Padilha’s Intentional Neutrality in Bus 174 Essay

Padilha’s Intentional Neutrality in Bus 174 Essay

Length: 1529 words (4.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview



In that hot, disturbing summer afternoon in 2000, about thirty-five million Brazilian people watched live, as Keough refers, the “reality TV at its most intense” Bus 174 hijacking incident. From then on, there are thirty-five million individual stories about what happened: the reasons, the motivations, the consequences, the hijacker, the hostages, and the police officers are all differently interpreted even though thousands of cameras were aimed at the same man at the same time. Reality is relative to the observer. Director José Padilha would certainly agree with such an argument as he claims to carry a “neutral tone” about the event in his documentary film Bus 174(Rother). Larry Rother also points out in his review of the film that “without either editorializing or flinching, Mr. Padilha shows a police force that is both incompetent and violent.” This illustration of police system, however, hints a question whether the director attempts to deliberately draw audience's attention on the rescuer rather than hijacker. Although his critical depiction of the law enforcement in Rio seems to challenge his intention of fairness, Padilha’s perspective on Brazilian justice system that the police force lacks discipline and integrity during the crisis reflects his outright and detached viewpoint on this particular event as a filmmaker.
This is an unfair story from the very beginning; Padilha’s goal of staying neutral can only be achieved by him balancing existing prejudice from the public and taking a more critical approach of directing. Without knowing any background, the audience have already been influenced by the definitions of “hijack” and “hostage” when these words are used by police, media, or any stranger on the street. As a matte...


... middle of paper ...


...ld and Mark Cousins. Boston: Faber and Faber, 1996. 97. Print.
Keough, Peter. “Onibus 174/Bus 174.” BostonPhoenix.com. The Boston Phoenix, 5-11 Dec. 2003. Web. 14 Jan. 2013.
Nichols, Bill. Introduction to Documentary. 2nd ed. Bloomington: Indiana Univ. Press, 2010. Print.
Padilha, José, Felipe Lacerda, João Nabuco, and Sacha Amback. Bus 174: Ônibus 174. New York: Hart Sharp,2004. DVD.
Peixoto, Marta. “Rio’s Favelas in Recent Fiction and Film: Commonplaces of Urban Segregation.” PMLA 122.1 (Jan. 2007): 170-8. MLA International Bibliography. Web. 14 Jan. 2013.
Pryluck, Calvin. “Ultimately We Are All Outsiders: The Ethics of Documentary Filming.” Journal of the University Film Association 28.1 (Winter 1976): 21-9. JSTOR. Web. 22 May 2013.
Rohter, Larry. “A Horrific Crime that Was Seen by Millions.” NYTimes.com. The New York Times, 7 Sept. 2003. Web. 23 Aug. 2012.






Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Discuss Whether it is Possible to Maintain the Neutrality of Humanitarian Aid

- The provision of humanitarian aid has become an increasingly contentious and complicated issue. A contributing factor has been the expanding numbers of humanitarian actors (Marriage, 2008: 2) and consequentially greater competition for funding and operational field space. Governmental and inter-governmental agencies have blurred the lines of pure humanitarianism by integrating these activities with their own state’s military and political objectives (Rigby, 2001). This is further exacerbated in contexts of conflict....   [tags: humanitarian aid, neutrality, international help]

Powerful Essays
2429 words (6.9 pages)

A Report On The Bus Stop Essay

- The ULL bus stop is something students and faculty walk by and use every day. It is a very visible part of ULL and has been looked passed and it is apparent that it has been neglected for years. Our Action Project is focusing on not only adding on to the bus stop, but also the renewal of what is already there. Our project topic is something that is important because the current bus stop does not meet certain needs. When you are at the bus stop to go to Cajun Field and you look at the covering you will notice that it is falling apart....   [tags: Public transport, Bus stop, Bus, Accessibility]

Powerful Essays
822 words (2.3 pages)

Net Neutrality Essay

- INTRODUCTION The emergence of the Internet and the World Wide Web brought upon a medium of communication with a range of opportunities for the world. However, this medium is, in due course, subject to the control of a few major companies. The enigma of information flow is the central concern of net neutrality. Consumers, competition and network owners would benefit directly from the regulation of network neutrality because it would provide a positive impact to those parties as well as provide equality....   [tags: Network, Neutrality, Internet]

Powerful Essays
1150 words (3.3 pages)

