Male Masochism in the Religious Lyrics of Donne and Crashaw Essay

Male Masochism in the Religious Lyrics of Donne and Crashaw Essay

Length: 3467 words (9.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Male Masochism in the Religious Lyrics of Donne and Crashaw

The impetus of my psychoanalytic exploration of male masochism in
Donne and Crashaw occurs in Richard Rambuss's "Pleasure and Devotion:
The Body of Jesus and Seventeenth-Century Religious Lyric," in which
he opens up possibilities for reading eroticism (especially
homoeroticism) in early modern representations of Christ's body. In
this analysis, Rambuss opposes Caroline Walker Bynum who, in response
to Leo Steinberg's The Sexuality of Christ in Renaissance Art, claims
that depictions of Christ's genitalia (the focus of Steinberg's work)
can only be regarded as erotic from a modern standpoint, for such
representations in historical context, before the advent of modern
sexuality, could not have rendered "sexual" meanings for their
audiences but only those signifying reproduction. As Rambuss points
out, Bynum's analysis denies the possibility of reading the
erotic--especially the homoerotic--in medieval/Renaissance
representation (268), for it works on the underlying assumption that
such meanings are structured according to the false binary of
"sexual/generative." Conversely, In Rambuss's view, "the body [is] at
least potentially sexualized, as a truly polysemous surface where
various significances and expressions--including a variety of erotic
ones--compete and collude with each other in making the body
meaningful" (268).

This is where my exploration begins. Rather than "delimit the erotic,"
I wish to investigate what is potentially sexual in
seventeenth-century religious poetry (here that of Donne and Crashaw),
tracing not only "same-sex" desire "spun out from and around Christ's
body," as Rambuss has done but also examining libidinal economie...

... middle of paper ...

...ery of a different strain of
masochism than that which Freud labeled "moral"--"Christian masochism"

[3] In "The Economic Problem of Masochism," Freud identifies three
types of masochism: 1) Primary or erotogenic--the bodily association
of pain and sexual excitement; 2) feminine--the desire to be beaten;
and 3) moral--the self-inflicted torture of one's ego by the superego
(161). My term, erotic masochism, would include the "erotogenic" and
"feminine" in a Freudian framework.

[4] Jean Laplanche, in Life and Death in Psychoanalysis, has shown the
role of such transition in the human subject's "sexualization," or
movement from non-sexual to "sexualized" drives. In erotic forms of
sadism and masochism, the subject transforms [via a "prop"] non-sexual
aggression into a desire for sexual aggression, directed at others or
against the self (85-102).

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Music Lyrics: Rights for Rights

- “[T]his nation was founded on respect for a wide range of viewpoints and faiths, a factor that has given the United States a special heritage and unique stability.” There have been many cases in which music lyrics have been changed as a result of offensive lyrics that citizens did not agree with, and unfortunately people hold the power so changes had to be made, but is it right. Record companies must not put regulations upon music lyrics, because it breaks an individual’s constitutional rights. (Patman) A very important and large reason that any record company should not censor music lyrics is simply because a 200 year old document, known as the constitution protects an individual from being...   [tags: music lyrics, record company, songs]

Powerful Essays
583 words (1.7 pages)

Religious Renewal and Sexual Masochism in Batter my heart, three person'd God

- Religious Renewal and Sexual Masochism in "Batter my heart, three person'd God" In Donne's Holy Sonnet, "Batter my heart, three person'd God," themes of religious renewal and sexual masochism are abundant. While religious renewal is clearly the front-most, and most clearly defined meaning of the poem, the poet's choice of words and subtle analogies leave the poem wide open for speculation in sexual meaning. That John Donne was a preacher, the fire and brimstone, evangelical ringings of religious renewal in this poem are well founded....   [tags: Batter my heart Essays]

Powerful Essays
754 words (2.2 pages)

Essay on Antigone's Masochism

- Masochist. What is a masochist. A masochist is someone who hurts themselves. A masochist not only hurts themselves, but they find pleasure in hurting themselves. A masochist is frowned upon by society. According to masochism is “gratification gained from pain, deprivation, degradation, etc., inflicted or imposed on oneself, either as a result of one's own actions or the actions of others, especially the tendency to seek this form of gratification.” Modern day masochists enjoy cutting themselves, and many die from this....   [tags: Greek Play, Martyrdom]

