Powerful Or Helpless : The Ruse Of Choice With Meticulous Essay

Powerful Or Helpless : The Ruse Of Choice With Meticulous Essay

Length: 1373 words (3.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

“Powerful or Helpless: The Ruse of Choice with Meticulous Nuance”
Poem 303, or “The Soul selects her own Society,” is a strong poem written by Emily Dickinson. Dickinson creates a strong, unmoving voice belonging to “the Soul” who is supposedly choosing her companionships, but there are small nuances that may cause one to read the poem in various ways. The poem may be read with a tone that is godly and/or royal. It may also be read as the Soul having a choice on her companionships or the ruse of having a choice.
Firstly, one must attempt to summarize or describe the essence of the poem to argue for it. The use of metonymy, the “Soul”, represents the person about whom the poem is about. This person is choosing her companionship or “Society” and does it strictly and carefully. The Soul places herself above royalty and above things heavenly since she continuously does not move to their attempts at companionship with her. The nuance and importance of this poem is whether she truly has the power to choose her “Society” or not. Throughout the poem it seems to suggest and hint toward her inability to choose. With a quick, outer reading of the poem, it seems that she has the power and control,but when digging deeper and exploring her meticulous use of diction, simile/metaphor, short meter, and use of slant rhymes, it seems to suggest differently. Through careful analysis of those devices one may decide to read the tone of voice as a powerful or as helpless.
It is of utmost importance to note what type of diction Dickinson has selected, especially because the diction lends itself to the metaphors and similes used. There are two sides to her diction. One side may be described as heavenly, with words such as “Soul,” “divine,” and “gate.”...


... middle of paper ...


...ly veiled insistence under the initial reading, one where the “Soul” is actually crying for help. It could be that she wants to believe that she has the power but perhaps an opposing force, perhaps a mental illness or a person is influencing her too much regarding her ability to choose. Regardless of whether the Soul is powerful or helpless – although the latter seems to be argued when the poem is analyzed – it is a strong voice nonetheless. The unmovingness, the authority, and superiority of an emperor kneeling, and shutting out the “divine Majority” before her inevitably places her upon a pedestal. The tone many times sounds romantic and yet condescending especially on an initial reading, then sounds pressing and helpless through further analysis. The subtle nuances used via her literary tropes suggests an anxious, internal argument occurring throughout the poem.


Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Murder Of Helpless Human Life Essay

- The Murder Of Helpless Human Life “The care of human life and happiness, and not their destruction, is the first and only object of good government.” This quote from Thomas Jefferson rings so true because people take for granite the quality of life anymore. Abortion is the deliberate termination of a human pregnancy, most often performed during the first 28 weeks of pregnancy. Abortion has now become so much the a part of the American way of life. I have a son and when I became pregnant my boyfriend 's parents wanted me to get an abortion because we were both to young they said....   [tags: Pregnancy, Childbirth, Abortion, Fetus]

Better Essays
1040 words (3 pages)

Essay on The Argument On Pro Choice Abortion

- Anderson brings up point after point to support his opinion on pro-choice abortion. Anderson writes about how the government should have no say in a woman’s decision to abort even if she is past the first trimester: “Pregnancy and motherhood affect every aspect of a woman’s life - public and private, emotional and physical - and Roe v. Wade confirmed that it was an invasion of privacy for the government to step in and make reproductive decisions on a woman’s behalf” (Anderson, 2015). Anderson explains how he believes a woman who decides to have an abortion does it because it will negatively affect their life in a way that will be changed forever....   [tags: Pregnancy, Abortion, Pro-choice, Fetus]

Better Essays
1310 words (3.7 pages)

Essay on Ruse on a Biological Foundation for Ethics

- Michael Ruse argues that "The Biological Sciences Can Act as a Ground for Ethics." (p.297) He begins with a distinction between the normative and the meta-ethical, and then sets out to lay the foundations for normative ethics as a biologically driven adaptive function. He then moves on to justifying why we ought to behave as biology influences us to do, where he runs into a problem. People feel certain ways about what is right and what is wrong, Ruse begins, and these feelings are what become the moral maxims we follow (p299)....   [tags: philosophy, right, wrong]

Better Essays
1367 words (3.9 pages)

