Politically Correcting an American Classic Essay

Politically Correcting an American Classic Essay

Length: 915 words (2.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In 1884, a book by the name of The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn was published and released into the public spectacle. Mark Twain's novel of childhood misadventures takes place in the American deep south, and unlike other writers of the time, Twain had an unorthodox approach to the story's narrative style; that is, he wrote the tale in the vernacular of the book's setting (Shmoop.com). That same vernacular is being censored some one hundred and twenty seven years later, by a publishing company named NewSouth Books, who has released a version of the novel that replaces the amply used word, 'nigger', with what they believe to be less offensive in the word, 'slave'. Adam Kirsch and Lorrie Moore, both opinion editorial contributors to the New York Times, both give their opinions on the censorship of the American classic, and some side-thoughts on the usage of the the 'N-word' in contemporary society.
Kirsch's article, entitled, “The First Drafts of American History”, briefly remarks on a recent decision of the House of Representatives to omit the portion of the Constitution found in Article I, section 2, which mentions “three-fifths of all other persons” in terms of state representation (the 14th Amendment made this passage completely irrelevant), and uses this as a segue into his discussion of Huckleberry Finn's newly utilized euphemistic censorship. Kirsch states his side of the dispute, stating that, “[if you] start eliminating everything offensive in literary history, you'll have nothing left” (NYT), but also empathizes with those who would wish to replace the derogatory word, giving the example of a black thirteen year old high school freshman, having to read the novel and seeing 'nigger' 219 times, all in pejorative connot...

... middle of paper ...

... these lessons to be taught may not be the best answer. There are the exceptions, of course, to those willing to adhere to the curriculum of high school. Some families may disagree with how the book is taught, or even that the book is being taught at all, but the point still stands: at 18 years old, high school seniors are about to leave the bubble that is home, stepping foot into the first steps of what is known as “real life”. If they take that first step with a distorted sense of principles and integrity, then it will be harder for them to become resilient towards living life without a shoulder over their backs. This clearly is not entirely based upon the question of whether or not Huckleberry Finn should be taught in class, but it assists. As Kirsch mentioned, the books of classical praise obviously have something to them if they are being taught in modern day.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Elmer Kelton's "Politically Correct or Historically Correct" Essay

- In Elmer Kelton's "Politically Correct or Historically Correct" he mentions about the way people see and describe historical events. Some people can describe an event completly diffrent then how another person is describing it simply because it was seen in a different way then the other person. In fact, it could even be because one of the people is describing or telling the event the way it was told to him by someone else or simply because it is the way that he wants to interpret that event. Many of the people that write about historical events have a tendency to leave the bad side of it and always talke about the good side of things....   [tags: Politically Correct]

Free Essays
304 words (0.9 pages)

Coach As A Classic American Style Essay

- As many of us women know about buying luxury handbags, shoes and accessories. There are many companies that sell luxuries materials that consumers buy to fulfil their wants. As of today consumers grab more towards luxury material because they last longer and they are branded. These luxury material are not cheap instead they are beyond expensive, but consumer still continue to buy them. Due to consumer these luxuries companies are in business. As a owner of coach items I have researched them before I bought my first handbag by them....   [tags: Balance sheet]

Better Essays
1569 words (4.5 pages)

The Civil War: The Great American Tragedy Essay

- Causing four years of bloodshed on American ground, the Civil War was considered to be one of the most divisive wars in American history. Lasting from 1861 to 1865, the US Civil War was fought between the American people, mainly the northern states versus the southern states. There is a common misconception that slavery is the key issue that led to the American Civil War. However, there were several other reasons that pushed American into the “Great American Tragedy”. Because the North and the South were very different economically, socially, and politically, and with territorial expansion all of this eventually resulted in the Civil War, or the War Between the States....   [tags: socially, economically, politically]

Better Essays
920 words (2.6 pages)

