Opposing Views On Othello 's Othello Essay

Opposing Views On Othello 's Othello Essay

Length: 1548 words (4.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Opposing Views on Character Fault in Shakespeare’s Othello
In Shakespeare’s Othello, the main characters suffer a tragic demise at the end. While it is clear that somebody is to blame for the unfortunate events, the main culprit behind the tragedy remains unclear. Three different authors, the humanists Baldassare Castiglione, Juan Luis Vives, and the Puritan preacher William Whately would all disagree on which character is to blame. While Castiglione would put Iago at fault for his misogynistic words and actions, Vives would say that Brabantio is the one to blame for his lack of control over his daughter Desdemona, and Whately would argue that Othello could have avoided this whole ordeal through forgiveness. While these different writers have good arguments for their side, Vives has the strongest argument. The tragedy carried out in Othello would have never occurred if Brabantio played his role as a father and stopped Desdemona from doing whatever she wanted. Had Brabantio played the role of a good father, he would have had Desdemona’s elopement annulled, which would have inhibited Iago from manipulating Othello.
Baldassare Castiglione would defend Desdemona based on interpretations in his work The Book of the Courtier. In The Book of the Courtier, Castiglione speaks of the duties and traits of an ideal noble woman. One of the things that Castiglione mentions that a perfect woman should have is a “ready liveliness of wit” (Castiglione 269). In addition, the ideal lady should have “a certain sweetness in language that may delight, whereby she may gently entertain all types of men with talk worth the hearing, and honest” (Castiglione 269). Such women are expected to speak to men besides their husbands and to “entertain… m...


... middle of paper ...


...ed.
While the three authors, Baldassare Castiglione, Juan Luis Vives, and William Whately all would have very good arguments as to who is most at fault in Othello, Vives’ would be the strongest. Vives’ points would be the strongest due to him using other sources to support his work, and for pointing out that Brabantio should have taken more care into his daughter’s well being. Brabantio neglects Desdemona allowing her to easily escape and elope with Othello. While some of his points are a little extreme in that they view women as property, Brabantio still should have performed his duty as a father and watched over Desdemona. However, Brabantio does the opposite and basically sets up the stage for Iago to use Desdemona for his gain, and to get hamed. Had Brabantio have been a good father, Othello’s tragic ending would have never occurred in the manner that it did.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Tough Love in William Shakespeare’s play, Othello Essay

- In William Shakespeare’s tragic play, Othello, Desdemona asserts, “‘wouldst thou do such a deed for all the world?’” (4.3.76). During a friendly banter, Desdemona asks Emilia this very question; would she cheat on her husband to help him become monarch and have power over all the world. She quietly replies that she would only in secret, but only for her husband’s own good. This question plays an essential role throughout Othello because Emilia is first accused of cheating on her husband. Additionally, she is obsequious towards Iago because of her female role and responsibility as a wife....   [tags: Othello]

Better Essays
1096 words (3.1 pages)

Animality and Beauty in Shakespeare's Othello Essay

- Othello - Animality and Beauty  At the most superficial level, the view of Shakespeare’s Othello as ‘animality and darkness’ in opposition to ‘beauty and light’ seems justified if the audience considers the 'motiveless malignity' of Iago against the pure, seemingly perfect union of Othello and Desdemona. This assumes that the 'animality and darkness' is to be found in the villain and the beauty and light in the love of the tragic hero and heroine as well as in the latter's physical beauty. There is ample textual evidence for this most basic of views, most effectively demonstrated in an early conversation between Iago and Othello's lieutenant , Cassio, by all accounts an honourable gentle...   [tags: GCSE Coursework Shakespeare Othello]

Better Essays
569 words (1.6 pages)

Othello: the Noble Savage Essay

- Othello: The Noble Savage There are many opposing views to the way that Othello is defined within Shakespeare's The Tragedy of Othello. Some suggest that Othello is a savage "Moor," and at no point is he the noble "Venetian" he attempts to portray himself as. Others suggest that Othello is the noble "Venetian" he portrays himself as, and his ultimate demise stems directly from Iago being a savage. Yet some agree that Othello is both the noble "Venetian" and the savage "Moor," unable to fully interpolate himself into the "Venetian" paradigm, but becoming, rather, a "noble savage." When the play begins, Othello is introduced as a military leader and a Christian, both characteristics of a...   [tags: European Literature]

