A Comparison Between Desirees Baby & Stench Of Kerosene

1874 Words4 Pages

A Comparison Between Desirees Baby & Stench Of Kerosene

'Stench Of Kerosene' was written by Amrita Pritam approximately fifty

years ago. This emotional short story mainly revolves around the

relationships between a woman, her husband and his mother. Another

important theme is the significance of cultures and traditions in the

protagonists' lives.

The main characters are Manak and Guleri, who are husband and wife.

Guleri and Manak are a loving couple who live with Manak's mother in a

small village in India. Guleri cannot give birth and her mother-in-law

desperately wants a grandchild.

Once a year, during a special festival, Guleri visits her parents in a

nearby village. This year, Manak halfheartedly tries to persuade his

wife not to go. Adamant, Guleri pays no heed to her husband's baseless

wish, and goes to visit her parents regardless. Upon her departure,

Manak's evil mother decides to bring an end her grandchild-less

status, and immediately purchases a wife for Manak, in the hope that

this new bride could have the baby Guleri could not.

When news of her husband's betrayal reaches Guleri, she commits

suicide by dousing herself with kerosene, and consequently setting

herself alight.

'Desirees Baby,' by Kate Chopin, amongst other themes, also explores

the theme of relationships.

Desiree, the female protagonist, is an orphan who was found at the

front of the Valmonde home, lying asleep in the shadows of a big stone

pillar. Madame Valmonde, the owner of the large house cannot have

children; hence welcoming the child and treating her as her own.

When Desiree grows up, she marries a man from a prestigious family.

After a period of marital bliss, they both have a child whom they

immensely love....

... middle of paper ...

...they do not obviously

state what was wrong with the women. Desiree is made out to be so

sweet and loving - her beauty helping to draw the readers into

sympathy for her. It is not blatantly stated that it was stupid of her

to commit suicide. Likewise, Guleri should really have had trust in

her husband, and listened to what he told her instead of proudly

ignoring his pleas. This shows that although their relationship

outwardly shows happiness, there were some serious problems that

occurred beneath the surface. Hence, I conclude that in 'Desiree's

Baby," Armand was wrong to have so much pride, but Desiree's weak

character spurned her awful fate. In 'Stench of Kerosine,' Manak was

weak and stupid, but the consequences of his marrying again could have

been avoided if Guleri trusted her husband. It is simply too easy to

blame the men entirely for what happened.

Open Document