A high school publications class provides a real life group learning activity that few other classes replicate. Students work as a team to create a newspaper, yearbook, website or broadcast, and while individual assignments are important, the class needs to come together to make sure all the work gets done, is done well and is put together as a whole. I want to see if teaching students to do peer writing conferences would help them become better writers and team members, because they would practice both writing skills and social skills by giving and receiving feedback. However, after some early difficulties with having my students give short, vague, grammar focused writing conferences I want to find out if writing conferences, especially peer writing conferences are useful and how I can improve the comments students make with each other.
Importance of writing conferences
I am interested in the dialogues that can happen when two people discuss writing. I have been experimenting with teacher-student writing conferences since reading Teaching Writing to Adolescents by Kelly Gallagher, where he discusses how students are more likely to pay attention to conferences with a teacher than comments written on a paper.
A teacher-student writing conference writing conference is a meeting between a teacher and one student to discuss the strengths and weaknesses of a student piece of writing (Walker & Elias, 1987). Walker and Elias found that writing conferences tend to receive higher ratings from students when the instructor and student can evaluate the student’s work together, rather than when the instructor takes over and discusses what he or she thinks the paper should be about.
While writing conferences are most effective when...
... middle of paper ...
...hen discussing writing with their peers.
Peer writing conferences are important because they offer students a way to receive in depth feedback on their writing, as well as practice writing skills by evaluating the writing of others. However, even strong writers do not know how to give effective writing conferences, and when students do not have practice with writing conferences and or are not given instruction on how to give them, the conferences are short, vague and can become off topic. Teachers can increase the effectiveness of peer writing conferences by using scaffolding strategies such as modeling feedback, discussing writing as a large group, and using different techniques to have structured small group discussions. With guidance and practice, the teacher should be able to step back from these discussions as the student voices take over.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- In High School there are many opportunities to write papers. Although some classes make you write more than others. My World Literature class was one of the classes that had to write more. There were over 15 writing assignments, but one stood out the most. For this essay we had to do peer review three times and had to have multiple conferences with the teacher to discuss the essay. Doing all of the peer reviews and conferences for the paper showed me that you can never put too much work into a paper.... [tags: Writing, Essay, High school, Peer review]
866 words (2.5 pages)
- My Philosophy on Teaching Writing As someone who has always loved writing, I hope it won’t be too hard for me to relate to students who may not enjoy it. Recalling my own school days, I know there were always some writing assignments that I didn’t find enjoyable or downright disliked, and I hope to minimize these assignments in my own classroom. Sometimes they’re necessary, but a lot of times they’re not. While in my classroom, I want my students to learn to write, but more importantly I want them to like to write.... [tags: Education Teachers Essays]
3538 words (10.1 pages)
- Writing 150 has been a truly enjoyable course for me. While I have always loved language and literature, this class gave me a fresh, new perspective on what it means to be a writer. From the very first class, I was redefining what writing means to me and how I could use it in my life, even if my career path isn’t centered around writing. As the semester comes to a close, I want to share with you which paper was my favorite from this course, how my identity as a writer has changed, and how I will approach future writing tasks with a new and improved writing process.... [tags: Writing, Writing process, Paper, Writing style]
943 words (2.7 pages)
- Motivation: Motivation has a large affect on the quality of work produced. It is difficult to do anything if you do not feel motivated to do it. Donald Murray in Bridging English explains motivation for writing as being a “want to understand his or her own life, to make meaning out of experience, [and] to share this meaning” (Milner, Milner, and Mitchell, 2013, 342). While this is a nice sentiment, I know that motivating students often requires an outside force other than their own want to understand.... [tags: Writing, Linguistics, Writing process, Motivation]
1056 words (3 pages)
- POLICIES: CLASS AND OFFICE INTERACTION This course revolves around you learning together with and supporting your peers. We have a significant opportunity to learn from each other. Therefore, you are expected to come prepared to class. This means being ready to share your writing, having the readings done ahead of time, bringing in drafts when they are due, and being alert during class. If you fall asleep during class for an extended time, you will have to see me during an office conference, or you will be marked absent for the day.... [tags: Writing, Essay, Reading, Reading]
1074 words (3.1 pages)
- Giving Peer Feedback Peer editing groups offer a fun, effective way to develop your writing and revising skills – skills you will need throughout your college experience. Specifically, such groups give each writer a chance to write for an audience other than the professor, and when you know your peers will read your draft, you often think ahead about how you can interest your audience and explain your ideas clearly. At first, some students find it difficult to say what they think about a piece of writing.... [tags: Writing, Essay, Editing, Idea]
1506 words (4.3 pages)
- The popularity of peer to peer file sharing was as an offshoot of the introduction of Naspers and people who were in need of certain information and those who could give it were interconnected.[ ] The workings of Peer-to-peer file sharing differ from the old-styled file downloading system in such a way that a software program is used to locate or search for computers that are in possession or have what you need rather than the web browser. The computers are called peers because they are same as yours, they are yours.[ ] So you run the software on your computer and send out a request for the file you need and the software will query other computers with the same software connected to the in... [tags: Peer-to-peer, File sharing]
722 words (2.1 pages)
- English has always been my favorite subject in school because a person can learn a lot through writing and can express themselves in many ways. Through taking this class I have realized that there are certain things most high school students think they know about English but in all reality there is a lot more to writing then just expressing yourself. I have personally learned how to write a summary and response paper, rhetorical analysis paper, synthesis paper, peer reviews and I have also learned how important your audience is during the writing process.... [tags: writing process, styles, peer reviews]
614 words (1.8 pages)
- During this College Composition course, I came across numerous obstacles and educational involvements. Every factor of this course contributed to my overall learning experience. For starters, we often read out of our textbooks, “The Little Seagull Handbook” and “They Say I Say”. These books helped showcase proper writing techniques. In addition, we would have class discussions that everyone would participate in. This opened my eyes to different viewpoints that could influence my writing. I recall one class we had a debate over a topic and everyone had to choose a side to argue.... [tags: Writing, Rhetoric, Book report, Essay]
1251 words (3.6 pages)
- Throughout this year I have had the opportunity to explore skills and methods of writing I’ve never used before. Multiple drafts and peer reviews were some of those skills, and they were new concepts I had never used in my work. I’d known what they are, just the basics, but before this class I never actually put those methods to work. During peer reviews I was able to get suggestions for revisions that I never would’ve thought of myself. By combining the ideas gathered in peer reviews and combining it with some of my own ideas, I was able to formulate stronger arguments.... [tags: Essay, Writing, Academia, Peer review]
746 words (2.1 pages)