The Popularity of Orphans in Frances Hodgson Burnett’s The Secret Garden and L.M. Montgomery’s Anne of Green Gables

1785 Words4 Pages

From infancy, children depend on their parents to do for them what they cannot do for themselves. They learn to recognize the faces of loved ones from an early age, and with no one else to rely on, they trust those loved ones to keep them safe and sound. But what about the children who aren’t fortunate enough to have another human being to depend on, the children who are left to raise themselves? Furthermore, is raising oneself from an early age a possibility or do such ideas only exist in fantasy? In “Abandoned Children” Rachel Fuchs suggest that “Any child who lives beyond birth does so only through his or her dependency on another human being” (Fuchs, 6) While this has proved true, especially during the nineteenth century when the survival rate of children was only a small percentage of what it is today, it is orphans, children who are forced to stand on their own two feet in order to beat the odds constructed by society, that make for exciting adventure heroes. Although authors may choose to base their stories on orphans for a variety of reasons, this essay will attempt to understand the motives behind choosing an orphaned protagonist. Characters like Mary Lennox in Frances Hodgson Burnett’s story, “The Secret Garden” and Anne Shirley in L.M. Montgomery’s story “Anne of Green Gables” are identifiable characters and it is because of the popularity of these characters that orphans came to be a commonly used protagonist in the literary world. It is difficult to understand why such sorrowful characters would be ideal literary heroes. “Unlike orphan stories, most describe a childhood more sweet and innocent than most, if not all, children ever experience.” (Nodelman, 220) Do readers find ‘Orphan stories’ enticing simply because the...

... middle of paper ...

...e heartstrings of readers in dissimilar ways, together, they demonstrate that children, even without familial structure, can find a way of reaching self-understanding and happiness. For Montgomery and Burnett, the usage of orphaned characters may have been taken from a range of possibilities. Through their characters, they proved that self-reliance and independence are qualities that any child, despite their upbringing, is capable of demonstrating. Additionally, the authors had roles in evoking the sympathy that truly defines a tragic character, and the era during which the tragedies occurred. Anne, Mary and the orphaned protagonists in the remainder of the literary world continue to prove that children, even those entirely independent from guidance, are every bit as capable of taking on the world as adults, and it is for this trait that they are adored.

Open Document