1. In Plato’s Meno, Socrates claims that all learning is actually recollection (80d – 86c). What prompts Socrates to make this claim, and what does he mean by it?
As Socrates and Meno were trying to find out the essence of virtues, Socrates said: “The soul, then, as being immortal, and having been born again many times, and having seen all things that exist, whether in this world or in the world below, has knowledge of them all; and it is no wonder that she should be able to call to remembrance all that she ever knew about virtue, and about everything; for as all nature is akin, and the soul has learned all things1.” As he suggested, the soul has already known everything, and thus the acquisition of all knowledge is the process of remembrance, the process of the recalling what we have already known with the help of some hints.
How does he demonstrate to Meno that learning is recollection?
Socrates then managed to verify his theory by demonstrating it on one of Meno’s slaves. He did not directly teach or instruct anything to that boy slave who originally did not know about geometry. Instead, Socrates provided that slave with hints and guided his thoughts step by step. As a result, the boy slave found out a simple geometrical theorem which apparently “emerged” from his mind.
Do you find his demonstration persuasive? Why or why not?
Of course no. His claim that “Learning is recollection” is not convincing either. Basically this claim is completely apriorism, an idealist theory in which I do not believe. When it comes to his demonstration of that theory, I think his demonstration might be persuasive at that time, but simply does not hold water at all when put into modern society. The complexity of modern science has g...
... middle of paper ...
...k, therefore I am, was so certain and of such evidence that no ground of doubt, however extravagant, could be alleged by the sceptics capable of shaking it.” 4
Are you persuaded that the statement “I think therefore I am” is a certain truth? Why or why not?
I tried to change the “think” with other verbs and make the phrase look like “I eat, therefore I am” or “I walk, therefore I am”, but no word other than “think” really makes sense. Thinking is the only action that can pass the test of doubting because it is the basis of doubting. The action itself has confirmed the substantiality of thoughts, and thus confirms the existence of one’s self.
1. Meno. page 45
2. [V. I. Lenin，What Is To Be Done? (New York: International Publishers, 1961) p. 31.]
3. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cogito ergo_sum
4. Part IV Discours de la Méthode, René Descartes, 1637
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Cephalus is presumed to be the role model of Book 1 in Plato’s Republic: he examines his past with admirable insight, uses holy diction when discussing secular topics, and dutifully attends his sacrifices. In fact, Cephalus’ only fault seems to be teaching Polemarchus the wrong definition of justice: “doing good to one’s friends and harm to one’s enemies” (332d). Nevertheless, Socrates easily forgives this transgression as he respects Cephalus very much. However, through Glaucon and Adeimantus’ invalidation of Cephalus’ righteousness in Book 2, followed by Socrates’ direct rebuttal of Anytus’ claim from Meno, Plato reveals Cephalus is actually the most unjust character of Book 1.... [tags: Plato, Justice, Virtue, Philosophy]
1258 words (3.6 pages)
- The Republic: Protagoras, Gorgias, and Meno One vigorous line of thought in contemporary moral philosophy, which I shall call ‘Neo-Aristotelianism,’ centers on three things: (1) a rejection of traditional enlightenment moral theories like Kantianism and utilitarianism; (2) a claim that another look at the ethical concerns and projects of ancient Greek thought might help us past the impasse into which enlightenment moral theories have left us; (3) more particularly, an attempt to reinterpret Aristotle’s ethical work for the late twentieth-century so as to transcend this impasse.... [tags: Philosophy Morals Neo Aristotelianism Papers]
4435 words (12.7 pages)
- The questions of what exactly knowledge, virtue and the soul are, are among the most important problems of philosophy The soul may be defined as the ultimate internal principle by which we think, feel, and exist. If there is life after death, the soul must be capable of an existence separate from the body. The mysteries of birth and death, the lapse of conscious life during sleep, even the most common operations of imagination and memory, which abstract a man from his bodily presence even while awake; all such facts suggest the existence of something other.... [tags: essays research papers]
