Analysing the Portrayal of Eddie Carbone as a Tragic Hero Essay

Analysing the Portrayal of Eddie Carbone as a Tragic Hero Essay

Length: 2150 words (6.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Analysing the Portrayal of Eddie Carbone as a Tragic Hero

A View from the Bridge by Arthur Miller is a dramatically tense
tragedy that presents the story of the downfall of an ordinary man.
The play examines the tragic consequences of Eddie Carbone's inability
to understand himself and his actions. This predominantly takes the
form of his prejudice towards his cousin and his inappropriate
attraction to his niece. It is set in the 1950s and was written while
Miller had become interested in the lives and work of Brooklyn's
dockworkers and longshoremen.

Miller uses the character of Eddie to express his viewpoint that the
tragedy of the ruined life of an ordinary workingman is just as
significant a subject for tragedy as that of any ancient king, God or
"Caesar from Syracuse or Calabria". He presents Eddie as an equally
valid antihero. Antiheroes, or Tragic heroes, are as Aristotle wrote
neither wholly good nor wholly evil but a mixture of both. Eddie is
not an evil man, but he acts selfishly, inappropriately and
recklessly. Antiheros, unlike heroes, have fatal flaws. These enable a
contemporary audience to empathise and identify with his fatally
flawed relationships and disastrous choices. Being able to relate to
Eddie will let the audience feel the dramatic tension of the
situations he is placed in.

According to Aristotle a traditional tragic hero is a person who finds
himself in a situation where he seems deprived of all outward help and
is forced to rely entirely on himself. A View from the Bridge is
recognisable as a tragedy because Eddie is a tragic hero even though
he is a stereotypical 1950s ordinary American. He is tragic because he
refuses to take the help and advice offered by his lawyer, Alf...


... middle of paper ...


...f instead of trying to gain control of the
other characters, he would have perhaps succeeded rather than causing
complete destruction.

By the end of the play, Eddie cannot see any view from the bridges of
Brooklyn; he only has eyes for Catherine. Unfortunately, Catherine,
like Rodolpho, sees all number of possibilities and dreams that lie
ahead of her. Although bridges connect things, they are also a symbol
of the way things are divided. Catherine needs to move across these
bridges, but Eddie dies fighting to hold onto her.

Eddies story is a tragedy because it is about how he handles his
hubristic character, the result of his disastrous choices and his
drastic change in fortune. It takes the audience on a roller coaster
of dramatic tension, ending up with his unfortunate and unnecessary
death, leaving the audience in mourning for such a tragic hero.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Claudius, the Unorthodox Tragic Hero Essay

- An Aristotelian’s tragic hero is a person of nobility who is ill-fated by a defect - seemingly intertwined with attributes that make him/her prosperous - in his/her character. Usually the protagonist, a tragic hero is commended for his/her honorable traits and is depicted to be the victim in most works of literature. In Hamlet, by William Shakespeare, the traditional portrayal of a tragic hero is defied: in lieu of being the victim, the tragic hero becomes the culprit of the play. By instilling the antagonist, King Claudius, with honorable qualities like that of a tragic hero, Shakespeare demonstrates that a person is never at the extreme ends of the moral spectrum but rather at the center:...   [tags: hamlet, shakespeare, tragic hero]

Powerful Essays
1362 words (3.9 pages)

A Tragic Hero And An Anti Hero Essay

- Like Aristotle had once said about tragedy, it is “the imitation of an action that is serious and also, as having magnitude, complete in itself; in appropriate and pleasurable language; … in a dramatic rather than narrative form; with incidents arousing pity and fear, where with to accomplish a catharsis of these emotions. A tragedy, therefore, is a kind of lie (“imitation”) that tells a certain truth about human nature and the self. Classical tragic heroes possess hamartia or a tragic flaw, such as hubris, that often lead to the character’s own downfall; and according to Aristotle, "A man cannot become a hero until he can see the root of his own downfall." The protagonist must not only poss...   [tags: Tragic hero, Tragedy, Poetics]

Powerful Essays
1295 words (3.7 pages)

The As A Tragic Hero Essay

- Aristotle, the Greek philosopher, characterizes plays or stories where the main character is a tragic hero, who confronts his downfall due to fate, his mistake or any other social reason as tragedies. In the novel “One foot in Eden” novel, set in the 1950s in Jocassee, a town in South Carolina, Rash tells the story of a local military veteran who suddenly disappears and the people who are involved in the case. Rather than follow the basic fiction formula of moving the plot in a straight line, Rash repeatedly switches the narration to give the story more depth....   [tags: Tragic hero, Tragedy, Mother, Hamartia]

Powerful Essays
1404 words (4 pages)

