Plato Vs. Thomas Hobbes Essay

Plato Vs. Thomas Hobbes Essay

Length: 1133 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview


Upon exposure under a modern viewpoint, with the benefit of hindsight to assist, the philosophies of Plato and Thomas Hobbes fall under an unequivocal category of judgment on how governments must run - specifically, that of complete authoritarianism. Throughout their lives, they pandered to delusions of assurance and refuge in absolute totalitarianism, with an insufficient amount of compelling evidence to bolster their assertions. Ordinarily, the enlightenment of enfranchisement in major countries like the United States should have abolished and denounced the ideologies indefinitely. Nevertheless, the philosophers and the administrative conceptions they supported receive unparalleled acclaim across the globe. Moreover, the doctrines still linger to influence the politics of today.

From 428 BC to 347 BC, Plato developed into a selection of the foremost of thinkers in primeval history. To establish his upbringing, he originated in Athens, Greece from a prosperous family, which commonly indicated that the he would immigrate into the province of politics. However, Plato failed in committing to a contending political party, and opted to study with the philosopher Socrates in matters of parliamentary and moralistic philosophy, before founding the Academy, his own institution. Throughout his lifetime, Athens had deteriorated between unfavorable conflicts, such as the Peloponnesian War, and the continuation of unscrupulous incumbents. Henceforth, Plato inductively concluded that the regimes in control could not receive redemption for their malfeasance against humanity. Furthermore, he postulated that only philosophers could administer the will of the commonality. Consequently, Plato’s findings led him to transcribe The Republi...


... middle of paper ...


...phies of Plato and Hobbes still prevail; without objection to their principles, they will always last in the consciousness of our overseers.
In the development of governments and society, the beliefs of philosophers Plato and Thomas Hobbes might have been perceived as an enlightenment to the world, but in reality hinder effective progress. Throughout history, totalitarian upon totalitarian seeks complete dominion over a commonality, and obtain encouragement from doctrines suggesting that only absolutism and consequentialism will achieve peace and order in the world. Unfortunately, even the powers-at-be who reject the concepts of tyranny embrace the constriction of liberty for the sake of security. But in the end, the guardians and sovereigns of the world will always arise. Ultimately, those who defend freedom and liberty must step up and defend their natural rights.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Plato 's The Republic And Thomas Hobbes Essay

- Plato’s The Republic and Thomas Hobbes’ Leviathan are key texts within the conservative tradition. They each explore the human condition and its relationship to society at large. The two theorists recognize the need for a hierarchical form of government to maintain order; however, they differ in their account of the effect of desires, and emotions on political order and hierarchy. Plato asserts that desires lead to the ultimate corruption of society, whereas Hobbes believes that certain innate desires can contribute to peace....   [tags: Thomas Hobbes, Political philosophy, Leviathan]

Better Essays
1376 words (3.9 pages)

Plato And Leviathan By Plato Vs. Hobbes Essay

- There is a diverse amount of themes that could be compared in Republic by Plato and Leviathan by Hobbes. Through these books the two authors each construct a system in which their ideal state can thrive. Both writers agree that government is necessary for the good of the people, however what that government entails drastically differs. Their images of a utopian society are largely based on their perception of human beings. Seeing as how their views on human nature are quite opposite from the other’s, it is understandable that their political theories have many dissimilarities....   [tags: Political philosophy, Thomas Hobbes]

Better Essays
966 words (2.8 pages)

Comparison Of Plato And Augustine 's Views On Psychology Essays

- Anuradha Singh Ethics Fall 2014 Hobbes “Pleasure therefore, or delight, is the appearance, or sense of good; and molestation, or displeasure, and love, is accompanied with some delight more or less; and all hatred and aversion, with more or less displeasure and offense” -Hobbes Both Plato and Augustine were psychologically insightful, even brilliantly so. Aristotle certainly delved into the logic of deliberation and action as deeply as any philosopher before or since. But the idea of basing ethics wholly on psychology is a distinctively modern idea, and one of its first and foremost proponents was the English philosopher Thomas Hobbes....   [tags: Thomas Hobbes, Political philosophy]

Better Essays
930 words (2.7 pages)

