The Physician Or A Proxy Essays

The Physician Or A Proxy Essays

Length: 1291 words (3.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The recommendations of who should decide is if a patient is incapable of deciding for himself, the physician or a proxy must reach a decision in his stead. In order to respect patient autonomy, they should make a decision that is in keeping with the patient’s autonomous will. Even if physicians have good medical knowledge and have encountered a number of psychotic patients before, decisions cannot be based exclusively on their own knowledge and previous patient autonomy involves regarding the individual’s specific wishes and requests in our case the patient’s religious ideals. It could be argued that decisions regarding decision capacity are essentially non-medical and should rather be executed by a judge or a court of law. The same objections, however, can be used against this ‘lawyer as proxy’ model. In addition, the legal expert or jury lacks the medical knowledge that is useful in order to assess the patient.
The author concludes of the three types of argument in support of coercive treatment that we have discussed; only one is acceptable. Coercive treatment cannot be defended for the sake of protecting others. While coercive actions can be accept- able in order to protect close family and others, medical treatment is not justified for such reasons but should be given only in the interest of patients. Coercive treatment may be required in order to promote the patient’s health interests, but health interests have to waive if they go against the autonomous interests of the patient. Coercive treatment is, thus, acceptable only on the condition that the patient cannot make an autonomous decision about treatment and treatment is in the patient’s authentic interest. Coercive treatment cannot be defended when the patient makes an au...


... middle of paper ...


... to sure as to what I what was being tested but overall the article had enough information to review it.
The conclusions in each of the articles where very similar as far as the information aspect and the effectiveness they all were easy to understand and included a conclusion paragraph. They all tied in information about. The psychological articles the conclusion concluded that this healing process is very effective because there a numerous of ways this healing can be used and performed. The psychiatric articles were different because some of the medicine that was used in the studies did not work, caused an effect, and or did work. This is why it seemed to me that this healing process is not as effective. I support the healing that depends on a psychologist because the healing results were higher that the healing effective results of the help from a psychiatrist.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Munchhausen by Proxy and Its Effects on Children Essay

- Munchhausen by Proxy and Its Effects on Children Munchausen syndrome by proxy (MSbP), or factitious illness by proxy, is the form of child abuse in which a parent (most often the mother) deliberately produces an illness in the child. The perpetrator, by definition, suffers from a serious emotional disorder that impairs judgment. The emotional disorder is not diagnosable; its pathology is culturally invisible and masked by social adaptation (e.g., overreacting to the child's illness and emotional hunger)....   [tags: facticious illness, child abuse]

Better Essays
1533 words (4.4 pages)

Munchausen Syndrome by Proxy Essay examples

- The term Munchausen syndrome by Proxy was originally coined by Meadow in (1977), to describe a situation in which a caregiver "creates factitious symptoms or signs in order to mislead the physician into believing the child is ill" (Blumenthal, 106). Meadow (2002) further defines Munchausen Syndrome by Proxy, The children had incurred numerous needles and painful hospital admissions, investigations, and procedures because of a false story and factitious signs...the falsification was not by the patient themselves but by another person "acting on their behalf" which is a proxy (502)....   [tags: Psychology]

Better Essays
2109 words (6 pages)

The Living Will : Who Has The Power Of End Of Life Cases? Essay

- The Living Will: Who has the Power in End-of-Life Cases. A living will is a type of advanced health care directive, which states an individual’s wishes for health care treatment when he/she is terminally ill. Living wills are often applied to end-of-life decision making when patients are no longer deemed competent to direct care for themselves. The form of living wills can vary widely. But, most address whether or not to use life-prolong medical treatment such as CPR, respirators, and artificial nutrition and hydration....   [tags: Medicine, Health care, Patient, Health care proxy]

Better Essays
1430 words (4.1 pages)

Essay on Medicine And The Practice Of Medicine

- Medicine and the practice of medicine has been in use for thousands of years. It incorporates different technologies for the purpose of diagnosis, treatment and prevention of disease in order to restore or maintain health. But what guides physicians to make life and death or difficult decisions. Most would argue that physicians are guided by the principles of medical ethics. Medical ethics are a set of moral principles that apply values and judgments to the practice of medicine. The four values of autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence, and justice are commonly considered to be the fundamentals within medical ethics....   [tags: Health care, Medicine, Health care proxy, Patient]

