The Politics Of History By Howard Zinn And The Genius Of American Politics

The Politics Of History By Howard Zinn And The Genius Of American Politics

Length: 1171 words (3.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In “The Politics of History” by Howard Zinn and “The Genius of American Politics” by Daniel Boorstin, both authors largely focused on American history taught with Eurocentric ideals. Comprised of history through nationalist eyes, American history omits the struggles of minorities’ experiences. In “Why Study History?” Peter Stearns addressed that history’s main contribution is to provide a national identity. Vincent Harding and Joan Scott agree, arguing that it is important to include Black History and the history of Women to provide an identity for previously forgotten social groups. Properly writing history must include a variety of perspectives and firsthand accounts including minorities, so that the United States and American citizens can create a more inclusive and accurate national identity.
Daniel Boorstin argues that Americans need a variety of perspectives because their education does not include the negatives of the past. The education system in the United States is very one sided to promote nationalism. Boorstin makes it clear that “The American must go outside his country and hear the voice of America to realize his is one of the most spectacularly lopsided cultures in all of history.” For an American to not know the voice of their own country is a disgrace and this starts with the history that they are learning. Multiple views of the country and its history does not get taught to promote a nationalistic view of the country. Americans only know this and most of them never come to the realization that the country has imperfections and is seen around the world very differently. Boorstin says, “The facts of our history have thus made it easy for us to assume that our national life, as distinguished from that of history ...

... middle of paper ...

... heard. By including women and minorities Americans can be informed to be able to grow as a nation and eventually naturally include more than one side to their history of education.
The writings of Howard Zinn, Daniel Boorstin, Peter Stearns, Vincent Harding and Joan Scott put together a very strong argument for how historiography should properly be done. These historical writings should also be included in the education of Americans. For a well-rounded identity to be formed for the United States and American citizens their history needs to include a variety of perspectives and first-hand accounts. Both of these should include minorities and when these pieces are put into the history of America then the United States can reach a new level of success. This will allow for the American citizens to create an inclusive national identity for the United States of America.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Howard Zinn's Ideas on Motivations for War Essay

- Although many people assume the motivations for war are determined by a territorial protection, a number of scholars have added other motivations for understanding why war occurs, among these historians one is a conspicuous example his name is Howard Zinn. Zinn has exposed that many countries go to war in order to bring economic prosperity to their region this need for gain in turn causes many of the upper class of that region to acquire fantastic levels of wealth, many of these powerful figures have denied these claims, Zinn,in reaction to these claims uses paradigm example, WW1, as a means for discrediting the upper class who incessantly deny profits during war....   [tags: war, Howard Zinn, ]

Better Essays
563 words (1.6 pages)

Howard Zinn on History, by Howard Zinn Essay

- Howard Zinn: On History by Howard Zinn (2011) is a collection of previously published essays ranging from Freedom Schools in the 1960s, issues in scholarship, to the American Empire. Even though the essays were written over several decades there is a constant theme throughout the work—the activist scholar. Zinn feels that scholars should not be passive citizens concerned with their research alone, but active citizens that use their research to change society. Zinn, unlike other historians, is not afraid to place what he views as right and wrong into his scholarly work....   [tags: Activism, Historian, Society]

Better Essays
1482 words (4.2 pages)

Essay about Howard Zinn's A Review of A People’s History of The United States

- A Review of A People’s History of The United States      A People’s History of the United States concentrates on the personal experiences and struggles of people who lived in the United States from 1492-present. It is a view of history from the common man’s perspective, rather than the view of the leaders and upper class of this country.      The book revolves around the views of history from the oppressed point of view. Howard Zinn makes it clear from the beginning that he will value the views and experiences of the oppressed over the view of the oppressor....   [tags: Howard Zinn essays research papers]

Better Essays
1207 words (3.4 pages)

