Miss Brill by Katherine Mansfield and Story of an Hour by Kate Chopin

1231 Words3 Pages

Bliss and Miss Brill by Katherine Mansfield and Story of an Hour by Kate Chopin On studying the texts Bliss and Miss Brill by Katherine Mansfield and Story of an Hour by Kate Chopin I have associated all the stories with a sense of female repression. All the short stories feature a main female character and this character is being repressed in various ways such as by another character or their lives in general. In all the stories the awareness of repression appears towards the end mainly due to an event that has taken place. This event brings forth a realisation of their lives, which is so far from the rest of the story. The realisation that occurs in ‘Bliss’ is that Bertha finds out that her husband, Harry, is having an affair. Throughout the rest of the short story Bertha appears overly happy and joyous. This is shown through Mansfield’s choice of language predominantly at the start of the story. Examples of this are things such as ‘she wanted to run instead of walk…’ and ‘…is there no way you can express it without being “drunk and disorderly”. These are examples of where extreme happiness is shown, and she mentioned how this happiness could not possibly be explained without seeming ‘drunk and disorderly’. The extreme happiness has then been contrasted with the confusion, which is brought on at the end by the affair. ‘But the pear tree was as lovely as ever and as full of flower and as still.’ This is how Mansfield ends the story as the ‘still’ part symbolises her life, as the pear tree does. Her life is inert and has come to a halt, as she feels numb. The numbness is also symbolised by the word ‘still’ as when you are numb you generally cannot move. This shows how the act of knowing about t... ... middle of paper ... ... wanted to ask…’ showing she didn’t ask but would have liked to. She is being restrained by the nanny into having a full motherly relationship with her child. One example of how Harry subdues her is how he bullies her into believing Pearl is a dull, boring, and a typical blonde. Harry seems to have obtained the ability to demystify and trick Bertha. Which is a sign he has been doing this for a while and he has become quite expert at it. I think Mansfield did this to prepare the reader slightly for what is going to happen at the end n the revelation that is the affair. The theme of repression therefore runs throughout these stories all written by female authors that have a female view on the world. It is typical of female characters to make men out to be the cruel characters and the women who are the vulnerable main characters who are being repressed.

Open Document