The Paradox Of The Liar Paradox Essay example

The Paradox Of The Liar Paradox Essay example

Length: 1497 words (4.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Traced all the way back to six centuries before christ, the Liar Paradox is an argument that arrives at a contradiction when assuming the principle of bivalence. The principle of bivalence states that a declarative statement must have only one truth value; the declarative statement is either true or false, not both (Bernecker). The classical liar paradox is composed of paradoxical statements, like: “This sentence is false,” and “L1 : L1 is false” (Bernecker). If the statement “L1 is false” is true, then “L1” is false, because the first premise says, “L1 is false” (Bernecker). However, if the statement “L1 is false” is false, then “L1” is not false, it is true (Bernecker). Instinctively, “L1” seems to be neither false nor true, but because of the principle of bivalence one knows that the statement must either be true or false, and not both, and not neither (Bernecker). Saying that a statement is “false” or “true” is referring to “what it says it is,” and if the statement is true then it “tells it the way it is” (Sainsbury). To analyze the first example one needs to assume that “L1 : L1 is false” is true (Bernecker). The first premise is “L1” is true; this serves as the assumption and the second premise, “L1,” is the disquotation (Bernecker). Therefore, the conclusion is that “L1,” is not true, it is false, and this is can be deduced by the definition of “L1” (Bernecker). However, one can see a contradiction between the first premise and the conclusion. I find this claim accurate because the first premise says that “L1” is true, but the conclusion says that “L1” is not true (Bernecker). I also have come to the conclusion that this contradiction means that argument does not follow the principle of bivalence, because the argument i...

... middle of paper ...

...his is one of the better solutions out there, due to the fact that it addresses the use of “true,” and “false.”
The Liar Paradox is one key arguments philosophers want to understand, so the theory of truth can be analyzed (“Liar Paradox”). Many who come across the Liar Paradox do one of two things: they either do not take the paradox seriously or they say that it 's meaningless (“Liar Paradox). However, even though with 2,300 years of attention, philosophers have not accepted one solution and are continuing to solve the paradox, proving the importance of this paradox (“Liar Paradox”). Solving the paradox will help explain the basic concept of truth, and also about logic (“Liar Paradox). I agree this is a paradox that is fascinating; it is a paradox about truth and how statements affect each other, and solving this paradox will teach many about the theory of truth.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Steinbeck's Paradox and Dreams Essay

- The structure of the american paradox is complex. The dreams set through decades upon decades of generations have consumed the americans way of living. this paradox and dream is what we have come to not just base our entire lives around but build are morals, standards, and expectations for overall existence. “Paradox and Dream “ isn't like Steinbecks normal pieces of literature. Steinbeck's “Paradox and Dreams” is a sarcastic and criticism filled outlook on the self made paradox created by americans and based on their way of living....   [tags: American Paradox and Dreams]

Free Essays
1178 words (3.4 pages)

Humour and Conflict in the scene in which Rita and Barbara Clash from Billy Liar

- Humour and Conflict in the scene in which Rita and Barbara Clash from Billy Liar Task: ‘Explain how both humour and conflict are created in the scene in which Rita and Barbara clash’ Billy liar is set in 1959, at the time of the teenage rebellion and the start of the swinging sixties. This is reflected in the play because there are still some ‘old Fashioned’ People around i.e. Barbara, which tells me that the ‘new age’ hasn’t affected some people yet. And there are also people like Liz who are really taking to the new style of living....   [tags: Billy Liar Keith Waterhouse Plays Essays]

Free Essays
1129 words (3.2 pages)

Marginal Utility: The Missing Link in the Diamond-Water Paradox Essay example

- Marginal Utility: The Missing Link in the Diamond-Water Paradox. American Heritage Dictionary describes a paradox as “a seemingly contradictory statement that may nonetheless be true”. I feel this definition applies to “The Diamond-Water Paradox”. Water is of immeasurable value to human survival, however it has virtually little or no monetary or trade value. While this seems to be a contradiction, it is in fact the absolute truth. On the other hand a diamond has no real value of use to mankind, however it is one of the most sought after and expensive items in the world....   [tags: Diamond-Water Paradox]