Defining The Definition Of A Tragic Hero Essay example

- Redefining the definition of a tragic hero Arthur Miller, the author of the essay titled “Tragedy and the Common Man” examines the definition of tragedy. Miller was also the playwright of “Death of a Salesman” which psychologically exploits a common man attempting to encapture the American dream. Miller’s theory pushes the limitation on the ideal of a tragic hero examined in these two pieces of literature. The following paragraphs will evaluate characteristics of a protagonist character named Willy Loman, examining his status in society, shortcomings and his choice to sacrifice his own life for his dignity....   [tags: Tragedy, Tragic hero, Poetics]

Powerful Essays
855 words (2.4 pages)

Essay about Macbeth As A Tragic Hero

- Macbeth is one of Shakespeare’s most well known plays. Shakespeare enjoyed writing a variety of play types, like comedies and tragedies. Shakespeare liked how tragedies could make the audience feel emotions towards the character while learning a lesson about life. Tragedies contain a tragic hero, who experiences a downfall, and a tragic flaw in the hero, which causes the downfall to occur. The main character in the play Macbeth, is a man named Macbeth, who nobly represents the king of Scotland until he meets three witches....   [tags: Macbeth, Tragic hero, Macbeth]

Powerful Essays
1055 words (3 pages)

The Tragic Hero Of Sophocles ' Antigone Essay

- In the Greek play Antigone by Sophocles is very different from traditional plays or tragedies. Not only does the play have two prominent characters, Antigone and King Creon, the two characters also function as a tragic hero. However, which of the two character is the real tragic hero. Antigone’s tragedy is from conflict and passion. To really understand which of the two character is the ‘real’ tragic hero, one must understand the definition of a tragic hero. According to Aristotle’s definition of a tragic hero, a tragic hero must be born from a high social class and his or her downfall must be caused by a fatal flaw of that character....   [tags: Tragedy, Sophocles, Poetics, Tragic hero]

Powerful Essays
826 words (2.4 pages)

Essay about The Tragic Hero Of Sophocles ' Antigone

- In Sophocle’s play Antigone, Creon fits all the traits of a tragic hero according to Aristotle’s definition. A tragic hero is a literary character who judges wrongly which creates his or her own downfall. Creon is the new king of Thebes and he will not allow any criminal activity, not even from his family. When Creon’s niece Antigone decides to go against Creon’s law he punishes her by burying her alive in a tomb; by doing so Creon is creating a recipe for disaster. Creon does not realize who else it will affect by putting Antigone to death, nor does he understand that he in turn paved the road to his own downfall....   [tags: Poetics, Tragic hero, Oedipus, Anagnorisis]

Powerful Essays
711 words (2 pages)

Essay about The Stock Tragic Hero : Oedipus

- The Stock Tragic Hero: Oedipus We’ve discussed in class the qualities of a “tragic hero”. Illustrate that either Oedipus or Creon satisfies the requirements to meet the definition. Oedipus Rex, the ignorant king, a character created for the very purpose of being the epitome of a tragic hero. Bound and kicked out of his homeland as an infant; a force he could not control, driving his fate, taking away his free will. The character of Oedipus created by Sophocles around 430 BCE is the precedent for all tragic heroes created in the time after Oedipus’s sinful conception....   [tags: Oedipus, Tragic hero, Tragedy, Sophocles]

Powerful Essays
1427 words (4.1 pages)

The Tragic Hero Of King Lear Essay examples

- In the words of Aristotle, a character must possess four key components in order to make them a tragic hero. First, the character must show his good intentions by any speech or action. In Aristotle’s words, “The character will be good if the purpose is good.” (Aristotle) The second component the character must possess is propriety. Propriety simply means the conformity to what is socially acceptable in behavior or speech. The third component is the character must be true to life. The character acts out of probability and necessity, and not just because of some random traits bestowed upon the hero....   [tags: Poetics, Tragic hero, Tragedy, Character]

Powerful Essays
707 words (2 pages)

The Tragic Hero Of Oedipus Essay

- Many things can describe a tragedy. However, according to definition of a tragedy by Aristotle, there are only five. The play has to have a tragic hero, preferably of noble stature. Second, the tragic hero must have a tragic flaw. Because of that flaw, the hero falls from either power or death. Due to the fall, the tragic hero discovers something. Finally, there must be catharsis in the minds of the audience. It fits all the characteristics as defined by Aristotle. The tragic hero of a play is a man of some social standing and personal reputation, but sufficiently like ourselves in terms of his weaknesses that we feel fear and pity when a tragic flaw, rather than an associate, causes his dow...   [tags: Sophocles, Tragedy, Tragic hero, Poetics]

Powerful Essays
1771 words (5.1 pages)