Opposition Of The Common Good Essay

Opposition Of The Common Good Essay

Length: 2204 words (6.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

To make this argument I will first outline this thought with regard to this issue. Second, I will address an argument in support of Rousseau’s view. Third, I will entertain the strongest possible counterargument to my view; namely, the idea that the general will contradicts itself by forcing freedom upon those who gain no freedom from the general will. Fourth, I will rebut that counter argument by providing evidence that the general will is always in favor of the common good. Finally, I will conclude my paper by summarizing the main lines of the argument of my paper and reiterate my thesis that we can force people to be free.
In the Social Contract, Rousseau discusses the idea of forced freedom. “Whoever refuses to obey the general will shall be constrained to do so by the entire body; which means nothing other than that he shall be forced to be free” (Rousseau, SC, Bk 1. Ch. 7). This forced freedom is necessary for a government that is run by the people and not a small group of few to one sovereign(s). For forced freedom allows a difference of opinions but the outcome is the idea with the greatest acceptance. Because political rule requires the consent of the ruled, the citizens of the state are required to take action within their community. The action within the community will allow the state to see the general will of the people. The general will creates laws within the state, that reflect the people’s thoughts and beliefs that move towards a common good for all citizens.
I will now argue that forced freedom allows generally accepted ideas to become laws. Generally accepted ideas are called the general will. The general will allows citizens to vote not with themselves in mind, but the well-being of the entire state and its peo...

... middle of paper ...

...eligion knows no constraint, there are many types of religions within one state. Rousseau’s idea are only viable if the state has one religion.
In conclusion, a man can be forced to be free if his views are contrary to the general will. First, I outlined my arguments about why being forced to be free is necessary. My arguments supporting Rousseau’s ideas included; generally accepted ideas, government responsibility, and responsibility to the government. Second, I entertained the strongest possible counterargument against forced freedom, which is the idea that the general will contradicts itself by forcing freedom upon those who gain no freedom from the general will. Lastly, I rebutted the counterargument by providing evidence that the general will is always in favor of the common good. In this paper I argued in agreement Rousseau that we can force people to be free.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Censorship Is Subversive Of The Common Good Essay

- What does it actually mean for a particular item, expression, or image within society to be censored. According to Encyclopedia Britannica, a suitable definition for the term censorship is as follows: “the changing or the suppression or prohibition of speech or writing that is deemed subversive of the common good.” With this explanation in mind, I confidently stand in opposition to the notion of censorship because I am under the impression that such a government-based concept and action utterly contradicts the rights clearly given to citizens in the First Amendment of the United States Constitution, and therefore, censorship has no role in a truly democratic civilization like our own (Anast...   [tags: Fahrenheit 451, Censorship, Ray Bradbury]

Better Essays
1008 words (2.9 pages)

Political Life and Man’s Ultimate End: Reading the De Regno of St. Thomas Aquinas

- St. Thomas’ purpose in writing the De Regno is to provide practical guidance for a Christian king on how it is that he ought to conduct his proper authority. The king, imitating God, is to lead those subject to him to their proper end, and this will be nothing other than communal virtue. This instantiation of the practice of citizen-wide virtue is the intrinsic finality belonging to political society, and for St. Thomas, it is the genuine concern of the king to lead and direct citizens towards the common good....   [tags: authority, common good, governance]

Better Essays
2549 words (7.3 pages)

Common Core Not for the Common Good Essay example

- “Nineteen countries and education systems scored higher than the United States in reading on the 2012 Program for International Student Assessment, or PISA, up from nine systems when the test was last administered in 2009. “While we’re standing still, other countries are making progress,” said Jack Buckley, the commissioner of the National Center for Education Statistics, which issued the U.S. report on PISA.” (Heitin). From the outside the initiative, “Common Core” that President Obama and the government have been pushing since 2009 seems like it would be a great thing for education ,our children, and the future of our society, but once you look closer it is not....   [tags: public schools, education system]

Better Essays
1080 words (3.1 pages)

Education: Will the Federal Government Encouraging States to Adopt the Common Core Curriculum Ensure a More Educated Nation?

