The Policy Of National Prohibition Essay

The Policy Of National Prohibition Essay

Length: 1972 words (5.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Assess the view that the policy of National Prohibition (1919-33) created more problems than it solved.

Prohibition was intended to reduce the manufacture and distribution of alcohol, and hence reduce the amount of crime, poverty and death rates, as well as improve the economy and the quality of life. Arguably, prohibition solved some of the problems to do with alcohol consumption of those from a low status background, as they could not afford drinks from new illegal establishments such as speakeasies. However, critics argue that the “noble experiment,” failed well before it was repealed in 1933. For example, although prohibition eradicated saloons, they were replaced by illegal bars known as speakeasies. Prohibition also led to other types of new crimes such as bootlegging, an increase in moonshines and the selling of poisonous alcoholic concoctions such as Soda Pop Moon. It also increased the rate of organised crime and gang warfare. Moreover, the fact that drinking was a traditional custom in America made it even more difficult to enforce. Consequently, the policy of National Prohibition created more problems than it solved by the increase of crime and overall alcohol consumption.

One of the problems that prohibition solved was that it led to the decline in the number of domestic violences. Parrish is right to claim that domestic violence was one of society’s major problems as it was one of the most reported offences. Pickett rightly supports this claim, as “wife beating and lack of family support decreased by 82%.” Alcohol clearly played a major role in this because men who drank it in excessive amounts regularly would have (revise) . Indeed, feminists correctly argue later on that liquor was the “leading source of physical...

... middle of paper ...

...he fact that it sharply increased by the penultimate years of Prohibition, suggested that the demand of alcohol was so strong, which led to the rise of organised crime, such as bootlegging, speakeasies and criminal gangs. Ultimately, Prohibition was not a healthy move because many people decided to turn to more dangerous substitutes such as heroin, hashish and cannabis. This had serious health consequences, such as addiction and shortened life expectancy. Due to the immense geographical size of America, prohibition was difficult to enforce, which also led to corruption. The limited number of underpaid police officers were usually bribed by illegal establishments to remain silent. Willoughby’s point is agreeable that the failure of prohibition was largely due to the fact that it was over-ambitious, resulting in many problems in America, that led to its repeal in 1933.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Social Policy : Drug Policy And Crime - Harm Reduction And Prohibition Essay

- Social Policy - Drug policy and crime - Harm reduction vs Prohibition Harmful drugs are an issue that creates controversy just by being mentioned, let alone acted upon by public policy. Despite this, policy actors must address drugs, through action or inaction, for the chance to make our society safer and healthier. Scientists and policy makers tend to agree that some drugs can be harmful to their users (Nordegren, 2002), but there are two broad camps of opinion on how best to protect users from these negative effects....   [tags: Policy, Government, Policy analysis]

Better Essays
1108 words (3.2 pages)

The Hopes and Realities of Prohibition Essay

- One of the biggest controversies of the twentieth century is the eighteenth amendment. Mississippi was the first state to pass the bill of prohibition. From there on out the entire country followed in Mississippi’s lead in the crusade of prohibition. The eighteenth amendment was a law, which tried to reform and protect the American people against alcohol, as some called, “the devil’s advocate”. The outcome of prohibition was more negative than positive and reeked more havoc than good on the American society....   [tags: Prohibition Essays]

Free Essays
806 words (2.3 pages)

The Prohibition and NASCAR Essay

- The Anti-saloon league museum is a standing testament of a period long gone. Located within the Westerville Ohio library, it houses important artifacts and memorabilia from the Prohibition era. At the height of its popularity, the league was a national organization which boasted branches across the United States.4. Along with various Christian organizations, the league was able to marshal resources that enabled it to bring the prohibition fight to congress and the senate. Tours and group presentations expose curious visitors to the inner workings of the league....   [tags: US History, Resolutions]

Better Essays
610 words (1.7 pages)

