Essay about Electoral College: An Essential Component of our Democracy

Essay about Electoral College: An Essential Component of our Democracy

Length: 1385 words (4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Electoral College: An Essential Component of our Democracy


The right to vote is fundamental to our democracy. For the last 100 years, the presidential candidate who won the most popular votes won the election, but the last election was different. [i] The candidate who won the presidency in the 2000 presidential election, George W. Bush, actually received fewer popular votes than the losing candidate, Al Gore. This raises some interesting questions: is the process by which Americans currently elect presidents democratic? If all Americans are equal, should not one American equal one vote? Does the Electoral College work, even though it disproportionably represents the votes of some Americans, or should we switch to a direct voting system?

There is some support for keeping the current system. One benefit is that generally, the Electoral College adds legitimacy to the winner of the popular vote by exaggerating the margin of the victory. For example, the Electoral College made it look as if John F. Kennedy was the clear winner of the 1960 presidential election. He received 303 electoral votes, while his opponent, Richard Nixon, received only 219 electoral votes.i The popular vote, on the other hand, was much closer: John F. Kennedy received 49.72% of the popular vote, while Richard Nixon received 49.55% of the popular vote.[ii] However, the winner of the most popular votes is not always the winner of the Electoral College. There have been four cases, one being the last election, where the winner of the most popular votes lost the presidency.

Another conceivable benefit of the Electoral College is that it can lessen the negative effects of third-party candidates who have no chance of winning. In order to win the presidency...


... middle of paper ...


...h a greater share of the population. To argue that the Electoral College is undemocratic or not American is not far from arguing that the distribution of power in our nation's legislature is undemocratic and needs reform. The Electoral College is nothing more than a combination of two essential components of our democracy. The Electoral College strikes a delicate balance between the rights of the minority and the majority so that all voices are heard.

[i] Tight election puts Electoral College under microscope

http://www.cnn.com/2000/ALLPOLITICS/stories/11/13/electoral.college/index.html

[ii] 1960 Election Results

http://h0040055bf148.ne.mediaone.net/~dave/POL/pe1960.html

[iii] 1992 Election Results/1996 Election Results

http://h0040055bf148.ne.mediaone.net/~dave/POL/pe1992.html

http://h0040055bf148.ne.mediaone.net/~dave/POL/pe1996.html

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Democratic System Of The Electoral College Essay

- so prominent that there was deliberation that created institutions that created the electoral college, in order to combat this specific problem (Federalist Papers, 68). Furthermore, the democratic system is based upon the simply supposition that if a politician acts in the detriment of his people, then his people will refrain from electing him once again. The challenge is stemmed from the premise that this can occur, and must be remedied by conclusive, accurate information that results in a wise electorate....   [tags: Democracy, Voting, Sortition]

Powerful Essays
808 words (2.3 pages)

Democratic Election: America, You’re Doing It Wrong Essay

- A class votes for which game they want to play to review for a big math test. Each student writes on a piece of paper the name of the game they want to play and gives it to the teacher. The majority of the class wants to play “Mathsketball”, but the teacher decides the class will play Jeopardy instead. Is that fair. Most of the class does not think so. Since the ratification of the Constitution of the United States, there has been a similar component of the government that has defied the requests of the public....   [tags: Electoral College, Federalism]

Powerful Essays
1591 words (4.5 pages)

The Creation of the American Democracy Essays

- The Creation of the American Democracy When the Framers of the Constitution met in Philadelphia, they came together with one common purpose in mind. They needed to form a fair and solid system of government that would stand the test of time; one that was both fair for the people and would not involve a monarchy. Each of these men had their own ideas on what would constitute this system, however, so many compromises had to be made. Together, the men gathered in Philadelphia created a federal system of government and drafted a constitution outlining this government....   [tags: American America History]

Powerful Essays
867 words (2.5 pages)

Time Out For The Electoral College Essay

- Time Out for the Electoral College American citizens are naïve of the function of the Electoral College because they believe in error that they directly elect the President and Vice President when in fact the “Electors” representing the candidates cast the Electoral College votes. The Electoral College Two hundred years ago, the Framers of the Constitution outlined the Electoral College when they disagreed on who should elect the president, and disagreed on the role of the people, the congress, and the states in the political process....   [tags: Elections Electoral College Government]

Powerful Essays
1759 words (5 pages)

Unfairness in the Electoral College Essay

- If you think on the Election Day, you just voted for US president, than you are mistaken, just like millions of Americans who hope their votes would pick next president. When voting for President, we actually vote for state electors who hold Electoral votes. Electoral votes are the votes that decide victory of candidate in election. This Electoral College System has limited democracy to people in major three ways. Electoral college holds an ability to alter result of Election over popular votes, discriminates candidates to campaign in certain states not others, and creates high voter turnouts....   [tags: Electoral College, USA, ]

Powerful Essays
798 words (2.3 pages)

Essay about The Electoral And Electoral College

- The Electoral College Every four year the United stated goes through the process to elect the person who will lead the nation. In order for that to happen the Electoral College is the instrument used for the elections to take place. The Electoral College represents the Founding Fathers’ determination to create a tool by which each US states select the nation’s leader by choosing a group of representatives known as electors, taken by the state. The Electoral ballots given to each state corresponds with each Senator and Representative that state holds....   [tags: President of the United States, Electoral College]

Powerful Essays
1072 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on The Electoral And Electoral College

- The Electoral College Is the Electoral College outdated or still relevant. I should start off saying that, “the Electoral College is a process, not a place” as many think. The Electoral College was a compromise between “election of the President by a vote in Congress and election of the President by a popular vote of qualified citizens.” In total there are 538 in the Electoral Election, “ if the amount of Electoral College votes a state received was directly proportional to its population, smaller rural states would be rendered completely irrelevant....   [tags: President of the United States, Electoral College]

Powerful Essays
1531 words (4.4 pages)

Questions On The Electoral College Essay

- In this paper four subjects on the Electoral College will be addressed. These four subjects are: What is the Electoral College. Why did the founding fathers create the Electoral College. What are some major criticisms of the Electoral College. Should we keep it. Before these questions are addressed it should be noted that many people were not aware of the existence of the Electoral College, perhaps even the Author of this paper. What is the Electoral College. Well for one, it isn’t a college, nor a place at all....   [tags: President of the United States, Electoral College]

Powerful Essays
927 words (2.6 pages)

Essay on Analysis of Iceland's Electoral College

- Iceland is a Nordic island state located in the Atlantic Ocean. Population of 315,281 and area of 103.000 square kilometers makes it the most sparsely populated country in Europe. Although highly integrated in the European market and the Schengen Area, Iceland is not a member of EU and currently has suspended negotiations that began in 2010, until the government can hold a referendum on the question whether or not to continue negotiations. (Pop 2013) Iceland is a parliamentary representative democratic republic, where the Prime Minister is the head of the government....   [tags: iceland, political systems, electoral college]

Powerful Essays
1932 words (5.5 pages)

The Electoral College Essay

- I choose to agree with the Electoral College. I don’t want a direct popular election because I want the smaller states to still have a voice, but, if America switches to direct popular election, the way things are, might just go worse. There are some good reasons for a direct popular election, and there are not good reasons for one too. I like the Electoral College a lot, and I would like the voting system to keep it that way. However, our founding fathers created the Electoral College, being the geniuses they are, created a good way to elect a president that would not cause chaos or havoc in the country....   [tags: Electoral College, USA,]

Powerful Essays
775 words (2.2 pages)