1338 words (3.8 pages)
- Socrates and Plato had a very distinct view on the human life and what constitutes a living of a “good life”-a life that would allow man access to the forms. Socrates was Plato’s teacher, and throughout much of Plato’s works, Socrates is the main character, who is ultimately the mouthpiece to express Plato’s ideas about life. These ideas were centralized around the idea of an immortal soul and one’s location of critical thinking and reasoning. Socrates and Plato believed that the soul was the home to reasoning and the body was a mere obstacle that hindered the pursuit of true knowledge.... [tags: Soul, Plato, Immortality, Socrates]
1927 words (5.5 pages)
- The Allegory of the Cave in Plato's Republic This paper discussed The Allegory of The Cave in Plato's Republic, and tries to unfold the messages Plato wishes to convey with regard to his conception of reality, knowledge and education. THE ALLEGORY OF THE CAVE Plato's "Allegory of the Cave" is a story that conveys his theory of how we come to know, or how we attain true knowledge. It is also an introduction into his metaphysical and ethical system. In short, it is a symbolic explanation of his "Theory of the Forms" (or eidos).... [tags: Papers]
909 words (2.6 pages)
- Plato's View in Human Knowledge Plato presents three different views about knowledge in Meno, Republic, and Theaetetus. In Meno's case, Plato believes knowledge as something innate in us when we are born; in his later view, in Republic, Plato believes we perceive things and gain knowledge; and from the last view, in Theaetus, Plato believes knowledge is the combination of a true opinion and a rational opinion. Strangely enough, Plato's views in Meno, Republic, and Theaetetus are similar, regarding the characteristics of knowledge.... [tags: Papers]
1400 words (4 pages)
- Plato's Vision Of The Ideal State As Presented In The Republic The concept of questioning meaning of life, the universe and everything has become debauched in modern society. But there is an exigency for and a value in the procedure of reasoning through aspects of our experience beginning with moral principles to existence. It can, for ordinary peoples as much as for professional philosophers, enlivening, vivid, and developmental. Plato is one of the most influential thinkers in human history. His philosophies have made a far-reaching impact on the human societies and have laid the foundation of many avenues of knowledge.... [tags: selfishness, utopia, God]
1275 words (3.6 pages)
- Plato was born around 428 BC, in Athens. As a child, his father died, his mother was a widow: someone who lost their husband and is single however, that did not last too long, because his mother remarried to a man named Pyrilampes. Plato was at birth, named Aristolcles, and had the title of Plankton. He had great interest in poetry and music; he was especially good in philosophy, which dealt with theoretical principles, and a field of philosophy called epistemology that explained human knowledge, and nature.... [tags: courage, justice, ideas, live, writings]
598 words (1.7 pages)
- Plato (circa 428-c. 347 BC) Plato was born to an aristocratic family in Athens. His father, Ariston, was believed to have descended from the early kings of Athens. Perictione, his mother, was distantly related to the 6th- century BC lawmaker Solon. When Plato was a child, his father died, and his mother married Pyrilampes, who was an associate of the statesman Pericles. As a young man Plato had political ambitions, but he became disillusioned by the political leadership in Athens. He eventually became a disciple of Socrates, accepting his basic philosophy and dialectical style of debate: the pursuit of truth through questions, answers, and additional questions.... [tags: essays research papers]
2476 words (7.1 pages)
- Philosopher. According to sources, Plato was born on or around May 21, 427 (or 428) B.C. in Athens, the son of Ariston and Perictione, both of Athenian aristocratic ancestry. He lived his whole life in Athens, although he traveled to Sicily and southern Italy on several occasions, and one story says he traveled to Egypt. Little is known of his early years, but he was given the finest education Athens had to offer the scions of its noble families, and he devoted his considerable talents to politics and the writing of tragedy and other forms of poetry.... [tags: essays research papers]
1730 words (4.9 pages)