A Comparison Between Death of a Naturalist and Digging Essay examples

A Comparison Between Death of a Naturalist and Digging Essay examples

Length: 955 words (2.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

A Comparison Between Death of a Naturalist and Digging

For GCSE course work we have to compare two poems from a foreign
culture. The two poems we picked were both by the popular Irish poem
‘Seamus Heaney.’ The two poems we’re looking at ‘Death of a
Naturalist’ and ‘Digging’ could be seen as autobiographical. ‘Death of
a Naturalist’ is basically about a young boy who had a keenness for
nature, which has disintegrated throughout a summer. ‘Digging’ is
about the poet remembering his childhood, he writes about about
digging as though it is patriotic of his family. He talks about fore
fathers and how he will continue this tradition, not by digging on a
farm but with his pen, writing.

Although with seemingly different storylines, the poems actually start
off quite similarly; with both poems taking you back you a specific
time in the poets’ childhood. In ‘Digging’ the poet is remembering
other people in his life, like his grandfather and father but with
‘Death of a Naturalist’ his memories are all introspective. In both
poems the original plot is elaborated upon with ‘Death of a
Naturalist’ taking a negative line and ‘Digging’ turning positive.

In ‘Death of a Naturalist’ the poem is split into two stanzas; this
separates the poets’ opinion in two, full of enthusiasm in one

‘I would fill jam pots full of……’

To the lack of enthusiasm in the second

‘I sickened, turned, and ran’

‘Digging’ is split into many stanza’s of seemingly almost random
length, nut when you look closer you see that they get longer when the
poem read to better things, for example the poet get most enthusiastic
when he remembers his grandfather this is reflected in the fact that
this stanza is by far the longest at eight lines.
...


... middle of paper ...


...athered there for vengeance’

There are examples of onomatopoeia in both poems although it isn’t
used at length in either. I noticed ‘slap’ is used in both poems, both
in descriptions of mud or dirt sentences, showing the link in the
poets’ language.

Overall I enjoyed both poems though I did prefer ‘Digging’ as I like
the way the poet flicked back and forth through time. I could also
visualise this poem more, like a film, which I liked. I also like the
cast use of alliteration which made the poem kind of roll off your
tongue. There is also a really good use of onomatopoeia in the poem in
the second stanza.

‘Under my window a clean rasping sound’

This sentence really draws you into the poem and you can almost hear
the rasping as the shovel sinks into the ground. To sum up, all of
these factors and more are the reason as to why I prefer ‘Digging’

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

A Comparison of Death of a Naturalist and Digging by Seamus Heaney Essays

- A Comparison of Death of a Naturalist and Digging by Seamus Heaney The poems 'Death of a Naturalist' and 'Digging' have many similarities, and contrasts. Some of the reoccurring themes in the two poems include memories of childhood and changes in the life of the writer. There are contrasts too, in 'Death of a Naturalist'; the writer is concentrating on himself and his own experiences in life, rather than the experiences of others. In 'Digging', the opposite is true, as the writer concentrates mainly on the events in other people's lives, namely his father and grandfather....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
1529 words (4.4 pages)

Essay on Death of Naturalist by Seamus Heaney

- Death of Naturalist by Seamus Heaney The poem "Death of Naturalist" was written by a well known Irish poet Seamus Heaney. The title "Death of a Naturalist" gives us a sense of loss. The opening line "All year the flax-dam festered in the heart" gives us specific detail like in Blackberry picking. The alliteration in the first line such as flax-dom and festered links in with the second stanza. Flax-dom is an onomatopoeia and festered has association of sickness and decay. It contrasts with the happy description in the first stanza when he recalls collecting the frogspawn....   [tags: Death of Naturalist Seamus Heaney Essays]

Better Essays
664 words (1.9 pages)

A Comparison of Seamus Heaney's Mid-Term Break and Digging Essay

- A Comparison of Seamus Heaney's Mid-Term Break and Digging I am comparing two poems by Seamus Heaney- `Mid-Term Break` and `Digging`. Both of the poems are written about his childhood and his family. The first poem I analysed was `Mid-Term Break`, where the simple and straight forward title `Break` caught my attention suggesting to me that this poem is going to be a positive experience, a break from work, a time to relax. The commencing stanza, the first line reads, ?I sat all morning in the college sick bay?, which has connotation of depression, illness and suffering suggested from the word `sick`....   [tags: Seamus Heaney Break Digging Poems Essays]

