Essay on Performing Animals: The Ill Treatment of Performing Orca’s in Captivity

Essay on Performing Animals: The Ill Treatment of Performing Orca’s in Captivity

Length: 1740 words (5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Immanuel Kant, an 18th century philosopher argues that human beings have an intrinsic worth that makes them valuable above all else, especially animals. In his argument, Kant postulated the soul as necessary for giving unity to the human person and found that it is not the human body that gives human beings their dignity, but their rationality and their status as rational beings and moral agents. Animals in Kant’s state of mind are a means to an end (the end being man) and overall have no importance. But if rationality is the key to being dignified, then animals are dignified organisms and in turn have great importance to this world than Kant gives them credit for.
Animals are rational. Based on behavioral dispositions humans have observed and studied such as hunting patterns and seasonal migration routes, animals make decisions based on their upbringing, experience, and current environment that best protect themselves just as a human would. When an Orca (the scientific name for killer whales) calf is first born, they spend approximately 10 years with their mothers learning survival techniques such as baiting their prey and following the leader of the pods direction before they venture off to begin their own family or pod. That is the same behaviors humans experience throughout their first 18 years of life. How can humans label themselves as dominant due to their ability to rationalize without including the rationality animals have that we simply do not and probably will not fully understand? The only difference between humans and other species are the direction of evolution taken to get us to where we are now. Eons ago, we humans had tails that aided in our survival momentarily just as whales had feet that aided in their survi...


... middle of paper ...


...ment in technology and economic shifts tune out. In the wild, orcas are peaceful examples of the beauty of life and its multiple mechanisms that contributes to its continuation. They go on living their lives without ever interfering with our own yet we have on multiple occasions disrupted their own. This now raises the question on whether Kant was accurate in his theory that humans are the sole rational agents present on this Earth because their actions and lack of consideration for the role, presence, dignity and meaning animals such as Orcas have on Earth also.






Works Cited

Rachels, James. "Kantian Theory: The Idea of Human Dignity." The Elements of Moral Philosophy (1986): 114-23. Print.
"Blackfish - Seaworld Bites Back." Blackfish Official Film Site. N.p., 15 July 2013. Web. 23 Mar. 2014. .

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Treatment of the Mentally Ill Essays

- Some of the most painful and torturous of all illnesses are those of the mind. There are many of instances of insanity among humans throughout history, some dating back to around 400 B.C. (PBS). These people were not considered human, but instead they were looked at as animals. There were several attempts to “cure” people of this kind, yet most were inhumane and brutal forms of torture. Many times, especially in early history, these people would be locked away and treated as if they had no purpose but to waste space....   [tags: health, mind, mentally ill]

Powerful Essays
1783 words (5.1 pages)

SeaWorld's Orca Whales Essay

- The Orca or “killer whale” is the largest member of the dolphin family. Weighing up to six tons the Orca’s power and large size make it one of the fastest marine animals, reaching speeds up to 35 mph. Orca whale societies are pods of up to 40 individuals and all pods use hunting techniques close to what a wolf pack would use, but when in captivity Orcas do not have this freedom. In an Orca society, females are dominant, and many Orcas live with their mothers their entire lives. SeaWorld’s Orca shows should be illegal because captivity causes the Orcas too much stress, they are responding with violence among the others, themselves, and to human beings, and with OSHA’s bans captivity becomes...   [tags: Orca, Killer Whale, Dolphin Family, Sea Mammal]

Powerful Essays
889 words (2.5 pages)

Essay about The Ill Treatment Of Street Dogs

- ‘How comfortable he looked!’ The calm smile on the face of the dog that I had just rescued warmed my heart. Brutally beaten by my neighbor, the dog limped towards me. I rushed this street dog to the veterinary hospital and got him treated for his injuries. Returning home, I felt an urgent need to do something for him and the other dogs, who I believed would meet the same fate. I informed the sector committee, delivered presentations on the ill-treatment of street dogs, and convinced the 350 residents of my locality to create a safer environment for these creatures....   [tags: Physician, Medicine, Health care, Medical school]

Powerful Essays
839 words (2.4 pages)

