Essay on Perception Of Language Over Thought

Essay on Perception Of Language Over Thought

Length: 2090 words (6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview










Perception in Relation to Language
Julianne Fritz, Carlos Herrera, Mo McDonald, Erick Ramirez
San Diego Mesa College











Abstract
The influence of language over thought has been largely disputed over time. If language does have an effect over cognition, would polyglots be able to perceive a single idea through multiple lenses? And if so, does the lens of perception change every time one changes the language being spoken? The Spanish and English language greatly differ in the way nouns are conjugated in the everyday dialogue. In the Spanish language, all nouns have a gender while, in the English language, the same nouns would be gender-neutral when translated. Speakers of both languages were surveyed order to test whether Spanish speakers would describe an image using more gender-specific adjectives when asked in Spanish than English speakers would when asked to describe the same image in English. The results showed that slightly more English speakers described the images using the translation of gender-specific adjectives than Spanish speakers but not enough to carry any statistical significance. Although this study does not support our hypothesis, it provides a foundation of the understating of cognition in relation to language as well as a method of research that can be built on by eliminating confounding variables.

Background
The idea that our thought is shaped by language is associated with the writing of Benjamin Lee Whorf (Boroditsky, Schmidt, Phillips, 2003). “The linguistic relativity (Whorfian) hypothesis states that language influences thought. In its strongest form, the hypothesis states that language controls both thought and perception” (Hunt, Agnoli 1991). Whorf was impressed by the diversi...


... middle of paper ...


...o Testing the Whorfian Hypothesis. Retrieved fromhttp://web.a.ebscohost.com/ehost/detail/detail?vid=18&sid=f0d7818c-2edf-4384-a9d25abdbb6a6188%40sessionmgr4003&hid=4209&bdata=JnNpdGU9ZWhvc3QtbGl2ZQ%3d%3d#db=pdh&AN=1991-32731-001

Sera, M. D., Elieff, C., Forbes, J., Burch, M. C., Rodríguez, W., & Dubois, D. P. (2002).
When language affects cognition and when it does not: An analysis of grammatical gender and classification. Retrieved fromhttp://libraryaccess.sdmesa.edu/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direc =true&db=pdh&AN=2002-15433-005&site=ehost-live












Appendix A










Appendix B









Appendix C


Appendix D


Chart showing average gender-based choices for both groups, bilingual Spanish speakers, and native English speakers.



Appendix E


Chart showing Spanish gender-based and English gender-based responses.
Appendix G

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Does Language Influence Our Perception Of Reality And Thought? Essay

- As time passed, the subject of whether language influence our perception of reality and thought has been introduced by a plethora of linguists and philosophers. People have been asking this for many years. Yet, the subject has been a dilemma that is hard to answer. However, The subject gained prominence when Benjamin Whorf asserted in his essay that “ we need to recognize the influence it [language] has on other activities, culture and personal.” (Whorf 1944: p.135). Based on his studies, Whorf claimed that Hopi and, what he called, SAE (Standard Average European) speakers have distinct experience of reality that is due the difference in language....   [tags: Mind, Psychology, Perception, Cognition]

Strong Essays
717 words (2 pages)

The Perception Of Categorical Perception Essay

- Introduction of Categorical Perception Everyone has experienced hearing a language they do not understand. In that context, the words seem to consist of a meaningless series of sounds; this is often ascribed to the listener not knowing the definitions of the vocabulary used. However, in addition to not being familiar with the words said, a person who does not understand the language will hear and process the sounds differently than a native speaker. This fact is partially explained by categorial perception, a perceptual-learning phenomenon in which the categories of different stimuli possessed by an individual affect his or her perception....   [tags: Perception, Psychology, Cognition]

Strong Essays
1347 words (3.8 pages)

Perception Of The World Of Perception Essay

- Before diving into the world of perception, I wasn’t aware of how differently the world is perceived by different humans and different animals. While researching for this paper, I witnessed first hand how different various perceptions could be. Like most Americans on Sundays, my family and I were sitting by the Christmas tree and enjoying a game. During the game, I remember how differently my mother and I reacted to Russell Wilson getting tackled by the opposing team. While I believed that Wilson took one of the worst hits he had all game, my mother at the same time said that she believed the hit wasn’t that bad....   [tags: Perception, Sense, Sensory system, Illusion]

