Open Controversy : Weaknesses And Genetic Classification Theories Essay

Open Controversy : Weaknesses And Genetic Classification Theories Essay

Length: 1329 words (3.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Open Controversy: Weaknesses in Genetic Classification Theories
According to DeGraf (2014, p. 233), in spite of the volumes of studies on creole, it has not been “operationalized with rigorous and reliable criteria in linguistic theory.” Creole is a sociohistorically as well as politically-motivated construct that is usually misidentified as linguistic (DeGraf 2014; Mufwene, 2008). The word creole itself comes from the Portuguese
word “crioulo” as well as the Spanish “criollo” which generally means “raised in the home” (DeGraf 2014, p. 233). The term was first used in the classification of certain animal and plant varieties rather than in languages. In the history of the Caribbean, the term was eventually used for the classification of biological beings, including man. Therefore, the word “Creole” usually precedes the official classifications of different types of species. As seen here, the original use of creole did not have any structural properties, and may be applied as a descriptor of speech varieties rather than species varieties.
DeGraf (2014) explains that the original creole speakers were those working in Caribbean plantations (Classic creole) with significant influence from African and European languages. It was developed gradually by both children and adults in different contact circumstances. According to DeGraf (2014), this development had been impacted by complex sociohistorical dimensions that encompass “a continuumof social divides and power asymmetries” (DeGraf, 2014, p. 233).
One end of the continuum is defined by inequality between dominant and dominated groups: these were the European speakers of superstrate (dominant) and the speakers of African substrate languages (dominated). At the opposite end of the sp...


... middle of paper ...


...ich the comparative method may be applied. However, far worse, creoles are considered as linguistic forms that have no predecessors. This belief is associated with another myth about creole that it is a modern replica of human language that is yet at its infancy.
This myth that creole emerged out of broken transmission is discredited by relatively recent studies using comparative data as well as empirical and theoretical evidence (DeGraf, 2014). Notably, studies have shown that there are “systematic lexical and morpho-syntactic correspondences between radical Creoles and their European lexifiers” right from the start of their emergence (DeGraf, 2014, p. 234). Researchers have also shown that African substrate languages have been transferred to Creole grammars. This is not surprising as a result of the Caribbean history as well as findings of L2 acquisition studies.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Strengths and Weaknesses of Biological Positivism Essay

- Biological Positivism has both its strengths and weaknesses, it changed the way of criminological ideas and opened up new theories that were based on scientific facts rather than philosophical ideas like in Classicism. It also highlighted the importance of looking into peoples genetic make-up as research such as Brunners' research into the extra 'Y' chromosome which led to the idea that genetic defects in a family can cause abnormal behaviours and also the Twin and Adoptions studies that showed a correlation between genetics and crime....   [tags: Criminology, Behaviors, Theories]

Better Essays
2095 words (6 pages)

Essay about Genetic Engineering And The Field Of Genetics

- Recent developments in the field of genetics have led to significant change in the way genetics contribute in medicine. Genomics is the human genetic information lying inside the nucleus of a human cell, which provides all the qualities, physical and psychological characteristics of a living organism. Classical genetic is a term which means the methods and techniques used in the study of genetics before the advent of molecular biology these techniques are: genetic and SNP (Single-nucleotide polymorphism) mapping, gene linkage, and pedigree analysis to identify genes responsible for traits that cause diseases (Paritosh, K....   [tags: Genetics, Gene, DNA, Genetic disorder]

Better Essays
1513 words (4.3 pages)

Classification Essay: The Types of Drinkers

- “I drink to make other people more interesting.” ― Ernest Hemingway In the great world of tending bar there is a myriad selection of customers one would encounter; The Social Drinker, The Self Defined Outcast, The Fish Out of Water, and last but never the least, The Freshman. Each level of drinker has its advantages in social circles and also has equal negative repercussions. Most of these classes aren't built from years of drinking, rather are formed through the personality traits they already have developed through their childhood and young adulthood....   [tags: Classification Essay]