Essay Treatment And Treatment Of Terminally Ill Patients

- Even though many dispute over the value and usefulness of treatment and care of terminally ill patients, the debate for the most useful care and pain reliever for these patients is the question that most patients, and their families, have to ask themselves daily. Wesley J. Smith suggests that Hospice care for patients with such a horrible illness is a beneficial program and that many patients need to utilize it. Smith also recommends that a valuable care option would be to “allow the terminally ill to enter hospice care without having to give up life-extending or curative treatments”....   [tags: Hospital, Patient, Medical terms, Illness]

Powerful Essays
882 words (2.5 pages)

Essay on The Treatment Of The Mentally Ill

- In the years prior to Pinel’s contribution to the treatment of the mentally ill, patients were not treated with the same respect as they are now. It is difficult to imagine how these patients were treated and the pain they must have felt as they were put on display as if they were caged animals in a zoo. The only cause of this was because no one understood what these mentally ill patients were feeling. But, as time went on and Philippe Pinel entered the world of treatment for the mentally ill, the people were able to better understand who these “beasts” really were....   [tags: Brain, Psychology, Perception, Cognition]

Powerful Essays
702 words (2 pages)

Forced Treatment of the Mentally Ill Essay

- Torture, for weeks, for months, for years, but it is somehow plausible to consider it help. The sane being shoved into a psych ward, drugged, and forced with erroneous treatments, yet this is regarded as the panacea. Mental institutes do not solve everyone’s problems. Forced treatment on the resistive or illegitimate mentally ill exemplifies the need to regain civil rights for patients. The current laws applied to the topic remain not enough to withhold these patients’ civil rights. Also, patients bias court cases while influenced by prescribed drugs....   [tags: psychiatric patient rights]

Powerful Essays
913 words (2.6 pages)

Treatment or Not for Criticallly Ill Essay

- ... However, it is chosen by various patients who are critically ill yet competent enough to make this decision. According to American Medical Association, unlike old times now most of the patients die either in hospitals, or in long term care facilities and 75 percent of all deaths in 1987 occurred in either hospitals or long term care centres. Nurses should incorporate these research findings in their practice because taking care of a palliative patient is difficult without understanding the patient and the situation of the patient....   [tags: medicine, patient, ethical]

Powerful Essays
784 words (2.2 pages)

Treatment Of The Mentally Ill Essay

- or policies that are aimed in helping the mentally ill. Which consequently impacts the availability of resources and funds for mental health care (Barry and Jarlenski, 2014). Treatment Evolution in the United States and around the world (Barrier) Without the appropriate resources, treatment for mental illness can be significantly limited or crippled. Just as stigmatized mental illness has been, so have its various methods of treatment. Treatment for mental illness has not always been where it currently is today, it has gone through multiple changes through the centuries, some of which have not been so favorable in the public’s eye....   [tags: Psychiatry, Mental health, Psychiatric hospital]

Powerful Essays
1562 words (4.5 pages)

Essay about Treatment Of The Mentally Ill

- Deinstitutionalization Deinstitutionalization is the process of replacing stay-in psychiatric hospitals, with community-based services for those with a mental illnesses. Community integration has been beneficial for people with high functioning mental illnesses. Unfortunately, many, who have severe mental illnesses, cannot function alone in society. As a result of deinstitutionalization and inadequate care, they are left homeless, drug dependent, and incarcerated. The major start to institutionalization of the mentally ill began in the 1840’s, after a woman named Dorothea Dix visited an East Cambridge jail full of people with various mental illnesses....   [tags: Mental disorder, Psychiatry, Psychiatric hospital]

Powerful Essays
1239 words (3.5 pages)

Treatment Of The Mentally Ill Essay

- The most common definition of mental illness is a condition that affects a person’s behavior, mood, or thought processes. In the past century the field of psychology which studies and attempts to understand how humans think, has made tremendous progress and much needed improvement. Treatment of the mentally ill has also improved since Victorian times. As science becomes more advanced, further insight into the human mind is discovered and beliefs that used to hold true are disproved. The Victorian times are described as, “a period in which the sexual impulse was systematically repressed and deformed” (Rosenberg, Charles E 132)....   [tags: Psychiatry, Mental disorder, Psychiatric hospital]

Powerful Essays
1536 words (4.4 pages)