Out Of This Furnance by Thomas Bell

Out Of This Furnance by Thomas Bell

Length: 1832 words (5.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
Refuting Capitalist Ideals

Thomas Bell, author of Out of This Furnace, grew up in the steel mill town of Braddock, Pennsylvania. His novel reflects the hardships faced by his family during the time when the mills ruled the area. The book also focuses upon the life of immigrant workers struggling to survive in the "new country." All events in Bell's novel are fictional, however, they create a very realistic plot and are based somewhat upon a true story. In this novel, Bell refutes capitalistic ideals and the lack of a republican form of government by showing the struggles and success of immigrant steelworkers.

In the late nineteenth century, many European immigrants traveled to the United States in search of a better life and good fortune. The unskilled industries of the Eastern United States eagerly employed these men who were willing to work long hours for low wages just to earn their food and board. Among the most heavily recruiting industries were the railroads and the steel mills of Western Pennsylvania. Particularly in the steel mills, the working conditions for these immigrants were very dangerous. Many men lost their lives to these giant steel-making machines. The immigrants suffered the most and also worked the most hours for the least amount of money. Living conditions were also poor, and often these immigrants would barely have enough money and time to do anything but work, eat, and sleep. There was also a continuous struggle between the workers and the owners of the mills, the capitalists. The capitalists were a very small, elite group of rich men who held most of the wealth in their industries. Strikes broke out often, some ending in violence and death. Many workers had no political freedom or even a voice in the company that employed them. However, through all of these hardships, the immigrants continued their struggle for a better life.

This is the struggle represented in the book: Out of this Furnace, by Thomas Bell.

The viewpoints of Thomas Bell in his novel seem to sharply contradict the viewpoints depicted by Congressman Abram S. Hewitt and Reverend Richard Storrs (Krause). These men were the main speakers at a key historical event during the late nineteenth century: the opening of the Brooklyn Bridge. "The ceremonies were called 'The People's Day' (Krause). It was a day that "proclaimed victory over the dark forces of history", and a "day to celebrate progress" (Krause). However, the opening of the bridge would be a celebration only for those who benefited from it.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Out Of This Furnance by Thomas Bell." 123HelpMe.com. 18 Feb 2020
    <https://www.123helpme.com/view.asp?id=162074>.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Out of This Furnace by Thomas Bell Essays

- Out of This Furnace by Thomas Bell Out of This Furnace tells a impressive story of a multigenerational family of Slovakian immigrants who comes to the United States in search of a better life in the New World. The patriarch of the Slovak family was Djuro Kracha, who arrived in the New World in the mid-1880s from the "old country." The story tells of his voyage, his work on the railroad to earn enough money to afford the walk to the steel mills of Pennsylvania, his rejection by the larger mainstream community as a "hunkey," and the lives of his daughter and grandson....   [tags: Papers Immigration Bell Furnace Essays]

Research Papers
1509 words (4.3 pages)

Out of this Furnace, by Thomas Bell Essay

- The book Out of this Furnace written by Thomas Bell is about a Slovak family immigration to America. Immigrating to America for the Slovak family brought trials and problems. The work that was available for the George, Mike and Johnny is hard and requires long hours of work, for very little pay. The family came hoping to get a better life. But in the end the American dream became very hard for them to reach. Jobs were hard to find and working in the mill required movement from place to place, finding a home for the family was difficult and making sure that family was happy and taken care wasn’t easy....   [tags: Immigrating to America]

Research Papers
1145 words (3.3 pages)

Andrew Graham Bell, The Man Behind The Creative Invention Essay

- Everyone knows Alexander Graham Bell, the man behind the creative invention; the telephone. Not only was the telephone one of the biggest invention in the history of America, but it was the most successful one as well. During Graham Bell’s time period, the only way you could communicate to others was by writing letters which had usually taken about a week to get delivered due to the lack of transportation. While amused by Alexander, creation of the first telephone, he also created something to help deaf people....   [tags: Alexander Graham Bell, Telephone]

Research Papers
908 words (2.6 pages)

The Diving Bell and the Butterfly Essay

- The Butterfly Diving Bell sits on my bedside table . It was a busy day when I finished and I'm struggling with how to express my appreciation for the best of the author , Jean - Dominique Bauby . As a beautiful French dessert , each crafted wonderful phrases should be savored. Posted by Bauby bears a sense of humor combined with depression that required for reading and slow digestion . He must have been a Morrissey fan . For those who are not familiar with Mr. Bauby , he was a former general editor of Elle magazine Parisian version ....   [tags: The Diving Bell and the Butterfly]

Free Essays
995 words (2.8 pages)

