The On Free Will And God 's Foreknowledge Essay

The On Free Will And God 's Foreknowledge Essay

Length: 1470 words (4.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In Critical Reflection #4 Augustine’s contention on free-will and God’s foreknowledge was explored. Here it was established by Augustine that God’s foreknowledge and freewill are in fact compatible, and that to deny the foreknowledge of God and yet embrace his existence is madness (City of God, Book 5). Yet this is only one side of an ongoing debate, in City of God Book 5 another philosopher, Cicero, makes a very different argument. Cicero believes that if God in fact has foreknowledge of all that is to happen, everything is predestined, therefore free-will is nothing but an illusion and our existence as God’s creation is undermined. As such, it is Cicero’s contention that God’s foreknowledge and free will are incompatible and cannot exist together. This paper will seek to explore both sides of this argument and come to a final answer to the question of compatibly between foreknowledge and freewill.
First up, Augustine. When espousing his notion that God 's foreknowledge and free will are compatible. Augustine says, “we assert both that God knows all things before they come to pass, and that we do by our free will whatsoever we know and feel to be done by us only because we will it" (Steinberger 470). He further states, “for our wills themselves are included in that order of causes which is certain to God, and is embraced by His foreknowledge, for human wills are also causes of human actions; and He who foreknew all the causes of things would certainly among those causes not have been ignorant of our wills" (Steinberger 470). From these excerpts one can draw the following analysis: God knows all things without undermining free-will, because the free wills themselves are causes. God has foreknowledge of these causes. God 's knowle...

... middle of paper ...

...rtainty of our actions, and that having a choice depends on the presence of genuine options. This dilemma is present in Peter Kreeft’s analogy of the story, here the presence of an omniscient author (God) does not allow for true choice if our actions are actually determined by the outcome of the story and not by our own choice. The second factor derives from the idea that the truth and presence of predetermination means that we don’t cause our actions in a significant way and our actions are not ultimately controlled by us. In other words, we lack the ability for self-determination. This dilemma is present in Augustine’s later notion of massa damnata, here God because of our tendency to sin has already predetermined who will be sinners and who will be saved, a controversial notion that only further compounds the fact that foreknowledge and free-will are incompatible.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Augustine's Thoughts on Free Will Essay

- One thing that philosophers are great at is asking big questions, usually without providing answers. However, Saint Augustine has a more direct approach to his speculation, often offering a solution to the questions he poses. One such topic he broached in The City of God against the pagans. In this text, Augustine addresses the problem of free will and extends his own viewpoint. Stating that humankind can have free will with an omniscient God, he clarifies by defining foreknowledge, free will, and how they can interact successfully together (Augustine, 198)....   [tags: free will, saint augustine, god]

Better Essays
752 words (2.1 pages)

Essay about Discourse Of Free Will And The How It Correlates With God 's Grace

- In our reading on Discourse of Free Will, we get a good idea of the opinions both Erasmus and Luther had on the topic of free will and the how it correlates with God’s grace. Once we look beyond the back and forth debate of this text, we will begin to look at their theological opinions on free will separately to find a better understanding and formulate our own opinions on this commonly debated topic. As we look to the different points of view between Luther and Erasmus, we will begin looking at Discourse on Free Will....   [tags: God, Theology, Free will, Predestination]

Better Essays
1165 words (3.3 pages)

Essay on Divine Foreknowledge

- Divine Foreknowledge Growing up as a Christian, in the Christian church, I was always taught that God knows everything. God knows the beginning and end, and everything in between. This is something that, until one starts asking tough questions, one usually accepts. My goal in writing this essay is not to change someone’s beliefs about God, or beliefs in God, but instead to challenge people to quote, un-quote, think outside the box. Consider the pros and cons of God knowing everything and also be open to other solutions....   [tags: Essays Papers]

Better Essays
1604 words (4.6 pages)