Strong Essays
1828 words (5.2 pages)

The Language Barrier : ' The Limits Of My World ' Essay example

- The Language Barrier Ludwig Wittgenstein wisely said, “The limits of my language mean the limits of my world” in Logico-Tractatus Philosophicus. Language colors our reality and the world, and what we see is shaped by the language we use. Speaking one language makes us think the rest of the world perceives the world in the same way. Mastering two or more languages shows us that the world’s outlooks are different with each language (Postman 124). Susumu Tonegawa, who won a Nobel Prize in Medicine in 1987, was quoted in a newspaper, Yomiuri, acknowledging that the Japanese language didn’t emphasize clarity (Postman 124)....   [tags: Mind, Thought, Cognition, Language]

Strong Essays
1050 words (3 pages)

Essay on Phenomenology : The Essence Of Perception And Consciousness

- Merleau-Ponty defines phenomenology as the study of essences, including the essence of perception and consciousness. He also says that phenomenology is a method of describing the nature of our perceptual contact with the world. Phenomenology also tries to bring to light the experiences that we create when we are introduced to the world around us. The first thing that Ponty addresses is our perception and how it is related to our experiences. We perceive objects as soon as we encounter them, but when we encountered them we only experience one version of it and that is a problem....   [tags: Mind, Perception, Psychology, Cognition]

Strong Essays
1720 words (4.9 pages)

Being At The Center Of Human Thought Essay

- After the second and third week of this course, I feel as if I am seeing things in a way I never have before. The idea that stuck out to me this week is that of interaction being at the center of human thought, ideas, and overall lives. I am not sure why I was surprised to hear this, but I think it is because of the fact that I spend a lot of time secluded from others and decided that that time was interaction-less, which is not the case. Even alone, I interact with myself. I talk, think, and listen, all to myself....   [tags: Time, Thought, Present, Future]

Strong Essays
703 words (2 pages)

Language's Influence on our Perception of The World Essay

- Although there is no official language in the United States, the English language is the most widely spoken. Language helps to shape our identities, define and limit our expectations of the world around us and who we are. You might ask yourself, how does our language shape our identities and influence our perceptions of the world. Through language, we are able to make meaning, understand, and define ourselves. We are able to communicate what we feel with others. However, our choice of words cannot always capture what we are feeling to the full extent....   [tags: languages, bilingual, english]

Strong Essays
1124 words (3.2 pages)

Frege's Interpretation of Language Essay

- Logic generally arises from argumentation, involving the study of reason and the forms it may take when presented as an argument. In determining the logical value of an argument, one must effectively assess the relations between objects and concepts put forth in a thought. However, thoughts themselves are inaccessible to anyone but the self as they exist only in the consciousness. To express such a thought, one must employ the tool of language, formulating thoughts and ideas into words so that they may be shared with a community....   [tags: Language]

Strong Essays
1430 words (4.1 pages)

Language's Influence on our Perception of the World Essay example

- Although there is no official language in the United States, the English language is the most widely spoken. Language helps to shape our identities, define and limit our expectations of the world around us and who we are. You might ask yourself, how does our language shape our identities and influence our perceptions of the world. Through language, we are able to make meaning, understand, and define ourselves. We are able to communicate what we feel, our ideas, our hopes, and our dreams with others who can respond to our feelings and thoughts....   [tags: communication, being bilingual]

Strong Essays
1322 words (3.8 pages)

Essay on Language and Perception

- Language is a persuasive tool but can also be misleading and confusing. Barriers such as distorting euphemisms, acronyms, lingo, illogicalities, and clichés can distort the meaning of words or phrases (Kirby et al, 1999, pg. 92). The most powerful ability of language is to understand and effectively communicate. Being able to clearly communicate ideas to each other allows empowerment and the ability to be open to new thoughts and opinions. The ability to reproduce this information to another in a certain manner can lead to persuasion....   [tags: essays research papers]

Strong Essays
713 words (2 pages)