A Bus Ride For Social Services Essay

- On August 31, 2016, I took a bus ride to social services off Summit Avenue. I started off by getting on the bus on Tate street (bus 2), which ended up at the bus depot. The bus depot is the main stop where all buses meet to exchange passengers so that passengers are able to get all over Greensboro from one location. While at the bus depot, I felt confused and out of place. One can understand why an individual would be disorientated and or confused on what bus to get on. Therefore, I went to the main building where passengers buy bus passes to ask what bus I need to transfer on to get to Guilford County Social Services....   [tags: Bus, Public transport]

Powerful Essays
1284 words (3.7 pages)

The Bus, A Modern Panacea, Lester Detroit Essay examples

- In the article The Bus, a Modern Panacea, Lester Detroit says that cars have become more of a problem than a solution. San Jose State University students are wasting their valuable time searching for a parking spot on streets and garages, instead of spending all that time on their studies. Furthermore, students who driving cars are creating environmental problems, traffic congestion, rising oil consumption, and carbon pollution. In this article, Detroit is encouraging SJSU students to drop their cars and start to get on VTA public transportation such as buses and light rails....   [tags: Public transport, Bus, Bus stop]

Powerful Essays
977 words (2.8 pages)

Slater 's Conduct Satisfies The Elements Of Intentional Infliction Of Emotional Distress

- ISSUE Is the judge likely to find that A.C Slater’s conduct satisfies the elements of intentional infliction of emotional distress. BRIEF ANSWER Likely yes, if it is proven that Slater: a) intended to inflict severe mental or emotional distress, that he b) was the cause of Morris’s severe emotional distress, and that c) his conduct was beyond the bounds of socially tolerable. FACTS At the time of the incident, Zack Morris was a technician employed by Cruisin’ California Airlines. During his shift on March 25, 2011, he completed a series of routine jobs on an assigned plane and signed off on the “job card” verifying the work was complete....   [tags: Intentional infliction of emotional distress]

Powerful Essays
1059 words (3 pages)

A Proposal For Extending Rapid Service Bus Schedules Essay

- A Proposal to Extend Rapid Service Bus Schedules Problem As a commuter student I spend an average of 16 hours and 25 minutes per week in campus while waiting for my classes to begin or for the first bus to start its route back home. The main problem with Rapid Service from Valley Metro, that connects Park and Rides and Downtown Phoenix, is that has strict schedules. For example, the I-10 East route that begins at Pecos Park and Ride starts the inbound at 5:10 AM and ends at 8:10 AM. The outbound stop location that is closest to Downtown Phoenix campus, in Central & Van Buren, starts at 3:30 PM and ends at 6:15 PM....   [tags: Bus, Public transport bus service]

Powerful Essays
1222 words (3.5 pages)

Correlation Between Proportion Of Bus Stops And Robberies Essay

- Correlation between Proportion of Bus Stops and Robberies 4.3.1 Model 1 Robberies happened in entire day in 2010 Table 4.3 Model 1 Robberies happened in entire day in 2010 Dependent Variable: 2010_Robbery_Pct   Beta Sig. VIF 10_BS_Pct 0.597 0.000 1.258 10_Pop_SQMI 0.295 0.005 1.198 10_Un25_Pct 0.140 0.228 1.560 10_Vacancy_Pct 0.238 0.030 1.343 10_Med_HH -0.039 0.753 1.786 R Square: 0.632 Adj. R Square: 0.591 The statistically significant facts can be witnessed from table 4.3. Diagnostics, more specifically, the variance inflation factor (VIF), which quantifies how much of a coefficient’s variance increases as a result of multicollinearity, is computed for all of the independen...   [tags: Bus, Public transport, Bus rapid transit]

Powerful Essays
2241 words (6.4 pages)

The Bus Essay

- The Bus I have this friend named Ted. Ted has an old school bus all spray-painted and beat up looking. This in and of itself is not that big a matter. What makes this bus different is he attached the top half of a Volkswagon van on top of the bus. This bus has been around for around fifteen years or so and has looked about the same if not worse the whole time. See, Ted used to live in this bus. It's a project he has been working on for some time now. Numerous people have asked him why he won't get rid of the ugly thing....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
1616 words (4.6 pages)

The Bus Essay

- It's around 5:30am and I am still waiting for the bus to leave the station. I'm so excited about my trip to Texas. It seems very odd because I'm only on the bus with 3 other people; the bus driver and a mother and her young daughter. The Driver He is a short man with white wavy hair and a long white beard. He reminds me of Santa Clause but I am sure that Santa doesn't carry cigarettes in his shirt pocket like this guy does. He keeps looking in the mirror at the people on the bus; almost like he was analyzing them and judging them....   [tags: Descriptive Personal Narrative]

Powerful Essays
1376 words (3.9 pages)