Better Essays
2070 words (5.9 pages)

Death Of A Naturalist By Seamus Heaney Essay

- ... This supports the theme because the speaker grew up most of his life admiring and probably expecting to live the farmer life, but the father son relationship changes. The son does not follow his dad’s footsteps but creates a path for himself. Once again the idea of the “perfect” father figure is brought in, in this poem. The way that the speaker talks about the things his father did, shows admirations. He talks about the way that his ancestors collected potatoes, there is a sense of pride in this poem....   [tags: Family, Poetry, Future, Time]

Better Essays
1441 words (4.1 pages)

A Comparison of Seamus Heaney's Poem Digging and The song of the old mother, by William Butler Yeats

- I have looked at the poem 'Digging' by Seamus Heaney. The poem is about the poet digging into his past and appears to be a modest poem. The "nicking and slicing neatly" that Heaney says in his poem can also apply to the crafting of a poem. Heaney seems unhappy and distanced from his farming family roots however he shows a good amount of admiration for farming men. Heaney shows the skill and dignity of labour. The expertise is rather admired than the strength and the technique is very precisely explained....   [tags: Digging, The song of the old mother]

Better Essays
1328 words (3.8 pages)

Essay on Death of a Naturalist

- Death of a Naturalist This poem is similar to Blackberry-Picking in its subject and structure - here, too, Heaney explains a change in his attitude to the natural world, in a poem that falls into two parts, a sort of before and after. But here the experience is almost like a nightmare, as Heaney witnesses a plague of frogs like something from the Old Testament. You do not need to know what a flax-dam is to appreciate the poem, as Heaney describes the features that are relevant to what happened there - but you will find a note below....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
1001 words (2.9 pages)

Death of naturalist Essay

- Death of naturalist This poem is a fertile mixture of imagery, sounds and an impression created by nature on people’s mind. Heaney sensualises an outstanding fear of the physical wonders of the world. He vividly describes his childhood experience that precipitates his change as a boy from the receptive and protected innocence of childhood to the fear and uncertainty of adolescence. As he wonders along the pathways of salient discovery, Heaney’s imagination bursts into life. The title of the poem is amusingly ironic – by a naturalist we would normally think of someone with expert scientific knowledge of living things and ecology....   [tags: English Literature]

Better Essays
727 words (2.1 pages)

Digging For a Living Essay

- Digging For a Living In his poem "Digging," Seamus Heaney describes a unique relationship between a boy and his father. Their relationship closely relates to the one I have with my father. Throughout the poem, the poet's pen is contrasted with the father's spade, using each as a symbol of their vocation and background. Along the same lines, the relationship between my father and myself can be expressed through my keyboard and his pencil. Heaney's poem tells of a boy and his father who have different callings for their career....   [tags: Digging for Living]

Free Essays
528 words (1.5 pages)

Digging Essay

- "Digging" “Digging” by Seamus Heaney is the first poem in the first full volume of Heaney’s poems, “Death of a Naturalist”. “Death of a Naturalist” is about the transition into adulthood and the loss of innocence. The poem shows how Heaney looked up to his father and grandfather, especially their hard work. Even though Heaney did not follow in their footsteps and become a farm laborer, he respects the work they do, especially their skill at digging. The poem is a free verse poem....   [tags: Literary Analysis, Seamus Heaney]

Better Essays
1098 words (3.1 pages)

Poetry appreciation of Death of a naturalist Essay

- Poetry appreciation of Death of a naturalist This poem ‘Death of a Naturalist’ by Seamus Heaney is about the lifecycle of frogs and a child’s interest in nature. As the child grows up he looses interest in all aspects of nature. It is as if ‘Death of a Naturalist’ was referring to the loss of innocence of the child and the love of nature he once had died inside him. Not only that, he now has respect for nature but not necessarily disliking it; nor loving it either. The atmosphere of the first stanza is quite positive....   [tags: English Literature]

Better Essays
1098 words (3.1 pages)