- The federal government encouraging states to adopt the Common Core curriculum will not now, nor will it ever, ensure a more educated nation. The Common Core represents a federal takeover of our education system and will compromise the future of the United States. The Common Core mission statement is flowery, embellished, and designed to mislead the American public. The Common Core State Standards provide a consistent, clear understanding of what students are expected to learn, so teachers and parents know what they need to do to help them....   [tags: Common Core Curriculum, Students]

Better Essays
1143 words (3.3 pages)

Theories Of Perspective, And The Opposition, Why Humans ' Perspectives Of Reality

- Think about everyday life. Imagine everything that is experienced in a single day, whether it is through sight, smell, touch, and/or taste. Now, what if someone said that what is experienced is not how it is in reality. This statement is confusing, but the perspective of every being is different, so if that is true, who is actually viewing the world “correctly”. This is to say, who is viewing her environment as it actually looks. This may seem unbelievable, but it is the truth. In this essay, it will be explained through perspective, theories of perspective, and the opposition, why humans’ perspectives of reality are not accurate representations of said reality....   [tags: Reality, Theory, Perception, Truth]

Better Essays
1230 words (3.5 pages)

Essay about In Opposition of an Amendment to Ban Flag Desecration

- In Opposition of an Amendment to Ban Flag Desecration In 1876 a Constitutional amendment was proposed that would eliminate the Senate. In 1893, there was an amendment proposed that would get rid of the Army and the Navy, and another one that would rename the country the United States of the Earth. They all share one common dominator: they would do absolutely nothing to benefit the United States or its citizens. To this list another proposed amendment can be added: the amendment banning desecration of the American flag....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Argument Essays]

Free Essays
343 words (1 pages)

Political Theories Of Democracy Focus On Competition, Contestation, And The Common Good

- Political theorists and philosophers have long grappled with attempting to intellectually define, explain, and model the complex interactions that take place among political man. Specifically, the topic of discussion over the past two weeks empirical theories of democracy focus on competition, contestation, and the common good. All of these topics are related to the success and development of modern democracy. However, as discussed by Dahl democratization is an imperfect process and governments never fully achieve democracy in its purest form....   [tags: Democracy, Government, Rationality, Voting]

Better Essays
1949 words (5.6 pages)

The Need for the Legalization of Physician-Assisted Suicide Essay

- Throughout the course of history, advances in medical technology have prolonged the length of life and delayed death; however, terminal illnesses still exist and modern medicine is often unable to prevent death. Many people turn to a procedure known as Physician-Assisted suicide, a process by which a doctor aids in ending a terminally ill patient’s life. This procedure is painless and effective, allowing patients to control their death and alleviate unnecessary suffering. In spite of these benefits, Physician-Assisted suicide is illegal in many places both nationally and internationally....   [tags: ethics, illness, opposition]

Better Essays
2478 words (7.1 pages)

Opposition between Liberalism and Conservatism Essay

- People’s views on a wide range of issues are influenced or determined by the kind of foundational belief systems they hold. Therefore, the difference in the nature of opinions among individuals or groups of people alludes to the existence of distinct belief systems. In the course of history, the distinction between Liberalism and Conservatism has become more vivid particularly in the political arena where various players have expressed opposing points of view regarding the nation’s future. It is indeed undisputable that the foundational beliefs of Liberalism are diametrically opposed to those of Conservatism....   [tags: Conservatism vs. Liberalism]

Better Essays
974 words (2.8 pages)

Essay on Horace Mann and the Common School

- Horace Mann and the Common School Horace Mann’s concept of the common school stressed many ideals, chief among them the need to create an institution capable of preparing students to contribute positively to the community and society as a whole. In order to achieve this lofty goal, Horace Mann advocated three main ideas. The first was a commitment to instilling Protestant virtues in the students. Secondly, Mann supported the idea that a community should be taxed to support the school in order to create a bond between the school and the community....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
653 words (1.9 pages)