Essay on Prohibition: A Failed Policy

- Intro: On Jan. 17, 1920 the US government enacted what would be one of the most failed and harmful policies of our history. Within five years alone, New York city had up to 100,000 speakeasy clubs, and the addiction rate had gone up by 44.6. Crime, homicide, burglary, and assault and battery had all risen by double digest percentages as well. Just 13 years later, the same amount of time the iPod has been around, the age of prohibition ended. Einstein defined “Insanity: [as] doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results....   [tags: illegal, drugs, regulation]

Better Essays
1312 words (3.7 pages)

Alcohol in the Roarin' 20's Essay

- During the 1830s, the average American, 15 years or older, consumed seven gallons of pure alcohol a year (PBS). Since women had very few legal rights, they heavily relied on their husbands to provide for the family; however, men were the predominant abusers of alcohol. This resulted in havoc in the household along with altercations in public. Chaotic society commenced The Temperance Movement. Public Broadcasting Channel wrote, “The country's first serious anti-alcohol movement grew out of a fervor for reform that swept the nation in the 1830s and 1840s,” (PBS)....   [tags: unintended consequences of national prohibition]

Free Essays
639 words (1.8 pages)

Prohibition Of Marijuana And Its Effects On America Essays

- Prohibition of Cannabis For four and a half decades, the United States has fought and spent billions on the “War on Drugs.” Most recently, cannabis (marijuana, weed, THC) has been the focal point of this costly war. Since 1996, twenty-three states, with California being the first, have legalized cannabis for personal, medicinal, and recreational usage (Caplan 131). However, controversy over this not-so-new public enemy remains because it is still illegal under federal law. The War on Drugs is one without end....   [tags: Cannabis, Hashish, Global Marijuana March]

Better Essays
985 words (2.8 pages)

Essay on How Alcohol Prohibition Was Ended

- You saved the very foundation of our Government. No man can tell where we would have gone, or to what we would have fallen, had not this repeal been brought about. -Letter to the VCL, 1933 This is a story about a small, remarkable group of lawyers who took it upon themselves, as a self- appointed committee, to propel a revolution in a drug policy: the repeal of the 18th Amendment. In 1927, nine prominent New York lawyers associated themselves under the intentionally-bland name, "Voluntary Committee of Lawyers," declaring as their purpose " to preserve the spirit of the Constitution of the United States [by] bring[ing] about the repeal of the so-called Volstead Ac...   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
1874 words (5.4 pages)

Essay on The Costs of Marijuana Prohibition

- The Costs of Marijuana Prohibition The nation that we live in today proudly proclaims its perpetuation of freedom and democracy, and with these qualities it conveys supreme justice. The United States government and its constitution are regarded by many as the pinnacle of civil government, as the ultimate projection of civil justice. However, no government is perfect, for man himself is inherently imperfect. For over two centuries since its birth, The U.S. constitution, which many hold in such high esteem, has been continuously molded to fit our ever changing society....   [tags: Ethics]

Better Essays
1827 words (5.2 pages)

Essay on Cultural Report: Prohibition

- Cultural Report: Prohibition - “The Noble Experiment” The 1920s was an era brimming with changes in the social order and culture in the United States, and these changes evidently brought about anxiety and confusion over the evolving concept of “Americanness”. Prohibition, officially enacted on January 17, 1920, is viewed retrospectively as a lunging effort on the part of the “old money” European American population to impose their ideals, values, control and power in the face of drastic social changes that threatened their hold on power and influence in society....   [tags: Governement American History Essays]

Better Essays
948 words (2.7 pages)

Aust Prohibition Act Essay

- Various international treaties and conventions (e.g. International Narcotics Control Board), has provided Australia with guidelines and regulatory measures that the Commonwealth government must put into action within the criminal justice system. Australia became a part of significant treaties and conventions to uphold strong alliances with other nations (Such as the U.S.). The preparedness of Australian Governments to sign these various treaties, and modify domestic drug laws accordingly, seems largely to have been a function of the country’s subordinate status on the world stage, and its desire to be seen as a good ‘international citizen’, rather than being driven by concern within Austral...   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
618 words (1.8 pages)