Comparing The Withered Arm by Thomas Hardy and Turned by Charlotte Perkins Gilman

Comparing The Withered Arm by Thomas Hardy and Turned by Charlotte Perkins Gilman

Length: 2749 words (7.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Comparing The Withered Arm by Thomas Hardy and Turned by Charlotte Perkins Gilman



This essay is aimed at discussing the differences between two short
stories, called ‘The Withered Arm’ by Thomas Hardy and ‘Turned’ by
Charlotte Perkins Gilman. These stories have similar plots and both
deliver and contrast these in their very own clever ways. They are
both based on the idea of triangular relationships, involving two
women and a man. In the story ‘Turned’ there is a couple named Mr. and
Mrs. Marroner, and their employee who is a young and beautiful Swedish
maid who goes by the name of Gerta. In ‘The Withered Arm’ the
relationship is between a lady called Rhoda Brook and a farmer called
Farmer Lodge and his wife who is called Gertrude.

This essay will discuss the similarities and differences between the
two stories and their characters, I will also discuss the language
used, and the way the same image is effectively conveyed in the two
stories.

The author of ‘Turned’ is Charlotte Perkins Gilman who was from a poor
background and was born in Connecticut, USA, in 1860. The first story
she wrote was called ‘The Yellow Wallpaper’ which she wrote in 1892.
She then went on to write her best-known book, which was called ‘Women
and Economics.’ Gilman was a feminist writer who believed that women
had the right to their own independence. This is demonstrated in the
character of Marion in ‘Turned’, as she is a clever woman with a
degree and has a title of doctor. Gilman published ‘Turned’ in 1911 at
the time where issues surrounding women rights was becoming more
serious and common.

On the other hand, Thomas Hardy wrote his novel ‘The Withered Arm’
with men in the powerful positions. For instance Farmer Lodg...


... middle of paper ...


...ld and frail and died and Farmer Lodge
became a kind, caring and thoughtful man! Gertrude died three days
later in the town “Her blood had been turned indeed, too far.” After
this Rhoda had lost her friend and her son so she decided to resume
where she had started where “Her monotonous milking at the dairy was
resumed.” Farmer Lodge on the third corner of this triangular
relationship gave up his farms and became a member of the parish after
he overcame his remorse and moodiness. “He eventually changed for the
better, and appeared as a chastened and thoughtful man”

To conclude this essay, triangular relationships happen and probably
always will happen for years to come. It doesn’t make any difference
about what century it happens in or if it is from a rich or poor
background because affairs, unwanted babies and complicated
relationships are part of life.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Compare Charlotte Perkins Gilman's, Turned with Thomas Hardy's, A Withered Arm

- Compare Charlotte Perkins Gilman's Turned with Thomas Hardy's A Withered Arm The short stories "Turned" by Charlotte Perkins Gilman, and "The Withered Arm" by Thomas Hardy both have very different techniques and plots with which they aim to appeal to their audience. The opening of "The Withered Arm" immediately involves the reader. Adjectives are used to describe the initial setting, and so the image of the "eighty-cow dairy, and the troop of milkers, regular and supernumerary" becomes clear. Hardy's emphasis on close description helps develop the scene, such as the image of the "many-forked" pail stand "resembling a colossal antlered horn"....   [tags: English Literature]

Powerful Essays
2409 words (6.9 pages)

Compare and Contrast Turned and The Withered Arm Essay

- With Particular Reference to the Relationships Between Men and Women, Compare and Contrast the Two Short Stories Turned and The Withered Arm. The two short stories by Thomas Hardy and Charlotte Perkins Gilman both share similarities in plot, characters and the relationships held by men and women. They both show, in a cyclical structure, the betrayal of men and the jealously held between people, although Gilman takes a more feminist view, largely due to the difference in era of the two short stories....   [tags: Free Essay Writer]

Powerful Essays
1577 words (4.5 pages)

Men and Women in The Withered Arm and Other Stories by Thomas Hardy and Men and Women in Turned by Charlotte Perkins Gilman

- Men and Women in The Withered Arm and Other Stories by Thomas Hardy and Men and Women in Turned by Charlotte Perkins Gilman "The Withered Arm" and "Turned" are both focused on relationships between men and women. "The Withered Arm" was about the relationship between Rhoda Brook and Farmer Lodge and also who he married later on called Gertrude. "Turned" was about the relationship between Mr.Marroner and Mrs.Marion Marroner but Mr.Marroner also had an affair with his servant Gerta Peterson and made her pregnant....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
933 words (2.7 pages)

