On her death bed Gretchen Weirob is looking for a slightest possibility of her surviving, but she cannot find anything that will prove that she, as Gretchen, will live to see another day. Weirob is not looking for any hope, only one proof that can show that her survival is possible, but can’t seem to be persuaded. I’m going to argue that Gretchen Weirob argument is valid.
Weirob believes that personal identity is consisting of combination of a person’s thoughts, memories, feelings, and experiences. According to her: “Survival means that tomorrow or sometimes in the future there will be some one who will experience, who will see and touch and smell-or at the very least, think and reason and remember…And I am related to her in such a way that it will be right for her to remember what I have thought and done”.To her “identity is the condition of memory and correct anticipation”. At the beginning of her argument Weirob agrees that an actual physical body does not fall under the concept of a “self”, she acknowledge that her body will die, be buried, and eventually rot in the ground. Along with the Kleenex metaphor, the physical attributes does not defy how a person shall identify his/her self.
The person can look different or can get a facial reconstruction, but his/her family will still know it is that person, from the way he/she talks and acts. A person’s character evolves and eventually becomes unique due to that person’s experience, memories. But the only way these memories can be obtained and stored is within physical substance o...
... middle of paper ...
... , as Gretchen , will never exist again, no matter how much of a persuading Miller and Cohen can do.
It will be impossible for the same person to survive in the same form, with the same physical attributes it previously lived and died. It is unclear if the soul or a human essence can carry out beyond human perception, but if it can it will survive without these attributes, or memories, or thoughts, etc. She clarifies with Miller if he means that words “soul, “self”, “mind”, and “consciousness” are come to the same thing, and distinction is irrelevant. But what’s relevant that all these words describe non-physical and non-material aspect of a person. If that non-material soul exists, there is no way to measure for how long it can exist. Therefore, there is a possibility that it can live longer than its body, or outside of the body.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- My mother shouted “Kabayo!” meaning horse, as she looked in the mirror at her first pair of dentures. The misalignment and bulkiness failed to meet her desired look. Perhaps our family finances set a limitation on material selection. After the delay, the effects of the new pair were immediate to her attitude. Whatever the setback, I’ve continued to learn my favorite traits: patience and determination. Self-identity is influenced by the thoughts of one’s physical features and experiences. I, too, became self-conscious about my teeth as they grew in; I’d squeeze them together.... [tags: Dentistry, Oral and maxillofacial surgery]
725 words (2.1 pages)
- The Concept of Identity To answer this question, it is important to first understand what is meant by identity. Identity concerns both self-identity and social identity. It is best understood not as an entity but as an emotionally charged description of ourselves. It is about the personal and the social as well as about us and the relations of others. It has been argued that identity is wholly cultural in character and does not exist outside of its representation in cultural discourse. Identity is ultimately not a fixed ‘thing’ but a becoming.... [tags: self and social identity, colonialism]
2211 words (6.3 pages)
- Stage 1: Identity Confusion This is the "Who am I?" stage associated with the feeling that one is different from their peers This stage also is characterized by a growing sense of personal alienation. The person begins to be conscious of same-sex feelings or behaviors and to label them as such. It is rare at this stage for the person to disclose inner turmoil to others (website). In terms of career counseling, a person in this stage may start to look at careers that are outside of their comfort zone.... [tags: Identity Model]
867 words (2.5 pages)
- Identity Theft Through Social Media Identity thieves are now making their way through social media sites, targeting more innocent people than ever . There are four major way 's peoples identity 's are at risk with the use of social media , these risks include general information ,facial recognition ,status updates ,and internet invitations ,these are the major way 's identity theft is made possible through social media. The first way identity thieves are stealing others identities through social media, is simply by looking at a person 's general information .... [tags: Identity theft, Theft, Facebook, Twitter]
1204 words (3.4 pages)
- Identity thieves are now making their way through Social media sites, targeting more innocent people than ever . There are four major way 's people identity 's are at risk to the use of social media . These risks include general information ,facial recognition ,status updates ,and internet invitations . Once these areas of information are reached peoples identities are easily accessible ,knowing this information could be vital to any persons life . This is how identity theft is made possible through social media .... [tags: Identity theft, Theft, Facebook]
1244 words (3.6 pages)
- Identity in Reality and Cyberspace According to Websters College Dictionary, identity is defined as, "the state or fact of remaining the same one, as under varying aspects or conditions." There are many claims made about the nature of identity in cyberspace. Such claims about the Internet is that you can act or express your personal opinions as another, without anybody knowing your true identity. I feel that being another identity can be very controversial and constructive at the same time. These types of aspects of changing yourself can be seen in online environments which can be over-abused and perceived as a way to express yourself and ideas.... [tags: Web Internet Online Identity Essays]
1522 words (4.3 pages)
- Creative & Personal Expression Personal and creative expressions are an alternative approach to traditional academic writing. They employ personal experiences to convey anecdotal narratives. Personal narrative in scholarly writing allows for a broader spectrum of emotion, such as empathy, compassion and humanity. This style no longer confines argumentative research to the empirically verifiable. For the reader, creative and personal expression allows for a broader chance of identification with the text.... [tags: Feminism, Gender, Academia, Sexual intercourse]
1001 words (2.9 pages)
- Cybercrime and social media are two major global problems that impact society. Today, are more accessible to computers and the Internet than in years prior. Nonetheless, perpetrators attack social media with illegal activity to facilitate their crime. There are different strategies or practices by various countries to combat cybercrime. However, identity theft, cyberbullying and phishing are three major type of cybercrimes which are impacting social networking websites. Many factors play right into the advantage of identity theft through social media.... [tags: Social network service, MySpace, Identity theft]
996 words (2.8 pages)
- Being label is something that has it up and down. Not everyone likes to label and others like to be label because it gives them their identity and shows their personality. The words that are used to describe ourselves can have effect on others and us. Are you an optimist. Would you like to become an optimistic person now or any time in the future. Being optimistic is a choice, not everyone able to be one because it is how personal characteristic. Optimism is believing that good things will happen in the future, or feeling confident that you will succeed.... [tags: Academic degree, Bachelor's degree]
758 words (2.2 pages)
- Major Theories Regarding the Nature of Personal and Social Identity Richard Jenkins said that ‘Without social identity, there is in fact, no Society’. Sociologists see identity as related to the society in which people live. They believe that our identity is formed against a social background, which tries to make social interaction meaningful, understandable and organised by categorising people in order of the group they belong to. Because we are categorised in such a way, we become recognisable as people such as mothers, daughters, students etc.... [tags: Papers]
1578 words (4.5 pages)
- Clinical Features, Diagnosis, Treatment And Prognosis Of Eoe
- The Stranger By Albert Camus
- Human Suffering And Animal Suffering Should Be Given Equal Consideration
- The Great Gilly Hopkins By F. Scott Fitzgerald
- Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorders ( Fasd ) Is Not A Diagnosis
- Gender Stereotypes And Its Impact On Society