The Importance of Being Politically Aware Essay

- Known to be off limits at family gatherings and a touchy subject in any other setting, politics always seems to bring out the worst in people. As a result, most Americans try to avoid involvement in politics. They find talking about the latest movie releases easier than discussing the huge national debt. But is it any wonder. Between the mainstream news, Internet sites, blogs, and other alternative media, trying to make sense of everything can be a daunting task. Sometimes pleading ignorance is simpler....   [tags: Argumentative, Persuasive Essay]

Better Essays
1699 words (4.9 pages)

Analysis of An American Tragedy and What Makes it a Classic Essay

- Analysis of An American Tragedy and What Makes it a Classic An American Tragedy is an intriguing, frighteningly realistic journey into the mind of a murderer. It is a biography of its era. And, it is also historical fiction. But what makes this novel a classic. While society has changed dramatically since 1925, Dreiser's novel, which shows the futility of "The American Dream" and the tragedies that trying to live it can cause, accurately summarizes social mores of this and any time period. Before Theodore Dreiser was born, his father, a devout German immigrant, lost everything when his large wool mill burned down (kirjasto.sci.fi 1)....   [tags: An American Tragedy Theodore Dreiser Essays]

Free Essays
3715 words (10.6 pages)

Classic Television Show: Leave It To Beaver Essay

- Wally Unloads A “Gopher” During the 1950‘s suburbs such as Levitown were springing up all across the country, and the so-called American dream was easier to achieve for everyday Americans than ever before. They had just come out of two decades dominated by The Great Depression and World War Two, and finally prosperity was in sight. The need for women to work out of the home that was present during the war was no more, and women were overwhelmingly relegated to female-dominated professions like nursing, secretaries, and teachers, if they worked at all....   [tags: american dream, expectations]

Better Essays
930 words (2.7 pages)

The American Classic Novel Of Kill A Mockingbird By Harper Lee Essay

- Banned Books The American classic novel, To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee, has been banned before. The novel is of strong contemporary national significance even though it was published in 1960 (Sullivan). The novel is taught in most high schools around the United States of America. To Kill a Mockingbird has been banned before because of the racism and language, stereotypes, and the history that is in the classic novel. Since it is in the realistic fiction category, it has some controversial issues (Mancini 65)....   [tags: White people, Black people, Race, Racism]

Better Essays
1388 words (4 pages)

Politically Correct Language Essay example

- Many times I have heard growing up, questions such as, “Why do we have to use politically correct language?” or “What is even the effect of me using politically incorrect english?” The use of politically incorrect english is the use of barbaric and intolerant language while describing a particular person or group. There are copious explanations of what politically correct english is and why it is used instead of randomly speaking conservative, out-dated, incorrect language to describe social classifications....   [tags: Reasoning and Arguments]

Better Essays
1085 words (3.1 pages)

Cold War's Impact on America Politically, Socially, and Economically Essay

- Cold War's Impact on America Politically, Socially, and Economically As the Soviet Union approaches Berlin from the East, the allied forces invade from the west. Hitler’s German war-machine was crumbling. The United States had to make an enormous decision. Should they attack the Red Army of the Soviet Union. Should they keep the increasingly shaky alliance with the Russians and end the war in Europe. America chose to remain allies, resulting in a decision that affected the world for the next 46 years....   [tags: War Cold Soviet Union Effect Papers]

Better Essays
1741 words (5 pages)

Mark Twain, the Classic American Writer Essay

- Mark Twain, the Classic American Writer Christened as Samuel Langhorne Clemens, Mark Twain was born on November 30, 1835 in the small river town of Florida, Missouri. He was the sixth child to John Marshall Clemens Jane Lampton, Twain grew up amid small-town life in Florida until the age of four, when his family relocated to Hannibal in hopes of an improved living situation. He is considered to be one of the major authors of American fiction. Twain’s varied works include novels, travel narratives, short stories, sketches, and essays....   [tags: Biography Biographies Essays]

Better Essays
1024 words (2.9 pages)