Parents May Not Be Licensed Essay

Parents May Not Be Licensed Essay

Length: 1621 words (4.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In the essay Licensing Parents, LaFollette argues that the state should require all parents to be licensed (182). Though LaFollette considers some theoretical and practical objections to his claim, he gives no particular attention to how an activity could be precisely defined as potentially harmful to others, what specific competence would be required for an activity to be done safely, and how reliably such competence could be determined. In this paper, I will argue that the difficulty of clearly defining the three criteria for an activity to be licensed undermines LaFollette’s assertion that parenting ought to be licensed. After describing LaFollette’s basic rationale for licensing parents, I will indicate that parenting may not meet the three criteria that LaFollette proposes for an activity to be licensed, under certain situations in the real world. In addition, I will show that even though parenting satisfies the standard criteria, there are special reasons why it should not be licensed. Though this does not prove LaFollette’s idea to be false, I will suggest some ways in which the range of the applications of his idea might not be as wide as LaFollette thought.
LaFollette starts his argument by presenting the fact that “our society normally regulates a certain range of activities” like driving, practicing medicine, law, pharmacy, etc. (182). In addition, the decision to restrict such activities derives from a plausible but inexplicitly formulated rationale that the restricted activities could be “potentially harmful to others”, “safe performance of the activities require a certain competence”, and “we have a moderately reliable procedure for determining that competence” (183). As a result, it is theoretically desirable th...


... middle of paper ...


...g parents, let alone a reliable competence test. In particular, I have shown that, without a clear definition of harm, parental abuse could essentially be beneficial to children, and licensing parents could be a prior restraint in which the potential for harm is minor, compared to the restraint to parents. Plus, since LaFollette mentions some ways to deny his conclusion such as finding special reasons why licensing parents is not theoretically desirable, I have demonstrated that it is actually possible to find evidences to deny his conclusion. Consequently, licensing parents is merely LaFollette’s creative approach to look at our society in a non-intuitional perspective, but is both theoretically and evolutionarily undesirable. Thus, parents should not be licensed.







Works Cited

LaFollette, Hugh. 1980. “Licensing Parents.” Philosophy & Public Affairs 9:182-97.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Should Parents be Licensed? Essays

- In this paper I will argue that licensing parents is not only impractical but irrational. Hugh Laffollette, the author, argues many premises. However, many of his premises are assumptions and in the end are begging the question and not supporting his conclusion that licensing parents would help determine who is fit to become a parent and also that doing so would help children to become better adequate for adult life. Licensing parents would be a system that would be tedious and even hard to establish....   [tags: licensing parents, avoid harm]

Powerful Essays
702 words (2 pages)

Should Parents Be Licensed? Essay

- On my 16th birthday, I passed for my drivers’ license test and began driving my beloved PT Cruiser. 2 year ago, my cousin passed her test and received her psychologist license. Now, my sorority sisters are studying to pass the bar exam. All of these activities require licenses because they greatly impact the quality of a person’s life. Parenting is potentially harmful to not only the child but to others as well. Hugh LaFollete raises and analyzes the possibilities of requiring parents to receive licenses....   [tags: Parent, License, Parenting, Licenses]

Powerful Essays
1065 words (3 pages)

Essay about Licensed Parents : Child Abuse, Neglect And Abandonment

- Licensed Parents Our society normally regulates a certain range of activities; it is illegal to perform these activities unless one has received prior permission, has met all requirements and licensure in order to do so. We require automobile operator 's, wild game hunters, and concealed carriers to acquire licenses after hours of classes. We forbid people from practicing medicine, law, pharmacy, or psychiatry unless they have satisfied certain licensing requirements. Today, we see an astronomical rise in child abuse, neglect and abandonment....   [tags: Child abuse, Physical abuse, Abuse, Regulation]

Powerful Essays
1172 words (3.3 pages)