The Bell Jar By Sylvia Plath Essay

- The Bell Jar, written by Sylvia Plath, starts of in the summer of the mid-1950s. Esther Greenwood, the main character, is a 19 year full of ambition and creativity that works at a popular magazine company. Esther mainly has two “best friends”, Betsy and Doreen. Having a pretty decent life in New York she feels as though she is missing something and that she isn’t experiencing life as some of the other ladies her age are. Esther is faced with the thought of not being what she should be. Which is, what the other women of her age are expected to be, by society’s views....   [tags: The Bell Jar, Sylvia Plath]

Research Papers
1641 words (4.7 pages)

The Bell Jar, by Sylvia Plath Essay

- As one of the most renowned and well-known literary critics in the world of composition, Harold Bloom has self-importantly granted himself the privilege of specifying the reasons as to why we read. From human connection to self-actualization to the acquirement of knowledge, he adheres passionately and unquestionably that “the strongest, most authentic motive for deep reading…is the search for a difficult pleasure.” Bloom, as an experienced critic, fully recognizes the task of judging a book for its merit....   [tags: Analysis of The Bell Jar]

Research Papers
1303 words (3.7 pages)

Disillusionment In Hemingway's For Whom The Bell Tolls Essay

- Disillusionment in Hemingway's For Whom the Bell Tolls In the late 1930's, Spain was in the midst of a civil war. The country had been in a state of disarray since 1931, when King Alfonso XIII went into voluntary exile. This was followed by a five-year power struggle between the fascists, led by General Francesco Franco, and the Republicans. This struggle became violent in the summer of 1936, and the war lasted until 1939, when Franco's forces triumphed. (Thomas 600) Ernest Hemingway's 1940 novel For Whom the Bell Tolls tells the story of Robert Jordan and his Republican comrades as they resist the fascists in the fall of 1937....   [tags: Hemingway Bell Tolls]

Free Essays
1289 words (3.7 pages)

Alexander Graham Bell Essay

- Alexander Graham Bell Works Cited Missing The importance of Alexander Graham Bell on today’s society is visible, or rather audible, every day and everywhere. First and foremost, Alexander Graham Bell was a prolific teacher of the deaf. This is what he considered to be his true life’s work, but only one of the many important things he did. Through his research of speech and sound, and his creative mind, he would become one of the most influential inventors in modern history. His own definition of an inventor, “A man who looks upon the world and is not contented with things as they are....   [tags: Biography Biographies Bell Essays]

Research Papers
1705 words (4.9 pages)

Essay on The Science Behind The Bell Curve

- The Science Behind The Bell Curve       The science behind The Bell Curve has been denounced by both the American Psychological Association and the Human Genome Project. Its authors were unqualified to speak on either genetics or intelligence, since their expertise lay in other fields. Their project did not rise through the usual system of academic publishing, and in fact the authors ducked the process of peer review. The Bell Curve was ultimately funded by the wealthy, far-right Bradley Foundation, which used its media connections to launch a massive national publicity campaign....   [tags: Bell Curve Essays]

Free Essays
3306 words (9.4 pages)

Changes in For Whom The Bell Tolls Essay

- Changes in For Whom The Bell Tolls The novel For Whom The Bell Tolls was primarily about Hemingway's changes through wartime. Hemingway reveals these ideas about war through the narrator's thoughts and through the interaction between the major characters. Hemingway shows that war brings about a personal change, that reveals much about man's individuality and that time is limited. Hemingway reveals much about the individuality of men and the singularity of the code through the relationship of Robert Jordan and Maria....   [tags: For Whom the Bell Tolls Essays]

Research Papers
1115 words (3.2 pages)

The beneficiaries were the middle class and capitalists who had little or nothing to do with the physical work involved in building the bridge. The lower class that received little or no benefit from it were primarily those laborers working in the mills that produced the steel for the bridge. While the bridge is in New York, the steel mills that most likely produced the steel for it were located in Pittsburgh. The speakers at the grand opening spoke nothing about the hard work that had gone into the steel, the poor working and living conditions of workers, the lives lost, and the huge amounts of air and water pollution dumped on Western Pennsylvania each day. Bell describes the environmental damage to Pittsburgh in the following passage:

The mills had filled in the shore line for miles up and down the river, destroying trees, obliterating little streams and the pebbly beaches where as recently as the turn of the century campers had set up tents in summer, burying the clean earth under tons of cinder and molten slag. The banks no longer sloped naturally to the water's edge but dropped vertically, twenty-foot walls of cold slag pierced at intervals with steaming outlets and marked by dribbling stains. (Bell 153)
The opening of the bridge could not truly be a People's Day, as the speakers called it, if only a small, select group of people benefited from it. Perhaps Americans had won the "struggle of man to subdue the forces of nature to his control and use," but at what cost and to whom (Krause)? The wealthy of New York City may have paid for much of it with their money, but the true price paid was through the backbreaking labor and the suffering of the working class to produce the bridge.
The Reverend Richard Storrs spoke of the bridge as a "durable moment of Democracy itself" (Krause). This brings up questions as to what democracy really means. It is usually defined as a government for the people through elected representatives. So in a sense, one might assume that the bridge was built for the people because the people wanted it. However, the decision to spend the money and forge the steel and build the bridge, regardless of the human costs of that progress, most likely relied on the decisions of the wealthy upper class, politicians, and the capitalists of the industries that would benefit from it.