Free Essays
1196 words (3.4 pages)

The Actor and The Liar Essay

- After playing a convincing role as an action hero in a new film, a movie star exits the stage, leaving his character behind, and attends a press conference claiming that he did all his own stunts, becoming both an actor and a liar. When it comes to the difference between these two characters, clear differentiations are not immediately apparent. In this example, in order to impress his audience, both the actor and the liar are untruthful regarding their accomplishments. Both require a skilled performer who is well versed in the various protocols....   [tags: Sociology]

Better Essays
797 words (2.3 pages)

Essay on The Transparency Paradox Of The Accountability Paradox

- QUESTION 1 Helen Nissenbaum writes about the transparency paradox. What does she mean by it. And how is it relevant with respect to the Internet. What do you think the correct solution to the transparency paradox is and why. Transparency paradox can be explained as a theory that basically states that owing to rapid development in technology and innovation. There has been a ubiquitous usage of digital tools. Each of these tools collects some information about a person. Consent to use the information, transparency and individual privacy has become an issue (Bernstein, 2012)....   [tags: Morality, Ethics, Network neutrality, Relativism]

Better Essays
1883 words (5.4 pages)

The Paradox Of The Stone Essays

- The paradox of the stone is an argument that is simple but implies big meaning, it states that if god is omnipotence, all-powerful, as described then he can create a stone that even he can’t lift. This very simple statement has been a major argument in favor of atheism, if you agree with the paradox then that means you think god is not all-powerful because he can’t lift a stone. Others like Christians disagree that this goes wrong in few different ways, some think the problem is with the word omnipotence and what that entails, others argue that the use of the word can’t with god is impossible because he is almighty and can do anything, and a few suggest that comparing god to people is where...   [tags: Logic, Critical thinking, Aristotle, Mind]

Better Essays
997 words (2.8 pages)

The Birthday Paradox Essay

- This particular project is going to be about birthdays. This research paper will unravel the meanings of important words and reveal the answers to frequently asked questions considering this Birthday Paradox. This Birthday Paradox states: if 23 individuals are amongst each other in an area, then there is a probability of 50% that two of the individuals will have the same birthday. A birthday is the anniversary when somebody was born (creative edge dictionary). “Birthdays are important they tell people when they were born and when they came into the world....   [tags: mathematics, probabillity]

Better Essays
951 words (2.7 pages)

Essay on Daniel DeFoe, Master Liar?

- "And after all, what is a lie. `Tis but the truth in masquerade" Lord Byron (1) Moll Flanders, a potent character of Defoe's, is haunted by her past, and as such, is driven to tell her story. Many literary scholars believe Defoe intentionally mislead readers to believe that Moll Flanders was a real person. Defoe has therefore often been dubbed as a liar. The dictionary definition of a lie is: To speak untruthfully with intent to mislead or deceive (2) Plots in other fictitious works, such as those by Shakespeare, were known as fiction due to their unlikely content, but in Moll Flanders it is harder to distinguish between fact and fiction....   [tags: European Literature]

Better Essays
1257 words (3.6 pages)

Billy Liar Essay

- Billy Liar The play 'Billy Liar' was first produced in London on 13th September 1960. Originally a novel, it was adapted by Willis Hall and Keith Waterhouse for performance. Billy the main character in the performance lives in a lower middle class family and is subconsciously trapped by their social class. Billy is an imaginative youth who indulges in daydreams and escapism, but cannot fulfil his fantasies due to the restriction of his social culture. In modern society Billy would have been more likely to fulfil his dreams as generally family and social restrictions have changed since the 1960s and movement away from the family unit is more accepted....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
1022 words (2.9 pages)

Platonic Paradox Essay

- To research Plato's paradox in the Meno, we can first consult the definition of what platonism is. Websters defines platonism as "actual things are copies of transcendent ideas and that these ideas are the objects of true knowledge apprehended by reminiscence." For this essay, we will assume that trancendency is- "that which is beyond comprehension", and reminiscence as "past experience". The Meno is a dialogue between Socrates, a scholar and Meno, who eventually became an explorer....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
1721 words (4.9 pages)