William Glasser’s Choice Theory Essay

- Dr. William Glasser was a distinguished psychiatrist and author known for his distinctive views about mental illness. Glasser broke away from the traditional model of psychotherapy in the early 1960s to develop his own model of counseling. Dr. Glasser began with the development of therapy before he developed his theoretical stance. Glasser created what is known as Reality Therapy. Glasser first defined Reality Therapy as “a therapy that leads all patients toward reality, towards grappling successfully with tangible and intangible aspects of the real world” (p.6)....   [tags: Choice Theory Research Paper]

Better Essays
2620 words (7.5 pages)

Shylock as Helpless Victim in The Merchant of Venice Essay

- Shylock as Helpless Victim in The Merchant of Venice         In 1594 the Earl of Essex, an English Nobleman who lived during the Elizabethan period in England, was actively involved in the persecution and trials of Roderigo Lopez.  Lopez was a Jew of Portuguese descent, who was wrongly accused of attempting to poison the Queen of England.  Lopez, being the Queen's royal physician, was in no position to defend himself once he was accused.  Essex, who provided the evidence also presided over the trial of Lopez, leaving Lopez little chance of survival.  The innocent Jew was hanged, drawn, and quartered in Tyburn, England for all to witness....   [tags: Merchant of Venice Essays]

Free Essays
2703 words (7.7 pages)

Infant And Infant Is Created Helpless Essay example

- An infant is created helpless, the infant depend on their mother for nine months for every need that they have. One day before the infant realizes what is going on they are being introduced to a new, loud, bright, big scary world. Right from birth the infant is poked and prodded and passed from person to person then the infant is placed in their mother’s arms. As the infant lays down on their mother’s chest the infant feels the warmth of their mother’s body. The infant hears a familiar sound of their mother’s voice as the infant on their mother’s chest then starts to cry....   [tags: Developmental psychology, Erik Erikson]

Better Essays
1672 words (4.8 pages)

Harold Brighouse's "Hobson's Choice" Essay

- Harold Brighouse's "Hobson's Choice" In Act two, Alice tells Maggie “I don’t know what you’re aiming at.” She replies, “The difference between us is I do, I always did.” Explain the differences between Maggie and her sisters. ‘Hobson’s Choice’ is set in Salford in 1880, at a time when women tended to occupy largely domestic roles. However, the leading character, Maggie Hobson, is a woman way ahead of her time. Unlike her sisters, she is a demanding and domineering character. She knows what she wants in life and is not afraid to strive for it....   [tags: Brighouse Hobson's Choice Essays]

Better Essays
1634 words (4.7 pages)

Essay on Maggie Hobson in Tim Sheader's Hobson's Choice

- Maggie Hobson in Tim Sheader's Hobson's Choice Maggie is an extremely bossy person, used to getting her own way. She is also stubborn and can easily manipulate people to do what she wants and is unlikely to change her mind on most matters. In act one of "Hobson's Choice." Maggie walks straight into the shop and immediately starts work "she crosses the shop and takes her place at the desk... she busies herself with an account book." This shows she has a sensible 'business like' mind....   [tags: Hobson's Choice]

Better Essays
2286 words (6.5 pages)

Pro-Choice Abortion Essay

- Abortion Abortion is one of the most personal, widely discussed, and controversial topics in American culture today. In most cases, people on both sides of the argument take worthy and moral positions. Who can blame someone who wishes to prevent the termination of a teen pregnancy to save the life of an unborn child. On the other hand, who can blame anyone who advocates the soon-to-be mother's right to make such a personal, heartbreaking choice. No matter what she chooses to do, should anyone have the legal right to force her to bear an unwanted child....   [tags: Freedom of Choice, Pro-Choice Essays]

Better Essays
1369 words (3.9 pages)

Essay about Pro Choice Abortion

- The topic of abortion is a hot subject among the people of America today. Some say yes, women should be able to have abortions no matter if the fetus is in the first trimester or well in to the second trimester of gestation. On the other hand the other people say that it is murder of a child no matter the stage of development. Many of the people that believe that the fertilized ovum is a human and has a soul at the conception are the pro-life people. They believe this because of their religious beliefs and cannot scientifically prove this in any way....   [tags: Freedom of Choice, Pro-Choice Essays]

Better Essays
493 words (1.4 pages)