God Knows All Things : Boethius 's Argument Essay

- There are countless aspects that we could attribute to God. That he is eternal, immutable, infinite, the list goes on and on. However, one attribute of God that I found to be the most interesting and overall shocking to ask is whether we as humans have free will if God knows all things. This question has forever been a sense of conflict in my eyes, if God knew all things and knew how I would react in every situation then what is the point of this life. What then is the point to even believe in a God that would knowingly send me out into this world already knowing exactly how I would react to every situation....   [tags: Time, Future, Free will, God]

Better Essays
1000 words (2.9 pages)

Essay about The Existence And Nature Of God

- When somebody asks me if I believe in God, I always have responded with a firm confirmation. Without hesitation, I am confident in my Catholic upbringing and belief in God. However, I have never truly been asked, “Why?” by anybody expecting an in depth answer. I have gone my whole life in ignorant confidence of my belief but never truly considered the reason or nature behind my faith. This semester, we have analyzed different thinkers, philosophers, and theologians as they discussed their ideas....   [tags: God, Omnipotence, Religion, Augustine of Hippo]

Better Essays
1122 words (3.2 pages)

The Loss Of Your Mother Essay

- Dear Jenny, I apologize to hear about the loss of your mother. I understand that you would like to discuss how the issues that you have relates to gods existence. The specific question is whether this problem of evil contradicts the traditional idea of God. The key points in the two arguments that are being held in regards to whether or not the problem of evil contradicts the traditional idea of God is that Augustine argues the reason why God is an all knowing foreseeing God and how actions are done out of choice....   [tags: Free will, God, Predestination, Choice]

Better Essays
1739 words (5 pages)

God's Nature vs. Man's Free Will Essay

- God's Nature vs. Man's Free Will The reconciliation of God's nature and Man's free will has long been a subject of debate for philosophers and theologians. Christianity rests upon certain ideas about the nature of God and the universe. The Bible speaks of God as eternal, all-knowing, and as the very author of reality. The concept of God as a benevolent, omniscient, omnipotent, and omnipresent entity is rooted in thousands of years of church tradition. This tradition is so ingrained in Western culture, that, when one mentions "God", these ideas almost invariably come to mind....   [tags: Philosophy Religion Essays]

Better Essays
1913 words (5.5 pages)

God´s Redemptive Promises in Jesus and the New Covenant Essay

- When we read and study the Bible, we are able to learn so many different messages and themes. This paper is going to discuss about the fulfillment of God's redemptive promises in Jesus and the New Covenant as expressed in the teaching about God's kingdom, God's choice of his people, Jesus' sacrificial death, and the visible expression of this in churches. The kingdom of the God is one of the common themes to both the Old and New Testament. Since the New Testament builds upon the literal meaning of the Old Testament message, a thorough study of both testaments is necessary to understand the kingdom....   [tags: kingdom, death, churches, people]

Better Essays
932 words (2.7 pages)

Milton 's Paradise Lost And The Concept Of Free Will Essay

- Milton’s Paradise Lost and the Concept of Free Will Within the context of Paradise Lost, it seems that Milton viewed free will as being somewhere between the ability to do whatever you wish and having all of your life events predetermined by God. Using this definition of free will Adam, Eve, Satan, the Son, and the Angels have the ability to choose their actions within situations that have been predetermined by, or are at least known to, God. It can then be proposed that the fall was not predetermined and that Adam and Eve had the choice to reject the temptation they were presented with but failed, leading to the fall of mankind....   [tags: Adam and Eve, Garden of Eden, Paradise Lost]

Better Essays
1376 words (3.9 pages)

Greek Philosophy On Fate By Alexander Of Aphrodisias Denied Three Beliefs

- Divine Foreknowledge. Greek philosophy didn’t have an exact term for "free will" as Latin did, the argument was more about responsibility and things that depend on us. A Peripatetic (taught the methods of Aristotle) philosopher, during the late 2nd century and the beginning of the 3rd century CE. Alexander of Aphrodisias denied three beliefs that were held strong in Greek philosophy, those were; the foreknowledge of fated events, determinism, and necessity. Alexander believed that man is responsible for their own decisions, and have the free will to do something or not....   [tags: Free will, God, Philosophy, Causality]

Better Essays
1609 words (4.6 pages)