Better Essays
1017 words (2.9 pages)

Classification of Dog Personalities Essay

- As the owner of three unique pups, I know that dogs’ variances are numerous. Any one who owns a dog knows that it has a mind of its own, and therefore a unique personality. Having had many dogs throughout my life, I have found that dogs fit into three classifications. Annie dogs As princesses of the canine universe, Annie type dogs have a loving yet manipulative personality. An Annie dog assumes the role of queen bee. As leader of the pack, she keeps everybody in line. She dominates all of the other dogs, often by physical herding or malicious growl....   [tags: Classification Essay]

Better Essays
912 words (2.6 pages)

Classifications of Beer Essay

- Classifications of Beer What's more refreshing on a hot summer day than an ice cold beer. How about drinking a cold one with some friends at a local bar after a hard day's work, sounds satisfying doesn't it. Beer has been around for hundreds years and will be around for hundreds more. A beer is any variety of alcoholic beverages produced by the fermentation of starchy material derived from grains or other plant sources....   [tags: Classification Essay]

Better Essays
1332 words (3.8 pages)

Classification Essay - Exercise Partners

- Classification of Exercise Partners Every woman's magazine I've ever read gives its readers advice on exercising, and one of the most common tips I've seen is to find a partner to exercise with. In my experience, however, having an exercise partner is not a good idea. I have encountered five types of exercise partners, and I have concluded that it is definitely best to exercise alone. The Drill Sergeant My ex-boyfriend represents the Drill Sergeant. He is one of those people whose motto is "No pain, no gain." Of course, he assumes that everyone else follows this decree as well....   [tags: Classification Essays]

Better Essays
948 words (2.7 pages)

Classification of Movie Goers Essay

- Classification of Movie Goers Many people go to the movies. The movies are an escape into a fantasy world. Everyone has a different preference on what kind of movie is the best. Romance, horror, action, and comedy are different types of movies. The kind of movie someone goes to see can give clues to what kind of person they are. People who prefer horror films obviously like to be grossed out or like to be frightened. The horror fans probably tend to enjoy suspense and anxiety. One might suspect these people love to go on frightening roller coaster rides or do other things that would cause suspense and anxiousness....   [tags: Classification Essay ]

Free Essays
523 words (1.5 pages)

Classification of Restaurant Customers Essay

- Classification of Restaurant Customers “I’ve been here for ten minutes and my server hasn’t taken my order yet!” This is a direct quote from me before I worked at a restaurant. I never looked to see how many tables my server actually had or how much running I made them do. The sad truth is most people do not notice these details either, which may affect the tip their server will receive. By looking at the attitude and maintenance of restaurant customers, you can classify them into three categories according to their tipping patterns: the “hmm…how good were they....   [tags: Classification Essay]

Free Essays
578 words (1.7 pages)

Classification of Psychic Experiences Essay

- Classification of Psychic Experiences Generally speaking, psychic experiences which deal with receiving information from an outside source, either living or passed on can be classified into the following categories: psychometry, telepathy, clairvoyance, clairaudience, automatic writing and channeling. Two more psychic techniques, assumption and projection, deal with transferring the personality to a remote location. Psychometry is the art of receiving information about someone by touching an object commonly carried by that person such as a key chain or jewelry....   [tags: Classification Essays]

Better Essays
1105 words (3.2 pages)

Classification of Beer Essay

- Classification of Beer What's more refreshing on a hot summer day than a nice cold beer. Or how about drinking a nice cold one with some buddies after work at a local bar, sound nice doesn?t it. Beer has been around for many years and will probably be around for many more. A beer is any variety of alcoholic beverages produced by the fermentation of starchy material derived from grains or other plant sources. The production of beer and some other alcoholic beverages is often called brewing. Most every culture has there own tradition and the own take on beer, thus producing many different styles and variations....   [tags: Classification Essays Beer Alcohol Essays]

Free Essays
1307 words (3.7 pages)