The Position of Men in The Withered Arm and Turned Essay

- The Position of Men in The Withered Arm and Turned In this essay, I hope to come to a successful conclusion to the essay question. I will do this by analysing the two main male characters in 'The Withered Arm' and 'Turned', Mr Lodge and Mr Marroner. In the narrative 'Turned', Mr. Marroner is a high class, educated working man who owns his own household. He is married to Mrs. Marroner and together they employ a servant; Gerta who is much younger than Mrs. Marroner, uneducated but has worked for Mr....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
1204 words (3.4 pages)

Women's Roles in The Yellow Wallpaper and The Withered Arm

- Women's Roles in The Yellow Wallpaper and The Withered Arm In the late 19th century, women were expected to conform to the conventions of society. This meant that they were expected to get married young, pure and beautiful. They were treated like objects as if men bought them. How the woman felt was irrelevant in this period. Women were expected to produce an 'heir and a spare'. Women were also victim to double standards. For example, women had to deal with a child out of wedlock yet were given no responsibility for this....   [tags: Yellow Wallpaper Withered Arm Essays]

Powerful Essays
1228 words (3.5 pages)

Comparing Story of an Hour by Kate Chopin, Turned by Perkins Gilman and Jane Eyre by Charlotte Bronte

- Comparing Story of an Hour by Kate Chopin, Turned by Perkins Gilman and Jane Eyre by Charlotte Bronte In recent times I have compared and comprehended three narratives that are very close to the position of women throughout the early 19th century up till the late 20th century. They entirely demonstrate the changes that have taken place over these eras, and how women acquire the strength to gain their rightful place in society's social circles. Two of these are brief tales known as, 'Story of an hour' written by Kate Chopin and 'Turned' by Perkins Gilman....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
1233 words (3.5 pages)

Comparing Interlopers at the Knap and Turned Essay

- Comparing Interlopers at the Knap and Turned The two stories seem to be quite different at first. "Turned" starts with the sobbing of two women for two completely different conditions. One is rich and the other is poor. While "Interlopers at the Knap" starts with the journey of a young man with his two companions to the Knap where a marriage is going to take place. So the start is quite opposite. One is sad and the other is pleasant. But as we go through the story more further the two stories seem to be sharing many themes....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
1430 words (4.1 pages)

Comparing The Withered Arm and An Imaginative Woman Essay

- Comparing The Withered Arm and An Imaginative Woman I will be examining two novelettes by a single author, Thomas Hardy. "The Withered Arm" and "An Imaginative Woman". I will be highlighting the similarities and differences between them. Additionally I will be analyzing the content of each. The first thing we notice about the two stories is that they are both written in third person narrative. Another thing we notice about the style of writing in both is that it is very old fashioned, which tells us these novelettes must have been written some time in the 19th century....   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]

Free Essays
1856 words (5.3 pages)

The Signalman by Dickens and The Withered Arm by Hardy Essay

- “The Signalman” by Dickens and “The Withered Arm” by Hardy The story of "The Signalman" opens with the words “Halloa. Below there”, this short, but effective line is very significant to the plot of the story. A questioning atmosphere is already created, as it is not clear to the reader as to who is speaking, or whom the anonymous figure is being shouted at. The opening paragraph of the "The Signalman" is unexplained, leaving the readers questioning. For example when the Narrator is shouting from above, the Signalman behaves strangely as he looks round to face the tunnel, whereas a normal person would look upwards in response to this....   [tags: Signalman dickens Withered Hardy Essays]

Free Essays
2658 words (7.6 pages)

Comparing the Suffering Between Rhoda in The Withered Arm and The Son's Veto

- Comparing the Suffering Between Rhoda in The Withered Arm and The Son's Veto in the tale 'The Withered Arm' in the story 'The Son's Veto' are both very lonely women. Both of these women and have been mistreated by men, but none of them ever speak out for themselves to tell the men that their behaviour is unacceptable. Women who were treated by men were just expected by their fathers (if the husband is rich) to just keep quiet and be happy that they are financially supported. Rhoda is a social reject....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
648 words (1.9 pages)