Better Essays
1896 words (5.4 pages)

Essay on How William Shakespeare Presents Othello in Act 1

- How William Shakespeare Presents Othello in Act 1 Shakespeare successfully creates ambiguity in his portrayal of Othello's character. He is seen as a man of opposing qualities and is presented as both an animalistic and intensly passionate foreigner, as well as a trusted, noble and honourable General in the Venetian army. Shakespeare was interested in the whole question of actors playing roles where they could convince an audience that they were something they were not such as a saint or a woman....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
957 words (2.7 pages)

Essay about Opposing Views On Animal Experimentation

- Opposing Views on Animal Experimentation Animal experimentation sends a different message to everyone. The two sides are made of those who think animal testing is beneficial for life and those who think it is unethical and wrong. Those who find these tests to be beneficial are consist of researchers, scientists, and other observers. People and groups who perceive these tests to be cruel and unethical, consist of animal rights activists and organizations that fight for animals rights, such as PETA and ASPCA....   [tags: Animal rights]

Better Essays
1212 words (3.5 pages)

Opposing Views on African Colonialization Essay

- The scramble for Africa and consequent colonization, a term used to describe European economic and cultural penetration, occurred between the 1870s and 1900. For some African states, imperial rule saw to their economic development through the implementation of infrastructure and institutions. In the case of others, little or a negative impact was felt, resulting in their present state of technological-backwardness. This regional heterogenic development has led to the emergence of two opposing views....   [tags: culture, infrastructure, economy]

Better Essays
704 words (2 pages)

Two Opposing Views Of Learning Curve Essay

- Two Opposing Views of Learning Curve The learning curve is a method of teaching which is based on low standards and consequently encourages students to pursue higher education. Nowadays, the curve is still debated on whether it is beneficial to students or harmful. In his article, “Grading Curve Benefits Students Through Competition,” David Oberman, a finance major, delineates the benefits of the learning curve used in certain colleges. Oberman uses an optimistic, yet vibrant, tone to express the fact that the curve system rewards the high achieving students while at the same time not hindering other students....   [tags: High school, Education, Learning curve, College]

Better Essays
968 words (2.8 pages)

The Universe: The Design Argument by William Paley Essay

- In this paper I will present two differing views on the topic of the design argument. In particular, I will explain William Paley's view supporting the design argument and Bertrand Russell's view against the design argument. After a presentation of the differing views, I will then evaluate the arguments to show that William Paley has a stronger argument. There are several forms of the design argument. The general form of the design argument starts with the basic idea that certain parts of the universe are such that they indicate that they have been designed and have a purpose....   [tags: bertrand rusell, opposing views]

Better Essays
1139 words (3.3 pages)

Essay about The Opposing Views of Great Minds

- The Opposing Views of Great Minds The word metaphysics is defined as “The study or theory of reality; sometimes used more narrowly to refer to transcendent reality, that is, reality which lies beyond the physical world and cannot therefore be grasped by means of the senses.” It simply asks what is the nature of being. Metaphysics helps us to reach beyond nature as we see it, and to discover the `true nature' of things, their ultimate reason for existing. There are many ways to approach metaphysics....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
1050 words (3 pages)

Opposing Views of the Effectiveness of Monetary Policy Essay

- Opposing Views of the Effectiveness of Monetary Policy Monetary policy is a powerful governmental weapon which has historically proven that it is difficult to wield. This difficulty is one of the reasons why some economists doubt the effectiveness of monetary policy as a whole. These economists find that monetary policy is difficult to implement because of estimation problems and time lag problems, as well as cyclic effects. They also point out situations in which monetary policy may not work at all....   [tags: Economics Economy Essays]

Better Essays
1430 words (4.1 pages)