One of the most important points in Bell's novel is his refutation of the lack of a republican form of government for all people. Primarily the small group of upper class capitalists and the politicians that they kept in office to protect their financial and industrial interests made the country's decisions at this point in American history. Undoubtedly, Andrew Carnegie, for example, saw much greater advantages in the building of the Brooklyn Bridge than did one of the employees in his mills.

Mill workers and other laborers often did not vote, and if they did, it didn't have much effect on the outcome. In the following passage from Out of This Furnace, one character speaks to another about the division of power among classes and the political confinement of the immigrants:

There are men in that mill who were born here, whose fathers and grandfathers were born here. They know more English than you'll ever learn. And what good is their vote doing them? They have to work in the mill and eat dirt like any greenhorn. Let me tell you, I've been in America enough to know that it's run just like any other country. In Europe your emperors and grand dukes own everything and over here it's your millionaires and your trusts. They run the country to suit themselves, and don't think they're going to let you interfere every few years with your miserable vote. Get that into your head. Your vote means nothing. The company man always wins. If he isn't a company man to start with, he becomes one afterward; the millionaires see to that. (Bell 66-67)
Many of the workers who produced the steel for the Brooklyn Bridge were the same workers that had little or no political freedom or voting rights. Workers were not encouraged to vote, and if they decided to vote, the company forced them to vote for the politicians that would favor the company. In Out of This Furnace, Bell shows how mill officials pressured a steelworker:
Mike had registered as a Republican -- anything else would have been suicidal -- but had determined to vote for Eugene Debs, the Socialist. He knew the risk. Should he be found out -- and that the company had ways of learning how a man had voted nobody in Braddock doubted -- he would be fired. (Bell 189-190)
This type of political injustice and manipulation of a man's rights were one of the biggest problems in the steel mills and other large industries during the late nineteenth century.
The speakers also mentioned that the Brooklyn Bridge opening was "a day to celebrate Progress" (Krause). It is important to remember that capitalists and workers strove toward different ideas of progress in Out of This Furnace. While progress for the capitalists meant the further supremacy of man over nature or the unchecked accumulation of wealth, progress for the workers simply meant an improvement in their way of life and an opportunity for equality. These different viewpoints were perhaps the main cause of the disputes between the two classes. It should also be noted that the workers were not entirely anti-progress or anti-capitalist, but they did have certain problems with the way the capitalists ran their businesses and tried to control the local government.

Abram Hewitt remarked that the Brooklyn Bridge was "more than an embodiment of the scientific knowledge of physical laws or a symbol of social tendencies pointing inexorably toward a perfectly harmonious social order" (Krause). He also said that it was "equally a monument to the moral qualities of the human soul" (Krause). These statements may have been almost completely contradictory to the actual outcome. Because capitalists chose to drive their workers into the ground and force upon them very unfavorable working conditions, the workers began to unite against them. The organization of labor became a tool that the workers used to combat the tyranny of the capitalists. The early goals of organized labor were better working conditions and pay, and political insurgency. Amalgamation was perhaps the only way that the workers could begin to improve their lives.

Out of This Furnace shows how the mill workers organized themselves and eventually overcame the capitalists to provide better lives for themselves and hope for generations to come. It also shows the improvement in living conditions, equality, and political freedom experienced by the last generation of Bell's characters, which was a great victory for the working class. One character stated his view of the changes in this way:

It was the way you thought and felt about certain things. About freedom of speech and the equality of men and the importance of having one law -- the same law -- for rich and poor, for the people you liked and the people you didn't like. About the right of every man to live his life as he thought best, his right to defend it if anyone tried to change it and his right to change it himself if he decided he liked some other way of living better. About the uses to which wealth and power could honorably be put, and about honor itself, honor, integrity, self-respect, the whatever-you-wanted-to-call-it that determined for a man which things he couldn't say or do under any circumstances, not for all the money there was, not even to help his side win. (Bell 411)
This passage represents not only events in history, but the way that Bell chose to portray the workers' idea of progress and show what they regarded as important.

Hewitt, Storrs and other wealthy capitalists largely over-glorified the Brooklyn Bridge as an example of progress American history. The ceremonies they presided over represent only the views and the interests of wealthy capitalists and mention nothing of the working class or hardships endured to achieve the capitalists' idea of "progress." Thomas Bell saw these neglected workers as the backbone of American society and he emphasizes how these people strove for true progress in their lives. They were the unsung heroes of an industrializing nation. Without the efforts of this working class, the Brooklyn Bridge may still be an idea on the drawing board.
Return to 123HelpMe.com