Analysis of Howard Zinn's Argument in his Article Dying for the Government

- Analysis of Howard Zinn's Argument in his Article "Dying for the Government" In June of 2003, Howard Zinn’s “Dying for the Government” was published in “The Progressive” newspaper. He discusses the government’s claim to military victory in Iraq, and he believes that many innocent people have died for an unjust cause in that war. His claim is that soldiers died for their government, not their country. An important part of his argument is his discussion of democracy, which he says is what our country is supposed to be based on....   [tags: Howard Zinn Dying For Government Essays]

Better Essays
1338 words (3.8 pages)

John Dewey And Mr. Howard Zinn Essay

- As we delve into the writings of Mr. John Dewey and Mr. Howard Zinn we notice a shared theme between the two authors, balance. However, both philosophers view the approach to reaching balance in different ways. In Zinn’s article The Uses of Scholarship, Zinn states that knowledge is a form of power. I find a great deal of truth in this statement. The presidential election of 2016 is on the rise. With that being said, even the most uninformed voter will elect the candidate he/she feels is the most knowledgeable to run our country, the candidate he/she feels is the most qualified to become the leader of our free world....   [tags: Sociology, Mind, Unconscious mind, John Dewey]

Better Essays
1599 words (4.6 pages)

Howard Zinn's Essay on The Pequot War

- When reading Howard Zinn’s essay on the Pequot war, one might not immediately notice the extreme bias in the writing unless he or she has prior knowledge of the Pequot war. It simply seems as though he is listing the facts, and that the Puritans were to blame for the war. In reality, however, history was different. The Pequots also fought in thewar. The extent of Zinn’s portrayal of the Pequots’ vulnerability is severe, and he even ignores important facts to support his opinions. This is completely inaccurate and can lead to misperception of British, Pequot, and Puritan history....   [tags: Literary Review]

Better Essays
723 words (2.1 pages)

Analysis Of Howard Zinn And James Loewen Essay

- History is and continues to be one of my most favorite subjects to discuss and learn about. When it comes down to it, I could never learn enough about this great country we have. How blessed by God and I am to be born in such a great country. One must know something in order to be proud to stand with it. This is why I love history. Because I have a love for America and gush with pride every time I talk about her. It excites me because it is part of who I am and who I always have been. This is why it is so crucial to have the right history....   [tags: Slavery, Slavery in the United States]

Better Essays
1499 words (4.3 pages)

The Other Civil War of a People's History of The United States Essay

- In chapter “The Other Civil War” of A People’s History of the United States, Howard Zinn described the underlying class tensions caused by industrialization during the nineteenth century. He claimed that these tensions would have led to radical labor reforms if the working class’s anger had not been directed towards other issues. Zinn used The Age of Enterprise by Thomas C. Cochran and William Miller to show the upper class’s indifference towards the problems of the lower class and to prove that the rich manipulated the poor to promote their own interests....   [tags: Literary Analysis, Howard Zinn]

Better Essays
1469 words (4.2 pages)

Analysis of A People’s History of the United States by Howard Zinn Essay

- ... And I was aware that no such book existed, that no such history existed. So I decided that I would try to fill that gap.” (1) A People’s History begins with a recounting of first encounters of the Native people with Christopher Columbus. Zinn’s opinions of the reality of these first encounters are substantially different from the stories we hear as children. We find Columbus traditionally depicted as a peaceful explorer who, after “discovering” a new land, made friends with the native people....   [tags: history, common, biased, gender]

Better Essays
695 words (2 pages)

Essay on Democratic America in the Eyes of Howard Zinn

- Democratic America in the Eyes of Howard Zinn In the first essay written by Howard Zinn he tries to answer the question of “How Democratic Is America?”. He seems to know what he is talking a great deal about government but it seems like anybody can just talk about how our government works and to say that that is the definition of democracy. The only thing he did differently was using an increase in vocabulary and try to talk about the same thing over and over again. Where Zinn could have said that democracy not only requires formal system of government equality to all Americans....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
657 words (1.9 pages)