Doctor Who is a British show that features The Doctor, a Time Lord that travels through time visiting events that happened in the past and witnessing events that will happen in the future. In season 4, episode 3 of Doctor Who the Doctor and his companion, Donna, go back in time to the eve of Pompeii’s destruction in 79 A.D. in their TARDIS, Time and Relative Dimensions in Space. Once the Volcano begins to erupt Donna and the Doctor are the only ones with the means of escaping. The Doctor is forced to make a difficult decision when Donna argues that they have to save at least someone from the destruction. Here Donna is making an ethical decision and despite the circumstances that would rule against it they decide to save a family from the volcanic eruption. The philosophical issue that arises from this is: should people make the decision to save someone’s life despite the consequences that can arise. First I will argue that your moral belief should dictate your decision because from a determinist perspective the consequences are already determined. Then I will argue that the decision you make should align with the laws of nature. Finally, I will argue from an ethical standpoint that the decision to save lives despite the events that follow is the most moral decision.
I will assert that all decisions and consequences are already determined by forces beyond our control. This argument relates to the philosophical issue at hand because if the consequences are already determined then a person’s action was already pre-ordained and whatever happens was intended to be, by a power that an individual had no power over. In the situation of deciding whether or not to save a life the determinist would believe that what is supposed to happen wi...
... middle of paper ...
...ir sovereignty as an individual. Neglecting that person so that you can be popular is wrong. Just like neglecting to save one person because they’re not five people is also wrong.
All in all when the decision arises to save a life one must make an ethically sound decision. An ethically sound decision is one that doesn’t violate a person’s position as a sovereign individual and aligns itself with universal law. You must do this despite what the consequences are because they are not within your control.
Works Cited
Buroc, Marc A. Determinism and Causation Examples. Http://philsci-archive.pitt.edu/. N.p., 2004. Web. 19 Jan. 2014. .
"David Hume." Wikipedia. Wikimedia Foundation, 20 Jan. 2014. Web. 20 Jan. 2014.
"Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy." Stoicism []. N.p., n.d. Web. 20 Jan. 2014.
involves helping a lot of people, in a short period of time, in tricky situations” (Light). Doctors Without Borders has worked in over sixty countries (“Countries” ), helped over a hundred-million patients and employed over 30,000 people in the past forty-six years (“Founding”). So with now knowing that, Doctors Without Borders is a non-profit organization that aims to provide health care and support to the people who need it most (Edmonds). "It’s simple really: go where the patients are. It seems obvious
Insomnia is a common sleep disorder. People who have insomnia have trouble falling asleep, staying asleep, or both. As a result, they may get an little amount of sleep or have a poor-quality of sleep. They may not feel refreshed when they wake up. There are four types of Insomnia. One is called Primary Insomnia; Primary Insomnia dictates that a person is having problems sleeping that are not directly correlated with any other health condition or problem. Then there is Secondary Insomnia, Secondary
Introduction The interview, conducted within An Overview of Investigative Interviewing (1998), depicted a scenario of a woman who had been assaulted. After reviewing the material, there were many points to consider, such as the location of the interview, barriers to communication, what was done well, what could be improved, communication, and planning. Overall, the interviewer did well in his role, and the problems found could be easily remedied. The location, while private, was not quiet, nor
reported by the patient to her doctor. (5) GBS is also known as acute inflammatory demylinating polyneuropathy and Landry's ascending paralysis after Jean B. O. Landry, a French physician who described a disorder that "paralyzed the legs, arms, neck, and breathing muscles of the chest." (4) (1) GBS was named after French physicians Georges Guillain and Jean Alexander Barre who, along with fellow physician Andre Stohl, described the differences of the spinal fluid of those who suffered f... ... middle
job; you are helping the physician during his hours of medical examination. PAs work hard during their job by examining patients and walking around the medical facility almost the whole shift. According to Job Overview ‘Physician Assistant” (2015),“Working under the supervision of doctors, PAs interpret X-rays and blood test, record patient progress, conduct routine physical exams and
