thinking....   [tags: Critical thinking, Logic, Reasoning]

Strong Essays
1000 words (2.9 pages)

Essay about Analysis of Visiting Hour by Norman Maccaig

- Analysis of Visiting Hour by Norman Maccaig The poem "Visiting Hour" by Norman Maccaig is a very emotional one. The poet helps you to understand the situation and his feelings by the use imagery and word choice. "Visiting Hour" is written in the first person as the poet himself is going to hospital to visit a very close relative who is severiorly unwell and is dying. The poet is having an emotional effect as he is having different thoughts as the poem progresses. I think that the poet is trying to contain his feelings by not expressing them freely....   [tags: Maccaig Norman Visiting Hour Poem Poetry Essays]

Strong Essays
834 words (2.4 pages)

Critical Evaluation Of Incident Analysis Essay

- Critical Evaluation of Incident Vachon and Leblac (2011) claim that reflective learning is facilitated by Critical Incident Analysis, the key components being a thorough analysis of an authentic, contextualised experience. In practise, through research, Kettle and Sellars (1996) established that peer reflection amongst groups of students, was integral to challenging preconceived ideas of their own pedagogy. In addition, Onjanen (1993), argues that the use of reflective journals, group discussion and own personal history are the most effective means to reflect, and subsequently improve on practise....   [tags: Education, Critical thinking, Teacher, School]

Strong Essays
1222 words (3.5 pages)

Performance Evaluations : Performance Evaluation Essay

- There are several reasons organizations initiate performance evaluations, however the standard purpose for performance evaluations is to discuss performance expectations; not only from the employers perspective but to engage in a formal collaboration where the employee and the manager are both able to provide feedback in a formal discourse. There are many different processes an organization should follow when developing its performance evaluation tool; in addition essential characteristics that must accompany an effective performance appraisal process....   [tags: Human resource management, Evaluation, Management]

Strong Essays
896 words (2.6 pages)

Essay Critical Evaluation : The Dammed Human Race

- Critical Evaluation: “The Dammed Human Race” by Mark Twain “Simple things which the other animals easily learn, he is incapable of learning” (Twain). Mark Twain’s essay over “The Dammed Human Race” is full of satire when he describes humans and their behaviors. In his piece, he compares humans and their lack of morals against animals who exhibit stronger morals. Mark provides several examples in the form of tests to back up his theory. In doing so, he denounces the Darwin theory and comes up with what he believes is more suitable, the Descent of Man from the Higher Animals....   [tags: Human, Rhetoric, Critical thinking, Species]

Strong Essays
1033 words (3 pages)

Other Sides of the Stereotypical Cop in "Brooklyn Cop” by Norman MacCaig

- "Brooklyn Cop” written by Norman MacCaig, a Scottish poet, is about an American cop who roams the streets tackling crime. Our impression of the stereotypical cop changes throughout the poem as we find that he isn’t all that he is made out to be. This essay will look at how the cop is portrayed and the techniques used to give this impression of him. The first impression we are given of the American cop is that he is a gorilla. The poet states “built like a gorilla.” The poet uses a simile to show that the cop is big built and often scary when on the job, like a gorilla....   [tags: Brooklyn Cop, Norman MacCaig, stereotypes,]

Strong Essays
628 words (1.8 pages)

The Aesthetic Pedagogy of Francis of Assisi Essay

- The Aesthetic Pedagogy of Francis of Assisi ABSTRACT: Despite his anti-intellectualism, Francis of Assisi was an effective teacher who intentionally illustrated the life of virtue in his own way of living. He was a teacher in the sense that the Hebrew prophets, Socrates or Gandhi were teachers. He was a performance artist for whom drama functioned pedagogically. His life was not always meant to be an example to his followers; sometimes it was a dramatic lesson, meant to be watched, not imitated....   [tags: Francis Assisi Essays]

Strong Essays
3470 words (9.9 pages)

Saint Francis of Assisi Essay

- Saint Francis of Assisi (1182-10/4/1226) was born into a well-off family unit at Assisi, Italy, the son of a wealthy merchant named Pietro di Bernardone. Francis received little formal education and during his formative years. As an adolescent, he was all the rage, attractive, appealing and was mostly preoccupied in having fun; enjoying practical jokes and was usually the central source of entertainment of the party. Francis was brought up in luxury and cheerfulness. He spent a substantial segment of his possessions in wasteful pleasures....   [tags: History Biography Saint Italy Assisi]

Free Essays
1801 words (5.1 pages)

Essay about Assisi

- Critical Evaluation-Assisi A poem that I have been studying recently is Assisi by Norman McCaig, which I found very interesting to read because it made a statement which relates to our world today even though the poem was wrote about thirty or forty years ago. The poem has lots of ideas including effective figures of speech, good choice of words, important images and irony. The statement that McCaig makes is, where ever there is great wealth it always exists along side great poverty. The poem is set in Assisi in Italy around the 1970’s were all the rich tourists are coming in hundreds from all different countries far and wide to see the frescoes painted by Giotto in Assisi’s huge cath...   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
1286 words (3.7 pages)

Assisi Essays

- A poem which has genuinely shocked me is `Assisi' by Norman MacCaig. It deals with a beggar in desperate need of help but does not receive any. MacCaig gets his point across through his different ideas and devices. The opening verse states what is physically wrong with the beggar. `sat, slumped like a half filled sack' This simile is used to create the image that he is deformed and floppy. The poet's use of 'on tiny twisted legs' gives the impression that the beggar is childlike and very innocent but also in pain....   [tags: Poetry]

Free Essays
463 words (1.3 pages)