Powerful Essays
959 words (2.7 pages)

Religious Conquest of the Americas Essay

- Before Columbus landed in the West Indies in 1492, The Spanish Inquisition made it known to anyone within Spain’s domain of influence that if a person was not of the Catholic religion, they were to be punished severely and sometimes even fatally. This influence would undoubtedly be brought over to the Americas a century later, as the colonization of the New World would begin by then. While it was very essential for the Spanish (as well as the Portuguese) to improve their economy by using the resources they found in Latin America, it seemed to a number of them as if that was the only reason for being there, or the main reason at the very least....   [tags: Religious History ]

Powerful Essays
1904 words (5.4 pages)

Religious Persecution as a Global Issue Essay

- In 2013, a study taken by Open Doors, a group that works against Christian persecution worldwide, showed that the number of Christians killed for their faith had nearly doubled since 2012. The number of Christians killed in 2013 was 2,123, whereas the number in 2012 was 1,021. While religious persecution may not be as much of a threat in the United States, where religious freedom is celebrated, this persecution occurs around the world to many different groups – even ones considered a majority in the U.S....   [tags: religious freedom, christians, atheism]

Powerful Essays
967 words (2.8 pages)

A Case Against Religious Exemptions Essay

- A Case Against Religious Exemptions A law can be thought of as a rule that is enforced by an organization or person, and whose purpose is to regulate social behavior. It is, however, hard to find a one-size-fits-all law that pleases everyone who has to follow it. Religious denominations have historically sought some exemption from generally applicable laws, and in many parts of the world, those exemptions have been granted. However, the bases on which these groups seek exemptions are questionable, and such immunities might not be the best foundation for sound political theory....   [tags: Islam, Religion, Religious pluralism]

Powerful Essays
1415 words (4 pages)

Religious Tolerance and Humanism Essay

- Introduction An old history teacher of mine once said that people are incapable of seeing the endless things they share when these common aspects of life stand in the shadow of their few differences. The differences of which he spoke promote unwarranted bias and prevent the advancement of all of humanity and even promote acts of war. Chief among those differences is religious belief. People treat people with a different religion with such great intolerance. They will either discriminate or commit hate crimes just to get their point across....   [tags: religion, intolerance, religious beliefs]

Powerful Essays
2240 words (6.4 pages)

Essay about Religious Head Garments

- In many religions, the use of garments such as the jewish yarmulke or the islamic hijab are not merely worn out of choice, but out of strict ritual or religious obligation. For religious groups, donning traditional dress is not just seen as religious duty, but ties closely with spiritual practice and provides a sense of spiritual identity. Widespread use shows that it has become an integral part to the continuity of multiple religious practices. Provided that wearing religious garments is based on manifesting central religious beliefs(SOURCE), to what extent can a State hinder this expression of freedom....   [tags: religious beliefs and expressions]

Powerful Essays
3092 words (8.8 pages)

Love in Molière's play, Tartuffe, John Donne’s Canonization, and Crashaw's On the Wounds of Our Cru

- Love in Molière's play, Tartuffe, John Donne’s Canonization, and Crashaw's On the Wounds of Our Crucified Lord Other than being examples of some of the best literature of the seventeenth century, the three works listed in the title of this essay don't seem to fit very well together. Or do they maybe after all. Creativity consists of connecting things that don't always seem to be related. All three of these works of literature deal with the various aspects of love--both human and divine. Earlier this semester I read about the Italian poet, Petrarch, whose sonnets followed certain romantic conventions as he recounted his unrequited love for Laura....   [tags: Comparison Compare Contrast Essays]

Free Essays
2354 words (6.7 pages)

Offensive Lyrics Essay

- Offensive Lyrics Intro Ben, a child no more than the age of eight, adores his older brother James. James is in his mid-teens and is a huge fan of rap music. One of his favorites is Eminem. Ben, wanting to be as much like his brother as possible, does everything to become a complete copy of James. Ben dresses like him, eats the same food as he does, and even tries to mimic the way he walks. Ben even tries to listen to the same music that the older brother does. He asks his mom to buy one of the CDs that James has....   [tags: Music Censorship Essays]

Powerful Essays
3008 words (8.6 pages)