Is it possible for the subject catalog to remain hospitable to users while also striving to be unbiased? This question has undoubtedly been raised in many professional circles during discussions surrounding subject analysis and the subject catalog. Perhaps the key is acknowledging the inherent subjectivity of subject analyzation and therefore acknowledge the continual existence of a certain amount of bias and inhospitality within the subject catalog. When such an acknowledgement is made, a system of checks and balances can be devised in order to work towards overcoming bias, on both the parts of the cataloger and the user, while promoting hospitality in the subject catalog.
There are some who suggest that it is indeed impossible when engaging in subject cataloging to both please the user and be without bias. As Prevost points out, in her 1946 article in Library Quarterly, the public is both very large and very diverse. She goes on to explain that figuring out the “public mind” is impossible. Prevost asserts that the principle of common usage is too illusive and subjective to consider in the midst of such a diverse and changing public, therefore it is best to catalog subjects keeping librarians and “intelligent users” in mind. This thought process seems contrary to Cutter’s focus on the reader which is a focus held in high regard by the ethics of many a library and librarian.
There are others who suggest that there are ways to objectively catalog and analyze the subject of works, therefore bias can be eliminated and relevancy can reign in the world of subject cataloguing. Patrick Wilson describes the techniques and strategies catalogers have employed in or...
... middle of paper ...
...inually evolving, the new term phasing out the older term, the cycle continuing indefinitely. Given the subjective nature of the subject catalog this is a realistic and beneficial solution. It is a solution which depends in great part on the “system-user interface” as Bates suggests in her article on the topic of subject cataloging in the online environment. The success of the proposed solution depends on the user friendliness of the interface. Increasing the guidance of users from unauthorized terms to authorized terms requires a well organized and hospitable interface. In conclusion, it is obvious that a solution of checks and balances by way of continually evaluating and updating the cross-references is not an inexpensive one, but it is a solution that will lead the subject catalog in a way that is unbiased, hospitable, and relevant in an ever-changing world.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- On the 9th of September 2001, an estimated audience of 2 billion people watched the destruction of the Twin Towers in New York, live on television (Giddens and Sutton, 2013: p766). The notion that information can be spread so fast and to so many receivers is still a relatively new notion to modern society but it has become such an integral part of our everyday lives. As Macionis and Plummer (2012: p762) state, “this is the time of the media”, with 73% of UK adults accessing the Internet everyday (Ons, 2013).... [tags: space-bias media, alternative biases]
1414 words (4 pages)
- This paper will explore the types of bias in testing, as well as examine the factors needed to determine if biases exist in psychological testing. The context will involve a test for cognitive ability and claims that the test is biased against a certain minority. Furthermore, fairness in testing will also be looked at in order to understand the concept in regards to tests. Bias and fairness may often be used synonymously, but bias can be measured when understood in terms of psychometrics; whereas fairness is more a product of a social system, and may normally be more subjective in its application (Aguinis, Culpepper, & Pierce, 2010).... [tags: Psychometrics, Psychology, Sociology, Bias]
1196 words (3.4 pages)
- Everyday millions of Americans plop down in front of their TVs to get their daily intake of news and current events of what happened that day. Sadly, most of the news and facts they are getting have been altered somehow by someone at the news corporation or by the reporters themselves. In the numerous news sources that cover world evens daily there are certain viewpoints that are thrust into the public’s face. This highly opinionated and biased news coverage has been present since there was news to report on.... [tags: Political Bias]
1547 words (4.4 pages)
- In the helping professions such as psychology, counseling, social work and education, it is imperative that we as professionals understand tests and be able to administer them properly to our clients or students. Tests should be carefully selected, as each has a purpose and as we are aware, there are biases within various tests. A biased test is one in which there are methodical distinctions in the meaning of test scores correlated to different groups. Most tests are well-formulated; however none are absolute.... [tags: Bias in Mental Testing]
1589 words (4.5 pages)
- Throughout the course of human events, it has become the widespread practice of many men and women to devote their lives to the study of the men, women, and associated civilizations that came before them; in short, the study of history. History in itself, for those that study it, presents the challenge of ascertaining the truth about the past. This process includes the discovery of such fundamental elements as how past civilizations made their living, where and what they used to provide for their basic needs, and what they chose to produce in their leisure time; all of which can generally be reached from observation of physical evidence and primary sources alone.... [tags: Gender Bias, Social Order]
1606 words (4.6 pages)
- The Loyal subject novel, published originally in 1988 under the title “Man of Straw” gives Heinrich Mann’s satirical connection of the nineteenth century European literal works. The writer of this novel derives the word subject from the word “Der Untertan” in German language. The novel highlights the difficulties encountered during nineteenth century Europe. As early as the 1950, Heinrich Mann’s novel plays a major role in the European’s history. The novel goes beyond the art bounds in its polemics and its structure fits into neither its modern challenge nor its realist tradition.... [tags: loyal, subject, difficulties, indictment]
795 words (2.3 pages)
- Upon researching Journalism, I was presented with two outstanding texts that I thought were very crucial towards laying the foundation for a framework that critiques Journalism followed by smaller other texts. The first source I chose was entitled, “Media Bias: How to Spot It-And How to Fight It.” The article was written by media Analyst and FAIR (Fairness and Accuracy In Reporting) member, Peter Hart. Hart asserts that there are three components of Journalism that “lack initiatives” when, “identifying examples of poor reporting, neglected context, and the reluctance to change status-quo notions and conventional wisdom.” I thought this was necessary for my paper and its reputability because... [tags: Mass media, Culture, Media bias, Bias]
1169 words (3.3 pages)
- Today it seems almost impossible to get a straightforward answer on any major topic from the media. All sources of media have a specific audience that they are intending to hear or view the information that they have prepared, therefore they will cut bits and pieces out so that only the message they are trying to get across will be received. So indeed there is a media bias, and yes it more often than not slants towards the liberal view point, as many reporters and journalists have liberal views themselves.... [tags: Liberal Media Bias]
2025 words (5.8 pages)
- Most of people believe that television news programs present biased information. On the other hand, there are people who believe that TV news just states the facts, and that it is not biased. These people who believe that TV news states the facts believe whatever they hear and see on TV. It’s very important to know how news stations can influence their viewers. Postman and Powers give a great example in their “Television News: The Language of Pictures” article. They said, “Consider a film clip showing an aircraft carrier at sea.... [tags: Television, Bias, TV, ]
617 words (1.8 pages)
- The powerful media barons have always altered broadcasts to achieve their personal or corporate agenda. What purpose does the media serve now. Measuring Bias on Television by Barrie Gunter has elaborated on the idea that news was originally set up to act as a national tool to stir thoughts. But is it. No. Is the media even enlightening the public now. After careful speculation of mass media and the communication world, I am under the impression that broadcasts have been used to entertain, frighten and cause controversy as a means to keep people watching.... [tags: Measuring Bias on Television]
990 words (2.8 pages)