Debate” and “Issue Overview: Vaccines”, the reader can reach an understanding of both sides of this argument. After reading these articles, one can educate themselves on both the positives and negatives of vaccinations. Many experts in the medical world support the use of vaccinations as a method for prevention of diseases. The article “Issue Overview: Vaccines” reports that “The Centers for Disease Control (CDC) recommends
The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down: A Hmong Child, Her American Doctors, and the Collision of Two Cultures (Fadiman, 1997) is an ethnography based on the story of Lia Lee. Lia was born to Hmong immigrant parents in Merced, California in 1982. The story is recounted in the Lee family and their collaborations with the medicinal group in Merced being taken care of by Lia, who develops an epileptic seizure at around 3 months of age. Dialect hindrances and conviction framework differences
and personality traits. Anorexia Nervosa People who have anorexia nervosa have a potent fear of gaining weight; due to this fear, victims of this disorder limit their food intake. These limitations can cause you to become very, very thin and eventually become very sick. Anorexia affects the body and mind. You start off dieting and then things quickly spin out of control. You constantly think about... ... middle of paper ... ...t in people who are trying to help you become healthy again (http://www
Regina Geis is a ten-year old female who is diagnosed with celiac disease. No one in her immediate family has been diagnosed, including her parents and her younger sister. Celiac disease is an autoimmune disease of the digestive system that is usually indicated by long-lasting inflammation in the small intestine that occurs when a protein from the plant called gluten, which is usually found in grains such as wheat, barley, and rye, is consumed, resulting in an interference of absorption of nutrients
Phoebe Zerwick’s article, “The Rise of DIY Abortions” covers the fact that women will do just about anything to receive an abortion. Her article talks about a young woman who goes to the black market to receive an abortion pill that has become illegal (Zerwick). This pill was once a legal part of medical abortions. As legislators tried to ban abortion, they banned on of the two parts of these medical abortions to discourage women from getting abortions at all. In doing this, women began to risk their
An Overview of the Rare Disease Known as Kabuki Syndrome As I look to graduate, I become increasingly aware that I have my entire life to look forward to. Even though I will have struggles throughout my life, I still have my well being to fall back on. When all else fails, I am and hopefully always will be self-assured that I am here, healthy and able to bring myself through the worst of circumstances. This realization and knowledge has presented itself in the most realistic way just within
One drink a day can create liver scarring. So like everything else in life it varies, it might affect everyone differently. The individual who drinks alcohol on a daily basis, or more often then others have a higher risk of developing cirrhosis. Hepatic cirrhosis has also been linked to serious liver infections such as hepatitis B and hepatitis C. Patients who are HIV positive have died from developing cirrhosis through the hepatitis virus. Other causes of cirrhosis come from reactions to prescribed
fused to the heart walls causing regurgitation. Since the heart does not work as efficiently in those who have this anomaly, the heart usually compensates and becomes enlarged. It... ... middle of paper ... ...rom http://www.ebsteinsanomaly.org/what_is_ea.html Hartnell, G. (2013, July 22). Ebstein Anomaly Imaging. Retrieved January 23, 2014, from http://emedicine.medscape.com/article/349278-overview#a24 Mayo Clinic Staff (n.d.). Ebstein's Anomaly Causes - Diseases and Conditions - Mayo Clinic. Retrieved
dangerous tactics. Team doctors and new rules have helped, but the best way to almost completely end this problem is to stop people from getting injuries all together. It is close to impossible to predict whether someone will get a concussion from a head on tackle. But we can use high tech machines to stop a player from playing if he/she has a high chance of breaking their collar bone or tearing their hamstring. Medicine started with spiritual healing in 1000 B.C.. People who practiced it believed
25) .Euthanasia . Politics.uk.co. retrieved from http://www.politics.co.uk/briefings-guides/issue-briefs/health/euthanasia-$366667.htm The UK Statue Law database(n,d) Suicide Act 1961 Twycross,G,R.(1993).A Doctor Dilemma. Journal of The Christian medical Fellowship,pg1 WHO,(n.d).Palliative care .World Health organization. Retrieved from http://www.who.int/cancer/palliative/definition/en/