Better Essays
1367 words (3.9 pages)

Support For Providing Culturally Competent, Evidence Based Nursing Care Essay

- Advocating for Providing Culturally Competent, Evidence-Based Nursing Care Healthcare is changing and with these changes come challenges regarding the best way to allocate funds to provide high quality healthcare and improve patient outcomes, while containing costs. Therefore, it 's imperative that we as nurses speak up and work together to advocate for ourselves and our patients in an effort to change healthcare policy and improve patient care. An advocate is defined "as one that pleads, defends, or supports a cause or interest of another and advocacy is "the process of building support for an issue or cause and influencing others to take action" (Tomajan, 2012)....   [tags: Health care, Nursing, Medicine, Physician]

Better Essays
819 words (2.3 pages)

Essay about The Role Of Parental Consent

- The role of parental consent is a significant factor in the medical world. To give consent to do medical operations or treatments, informed consent is needed. Consent cannot usually be given by children since they are not deemed competent enough, so the responsibility is given to the legal guardians. Many controversies have arisen due to minors needing consent from parents for medical procedures. Is giving parents the power to decide on their child’s medical treatment always just. I believe that parental consent plays both a positive and negative role in medicine....   [tags: Medicine, Informed consent, Autonomy, Physician]

Better Essays
1563 words (4.5 pages)

Symptoms And Treatment Of Medical Care Essay

- Patients play a big role, in which they need to ask lots of question and stay informative about every procedure and medication they are going to consume. They need to make sure how many doses, the type of medication and how many times a day, because they could overdose them self if they take more than needed. Therefore, advance directive is where the patient chooses the type and how many medical care they wish they want to be provided with. Theirs time in where patients are placed a proxy; the authority to represent someone else....   [tags: Physician, Medicine, Patient, Hospital]

Better Essays
1113 words (3.2 pages)

Thank You For Contacting The Ethics Committee Regarding Mrs. Mitsue Takahashi 's Healthcare Plans

- Thank you for contacting the Ethics Committee regarding Mrs. Mitsue Takahashi’s healthcare plans. As you are aware, 83 year old Mrs. Takahashi was recently admitted to the hospital immediately following a stroke. Through looking at her past medical history and running various tests, it was apparent that she suffers from several serious medical complications. Notably, she suffers from dementia which makes it impossible for her to make autonomous decisions concerning her healthcare. Despite poor prognoses from neurology, cardiology, and psychiatry consultations, the patient’s two grandchildren disagree over the next step in their grandmother’s healthcare....   [tags: Family, Medicine, Physician, Patient]

Better Essays
1106 words (3.2 pages)

I Am A Choice Of Becoming Psychiatrist Essay

- I have often wondered how I happened to make a choice of becoming psychiatrist. All I can figure is that something I read or heard must have convinced me that this would give my life the meaning it seemed to lack or maybe provide with answers I was looking for. I am aware of steps I tool after that to learn more about what was involved in that profession, how I turned an inner conviction and ambition into reality over years, but I never have learned what that initial deciding incident was….. Being raised by the teacher of Russian literature, I learned all the corners of “mysterious Russian soul” from the classical literature characters with their complexity....   [tags: Psychiatry, Medicine, Physician, Psychiatrist]

Better Essays
1143 words (3.3 pages)

Essay on Hypochondriasis and Munchausen by Proxy

- For my research paper I chose the two mental illnesses of hypochondriasis and Munchausen by proxy. I chose these topics because I have an aunt related by marriage who is thought to have hypochondriasis and Munchausen by proxy because like hypochondriasis it can be used as a way to gain attention or sympathy from others. I will start off with hypochondriasis since it is the illness I have the most familiarity with. Hypochondriasis is defined in the DSM-IV-TR under somatoform disorders as “Preoccupation with fears of having, or the idea that one has, a serious disease based on the person’s misinterpretation of bodily symptoms.” This preoccupation of having an illness will persist even after m...   [tags: Mental Health ]

Better Essays
2005 words (5.7 pages)