While the reasons for the absence of a voting record are plentiful, the consequences for empirical research are the same: Inference about how observables are related to committee members’ vote choices is challenging. In search for means to make inference, some have turned to committees’ decision records. A decision record can generally be defined as a list detailing the decisions of a committee as a whole. In its most elementary form it is a list of which decisions have been adopted or rejected but it might also come with more information such as the margin of victory for the majority. If this decision record is available, it can be correlated with observables which often requires to summarize the member-specific variation of the observables with a statistic. In essence, the idea is to use decisions of the committee to learn about how observables are related to members’ vote choices.
As an example consider the United Nations Security Council ...
... middle of paper ...
...s are related to members’ vote choices or intends to make comparisons across institutional contexts, the structural model is a more suitable way of analyze decision record data.
I illustrate the application of the structural model with data from two distinct institutions: the U.S. State Supreme Courts and the U.N. Security Council. Using U.S. State Supreme Court abortion decisions collected by Caldarone et al. (2009), I illustrate how including a random subset of observed votes, mitigates the costs of aggregation. I also return to the example of the U.N. Security Council, re-analyzing data by Hultman (2013) on the correlation between civilians killed and the deployment of U.N. peace operations. I show that the effect on the vote choice probability with respect to changes in one-sided violence is quite substantial while the effect on the adoption probability is small.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- What is the importance of the UN Security Council. “The United Nations Security Council (UNSC) has primary responsibility, under the Charter, for the maintenance of international peace and security” (UNSecurity Council 2010). The end of the 1980s and the 1990s has been marked by major changes in international relations, both as practice and as an academic discipline. The collapse of the multi-polar system in the world politics, fall of the Berlin Wall, the end of the Cold War and the beginning of some state level wars transformed the international peace affairs with the Security Council in the international cooperation to resolve conflicts.... [tags: International Relations Politics]
2129 words (6.1 pages)
- Delegation from Represented by Russian Federation Palm Beach State College Position paper for the United Nations Security Council The international issues currently under discussion by the United Nations Security Council are: How to hand the current war with the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria, possible Measures that could be used to combat terrorism in Africa, and the Maintenance of International Peace and Security particularly in regards to Security Sector Reform (SSR). The Russian Federation hopes to come to be best solution for these problems with respects to every individual nation involved in the international community including those of the United Nations Security Council member stat... [tags: United Nations, United Nations Security Council]
1190 words (3.4 pages)
- “Chief responsibility for the maintenance of peace and security lies with the Security Council. It is therefore essential to its legitimacy that its membership reflect the state of the world.” – French President Chirac’s address to the United Nations General Assembly. Objective The focus of this paper is on the United Nations Security Council reform issue. It will start by giving some history on the United Nations charter and the Security Council. This background will set up a discussion on the past and present proposals to reform the Security Council.... [tags: UN World Politics Essays]
5425 words (15.5 pages)
- The United Nations Security Council is in desperate need of reform because of the current dysfunction which surrounds it. Any suggestion of reform could be idealistic. To not enlarge the Security Council is an option too. Over the years, proposals on the reform of the Security Council have included the enlargement of the Security Council, changes to the categories or proportions of membership of the Security Council, the addition of Regional Representatives and changes to the relationship between the Security Council and the General Assembly.... [tags: international peace and security]
1735 words (5 pages)
- The United Nations Security Council was set up in order to uphold and enforce the utopian ideals of international peace and security. This essay will argue that the UNSC is hampered in its goal by structural issues that impede international cooperation efforts for collective global peace and security. One of the issues examined in this essay are the adaptive failures of the UNSC in response to both global shifts in international relations philosophy and changes in power structure and politics. Another issue that will be argued is the flaws within the composition of the UNSC, especially in its ideas of regional representation and its primarily undemocratic setup.... [tags: International Government ]
2022 words (5.8 pages)
- The United Nations (UN) is an international organization that was formed after the Second World War. The main purpose of UN is to provide security and peace at the international level, resolve conflicts and protect human rights. The UN also promotes international co-operation by maintaining global social, political and economic conditions. However, it is difficult for many countries in the UN to partake in the decision-making because the UN is made up of different countries that have distinct political systems and ideologies.... [tags: United Nations, United Nations Security Council]
2002 words (5.7 pages)
- Security. Economically, socially, and humanitarianly, speaking. As well as peace, are what the United Nations wished to provide when it was founded in 1945 (Amrith 254). Multiple different individuals from numerous countries, both east and west, aided in its installment. United States’ President Franklin Delanore Roosevelt and his wife, Eleanor, were huge contributors to the founding of the United Nations (Amrith 253). The security and peace the U.N. was to provide was in high demand following World War II and so it was built around these ideas (Amrith 253).... [tags: international relations, diplomacy, politics]
1826 words (5.2 pages)
- Introduction The Security Council and the International Court of Justice, both were established around 60 years back, for the purpose of maintaining international peace and security by developing mutual faith and promoting cooperation between the countries who were the victims of the deadliest manslaughter that the world has ever witnessed, i.e. The World War II. In order to achieve the same objectives, in both the world vested enormous powers, so that in cases of conflicts peace can be restored through their intervention.... [tags: WWII, League of Nations]
1042 words (3 pages)
- The process of reforming the United Nations (UN) has been a highly debatable issue among the international community. Since the initial signing of the UN Charter in 1945, the world has changed dramatically as the UN is trying to regulate a forum that assesses and deals with global issues while also struggling to unite all 193 member states of the UN when some states have been seen to have conflicting ideas and personal agendas (Teng, 2003, pp. 2-3). This essay is targeted to highlight what I feel are the most pressing arguments for UN reform amongst the international community.... [tags: UN Security Council, international relations]
2031 words (5.8 pages)
- In this paper I will argue that the inclusion of Human Security in the UN mandate does not necessarily make UN Missions more successful. In order to do this, I have considered two UN Missions in the Congo. I have compared the two interventions that the UN had to make in Congo, first in 1960 when the Human Security framework did not exist and later in the period after 1997-2006 when Human Security became an important consideration. I have also analyzed the role of other states that were involved in the Congo during the two interventions in the context of Realism and assessed if the generalizations contained therein were applicable in this situation.... [tags: Congo, Security]
2873 words (8.2 pages)