Essay on Thomas Hobbes : The New Era Of Philosophy

- Thomas Hobbes was born during the Spanish Armada on April 5th, 1588 in Westport, England. Abandoned by his father at an young age, Hobbes went and lived with his rich Uncle. The Uncle provided him with an education and sent him to Magdalen Hall at the age of 14. In 1608 he left college and became a tutor to the earl of Devonshire’s son. While he was a tutor, he was exposed to foreign lands and libraries with vast amounts of knowledge. While he was abroad, he studied the works of modern philosophers: Copernicus, Bacon, Gassendi and Galileo....   [tags: Thomas Hobbes, Political philosophy, Sovereignty]

Better Essays
1672 words (4.8 pages)

Essay about Plato, Machiavelli, And Lao Tzu

- “Goodness” in government Plato, Machiavelli, and Lao-tzu each have varying points of views on government. Plato’s political views have more similarities to that of Lao-tzu rather than Machiavelli. In general, most people believe that in order to have a strong country you must have a good government that cares equally for all of its citizens. According to Plato, leaders are those who ascend to a higher level of good and are then able to empathize with the people. Similarly Lao-tzu states “If you want to govern the people, you must place yourself below them....   [tags: Political philosophy, Thomas Hobbes, Government]

Better Essays
1641 words (4.7 pages)

Thomas Hobbes And John Locke Essay

- Living in a society that based on the social contracts we signed, government and man-written law are without doubt forceful defenders of the covenant itself. They provided benefits to its citizens as well as the protection to the state’s safeness. Nonetheless they should not be the only ground that justice lays itself on and shall never be the prerequisite for justice. To decide whether justice can be separated apart from government or law, we shall first focus on the conception of the state of nature: a hypothetical condition in which the government and law can be nowhere to find....   [tags: Political philosophy, Government, Social contract]

Better Essays
855 words (2.4 pages)

The British Tradition from Thomas Hobbes to the Utilitarians Essay

- The British Tradition from Hobbes to the Utilitarians Hobbes Thomas Hobbes (1588-1679) is an outstanding example of the independence of mind that became possible in Protestant countries after the Reformation. God does, to be sure, play an honourable role in Hobbes's philosophy, but it is a dispensable role. The philosophical edifice stands on its own foundations; God merely crowns the apex. Hobbes was the equal of the Greek philosophers in his readiness to develop an ethical position based only on the facts of human nature and the circumstances in which humans live; and he surpassed even Plato and Aristotle in the extent to which he sought to do this by systematic deduction from clearly...   [tags: Politics Philosophy Sociology]

Better Essays
743 words (2.1 pages)

Essay on Thomas Hobbes' Answer to Davenant's Preface to Gondibert

- Thomas Hobbes' Answer to Davenant's Preface to Gondibert   In his "Answer to Davenant's Preface to Gondibert," Thomas Hobbes takes a stab at literary theory. He is prompted to write the reply because Davenant mentions Hobbes in the preface to the epic poem, Gondibert. Hobbes notes up front that he is hindered in two ways because he is 1) incompetent in poetry and 2) flattered by the praise Davenant has lauded him. These hindrances don't prevent Hobbes from detailing a general theory of poetry....   [tags: Answer to Davenant's Preface to Gondibert]

Free Essays
1078 words (3.1 pages)

Thomas Hobbes' Leviathan Essay

- Hobbes; Leviathan Hobbes wrote the Leviathan and divided it into four different sections. For sake of brevity, I will only discuss the second book in, which Hobbes discusses the Commonwealth. He, like Rousseau, holds up the idea that the people of a society are better off by joining the social contract, which all humans are unintentionally apart of. In Book II, Hobbes asserts that there must be some form of leadership, which holds the people together and keeps them from following their natural instincts to gain power and use it in a malicious way....   [tags: Leviathan Essays]

Free Essays
629 words (1.8 pages)

The Common Good in Hobbes, De Tocqueville and Marx Essay

- The Common Good in Hobbes, De Tocqueville and Marx Political philosophies are those theories and ideas that seek to study the impact of various political idealisms on society, and their impact in the shaping of social, political, and economic ideas. The questions which political philosophy seeks to turn its attention towards range from describing what the state of Man actually is at the existential level, to the types of social regimes, which are necessary to tame and organise that nature. In this context, there is a measure of truth in the suggestion that the answers, or visions they give are not, necessarily, entirely original....   [tags: Philosophy Politics Papers]

Free Essays
2748 words (7.9 pages)