Ethically Acceptable Method of Treatment
Is there any moral dilemma in making it mandatory to provide a means of life to those in need? In
the world at any given time there are countless individuals whose organs are failing them to the point of
threatening their lives. In the world at any given time there are also countless healthy individuals and
individuals taking their last breath, who possess what those aforementioned individuals need to survive.
Given this truth, we would argue that no opposition to organ donation outweighs the benefits of organ
donation. We propose that organ donation should be mandatory upon the death of an individual,
considered on a situational basis in cases where the donor is a living donor, and promoted in cases of
brain-dead donor patients on life support.
Review of Literature Addressing the Cons
Even though we support the perspective that organ donation should be mandatory we must not
neglect to consider the perspective of those opposed to this idea. Why are people against organ
donation? According to Mary Jiang Bresnahan and Kevin Mahler (2010), “guidelines offered by organ
procurement agencies do not mention that in several religions, the issue of the ethics of brain-dead
organ donation continues to be controversial” (p. 54). Religion offers a moral guideline for many
people who struggle with whether organ donation is an ethical solution to treat the physically ill,
especially in cases of brain-dead donors. According to Goeedele Baeke, Jean-Pierre Wils and Bert
Broeckaert (2011) “differences might relate to a different world view; indeed, world views, conceptions
of God, humankind and life – in other words, t...
... middle of paper ...
...they will likely run out before you get to the front of the line.
Only, you can live without the coffee; the people on the transplant waiting list cannot live
without the organ.
We have a resource that is in high demand – donor organs – seemingly caught in the gap
between donor and recipient on account of a moral dilemma. Given the statistics and
theoretical material available, it seems obvious that neither the right to not do good, nor
religious queries or deliberations on defining who is dead and who is “not dead” should
supersede the urgency of providing the necessity of life to those who need it. Protecting the
life of one who is living should not be forfeited for those perceived “norms” of those
apprehensive of a life-saving practice. We have the resource, now we must use it. The cost of not
using it is too high.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- ADVOCATING ORGAN DONATION 2 A Paper Advocating Organ Donation as an Ethically Acceptable Method of Treatment Is there any moral dilemma in making it mandatory to provide a means of life to those in need. In the world at any given time there are countless individuals whose organs are failing them to the point of threatening their lives. In the world at any given time there are also countless healthy individuals and individuals taking their last breath, who possess what those aforementioned individuals need to survive.... [tags: Organ transplant, Organ donation, Death]
1422 words (4.1 pages)
- There has been always a debate on the use of the animals in the biomedical research and experimentation. They are being used in this field for centuries now and have proved very beneficial and contributed in medical research far more than expected. With use of animals in research, the medical field has greatly advanced. But in these experiments a large number of animals are killed and animals have to suffer a lot of pain and distress. Considering these pros and corns the question arises, should animals be used in experimentation.... [tags: Animal Rights, Ethical Science]
1962 words (5.6 pages)
- ... Many people like to involve themselves with something that they do not really care about just because. Other people like to involve themselves in order to push a personal agenda, be it political or religious. When it comes to stem cell research, the people that are actually effected and whose opinions really matter are the investors, the scientists, and, possibly, the embryos. The easiest group of people to consider is the investors. Aside from the people who provide the funds for the research, investors include the people who give their genetic information to the research, including their eggs.... [tags: embryonic, adult, multipotent, pluripotent]
669 words (1.9 pages)
- Back in 1954 Dr. Joseph Murray and Dr. David Hume preformed the very first successful organ transplant that utilized a living donor ("History of Organ Donation & Transplants | New York Organ Donor Network," 2015). That miraculous event shows how far medical miracles have gone, and are continuously going. Organ transplants are permitting people to live longer and healthier lives. The only issue is that there is just not enough supply to meet the amount of demand. People should become organ donors, and be allowed to donate if they choose, because it can save lives and help to put an end the black market on organ sales.... [tags: Organ transplant, Organ donation]
1317 words (3.8 pages)
- Organ transplantation is a surgical procedure that can expand the life expectancy of someone who is suffering from a certain organ failure. The organ recipient and organ donor have to be cross-matched and be found compatible through a series of tests before that organ is deemed acceptable for transplantation to that individual. Unfortunately many people do not ever reach the process of cross matching since the demand versus the availability of donated organs is so high that many people die before they ever get the chance of receiving an organ.... [tags: Organ transplant, Human anatomy, Organ, Biology]
738 words (2.1 pages)
- Organ Sales: An Exploratory Essay Imagine being a hospitalized patient waiting for an organ donation to save your life, knowing that the amount of people in need of organs outweigh the amount of donors. This is a sad reality for many people across the United States due to the lack of available organs. The debate over monetary payment to donors to increase available organs has been an ongoing fight for over 30 years. In 1984 an act was passed to put tight restrictions on organ sales through Task Force on Organ Procurement and Transplantation, which resulted in a depleted amount of available organs.... [tags: Organ transplant, Organ donation, Organ]
1556 words (4.4 pages)
- Within the United States, an archaic system is in place that costs roughly thirty American lives every day; this system is the organ donation process. Waiting lists can potentially involve thousands of different patients in need of a vital organ to prolong their lives; however, some of these patients never have the opportunity to receive a kidney or a lung due to the lack of donations. Other nations have found a way to eliminate these long, waiting lists, including Iran, by providing citizens with an incentive to donate: money.... [tags: Organ transplant, Organ, Organ donation]
715 words (2 pages)
- When an individual is diagnosed with organ complications and qualify for receiving a new organ, they are placed on a waiting list. Individuals whose name appears on the list live a highly restrictive life, which they could be forced to live for years due to the shortage of organ donors in comparison to those in need of the donations. Individuals risk being on the donation list for anywhere from a few months or until the end of their life, because they cannot receive an organ unless it is compatible with their body makeup and is from an individual who lived in their region.... [tags: Organ transplant, Organ donation, Organ]
1126 words (3.2 pages)
- Bullying: The Acceptable Halt on Unacceptable Treatment The high school years of a students life has its pros and its cons. It can often times be stressful and overwhelming, but high school should be some of the most fun filled and memorable years of a teens life. There are clubs to join, sports to participate in, prom to attend, and many more fun activities. High school, however, does have a major con, which is bullying. Bullying can be acts of violence such as fighting, or it can verbal such as name-calling, spreading rumors about someone, and a number of many more harmful actions or words towards a person.... [tags: High school, Bullying, Education, Teacher]
1190 words (3.4 pages)
- Organ Transplantation Since the 18th century, scientists have been researching and discovering new developments that deal with the process of obtaining organs and tissues and transplanting them to other organisms that are in need of new ones. In the early days, around the time when Mary Shelley wrote Frankenstein, not much was understood about the entire process causing people to come up with their own theories and solutions. As more trials were completed, success came to the table around the mid-20th century, when scientists were performing the first successful organ transplants ("Learn About The History Of Transplant - OPTN").... [tags: Organ transplant, Organ donation, Surgery, Organ]
1127 words (3.2 pages)