Becoming A Licensed Christian Counselor Essay

- Every person over the age of 19 can honestly say they have been a teenager, and as we all know the teen years can be pretty tough years. Being able to talk with an adult about these challenges is key to their future successes; unfortunately, many parents fall short on the explanation of God’s physical, emotional and spiritual design for them. This is where the Christian counselor comes in. It is my dream and goal to ultimately become a Christian counselor specializing in at-risk teens and families....   [tags: Education, Adolescence, Foster care, Psychology]

Powerful Essays
714 words (2 pages)

My Intention Of Becoming A Licensed Architect Essay example

- Everyone has dreams and goals. Those desires that, no matter what, you will never give up until you reach them. For me, graduating from an outstanding university with an undergraduate degree from the architecture program is the most prominent on my current list. I am nearing the end of this journey and I will be completing the undergraduate portion of my desire. With that said, I now set my sites higher on a loftier goal and a more exceptional dream. The new target, is to be accepted into an equally extraordinary graduate school so I may further my education which will assist me in taking the necessary steps to reach my apex....   [tags: High school, College, Higher education, Architect]

Powerful Essays
1085 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on Why Should We Be Licensed? Vaccines?

- To be licensed, vaccines must go through many years of research, and they have to pass certain standards. The vaccine process includes experts, including public health, epidemiology, immunology, and statistics.. Sometimes researchers disagree about who to include in vaccine trials, it 's a very important decision when deciding. To properly test a vaccines, a clinical trial is usually a big part in it. Historyofvaccines.org states that “failing to provide any option can be a difficult decision when the vaccine can potentially prevent a serious, untreatable, or fatal infection, however....   [tags: Vaccine, Vaccination, Immune system, Immunology]

Powerful Essays
750 words (2.1 pages)

Abortion Is Defined As An Intervention Performed By A Licensed Clinician

- Abortion is defined as an intervention performed by a licensed clinician (e.g., a physician, nurse-midwife, nurse practitioner, or physician assistant) that is intended to terminate an ongoing pregnancy (Center for Disease Control, 2014). According to the Center for Disease Control (2014) in 2011, 730,322 legal induced abortions were reported from 49 reporting areas. The abortion rate was 13.9 abortions per 1,000 women aged 15–44 years and the abortion ratio was 219 abortions per 1,000 live births....   [tags: Pregnancy, Abortion, Pro-choice, Roe v. Wade]

Powerful Essays
756 words (2.2 pages)

Essay on I Live With My Parents

- I live with my parents ' and five siblings. My mother’s name is Sharon Bailey and my father’s name is Everald Bailey. I have one brother and four sisters; from oldest to youngest their names are Lakisha Bailey, Angeleta Bailey, Sacha Bailey and Shanel Bailey and my brother’s name is Christopher Bailey. Other members such as aunts and uncle either live in Jamaica, New Jersey, Connecticut or New York. The health related changes that my family faced most recently is my father’s father passing away on October 10, 2015 and my aunt has been diagnosed with having diabetes....   [tags: Family, Nursing, Jamaica, Mother]

Powerful Essays
1597 words (4.6 pages)

The Challenge of Finding Quality Childcare Essay

- The challenge of finding a quality childcare facility and program for a 6 month old child can be very challenging. This task will require the analysis of multiple facilities and learning programs to find the right fit. In order to choose a quality childcare facility, it’s important to consider and analyze such factors as the quality of the facility, the professionalism of staff, the learning program practiced or offered and the safety and security of the facility. To find quality childcare it may be necessarily for parents to compare two to four different facilities and ask lots of questions in order to find the right match for your child....   [tags: developmental needs, safey, licensed facility]

Powerful Essays
872 words (2.5 pages)

Supporting Arguments for Parent Licensing: Hugh Laffollette's Licensing Parents

- Supporting Arguments for Parent Licensing In Hugh Lafollette’s paper, “Licensing Parents” he talks about the need for government licensing of parents. His argument states that for any activity that is harmful to others, requires competence, and has a reliable procedure for determining competence, should require licensing by the government. This argument relates to parenting because it can be harmful to children, requires competence to raise those children, and we can assume that a reliable procedure can be formulated....   [tags: Maltreatment of Children, Overgeneralization]

Powerful Essays
1167 words (3.3 pages)