On Experts and Global Warming Essay

On Experts and Global Warming Essay

Length: 880 words (2.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Global warming is an increasingly common subject in our political realm, and the opposing sides seem to be farther apart and more contentious than ever. In his article at NYTimes.com, “On Experts and Global Warming”, Gary Gutting argues that given the nature of the arguments this should no longer be the case. The use of experts as evidence for each side’s belief, he suggests, takes the argument out of the hands of “nonexperts” and places it within the climate scientists’ domain. While this is the example he uses, Gutting, a professor of philosophy at the University of Notre Dame, makes it clear that this isn’t the only forum where his idea applies.
Gutting’s idea is simple, if the two sides agree that a certain topic falls into the area of expertise of a given group, then they must accept the consensus on the subject of that group. He uses Global Warming as an example of a current issue that exemplifies his idea. Gutting points out that both sides have recognized “climate scientists” as the experts on this subject since both use studies and statements from this field to support their beliefs. Since the opposing parties have agreed on a field of expertise, Gutting argues that the consensus of that field on the topic should be accepted by each. “As long as they accept the expert authority of the discipline of climate science, they have no basis for supporting the minority position” (Gutting, 2011). Being “nonexperts” themselves, opponents are in no position to reject the conclusions of the majority, leaving only one other option. “It follows that a nonexpert who wants to reject [anthropogenic global warming] can do so only by arguing that climate science lacks the scientific status needed be taken seriously in our debates about pu...


... middle of paper ...


...sophisticated tone of the paper. While this makes his idea less emotionally appealing, the logical style will help the audience relate and comprehend it. Gutting’s article is an effective argument within the exigencies, and the constraints he places on his argument help clarify its’ meaning and purpose. His idea will be increasingly relevant to his audience in many of the upcoming discussions around the primaries and the general election itself.



References
Gutting, G. (2011, July 12). "On Experts and Global Warming". Retrieved September 04, 2011, from NYTimes.com - Opinionator: http://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/07/12/on-experts-and-global-warming/
Montopoli, B. (2011, August 17). "Rick Perry Suggests Global Warming Is a Hoax". Retrieved September 04, 2011, from CBSNews.com - Political Hotsheet: http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-503544_162-20093535-503544.html

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Global Warming: Humans Are Destroying the Planet

- There has been much discussion recently about global warming do you know what are the causes behind the global warming. The phrase Global Warming has specific meaning. "Global" means something above borders or international. "Warming" means an alarm that something bad will happen. The whole phrase means increase in the average temperature of the earth's atmosphere that causes changes in climate around the whole world, which refers to the meaning of global. For years, global warming was a scientific theory nobody cared about except scientists....   [tags: Global Warming Essay]

Free Essays
1156 words (3.3 pages)

A Global Disaster: Global Warming Essay

- When disasters ensue, proper response must be thoughtfully recognized and relief thoroughly enacted. Without recognition, said disasters still exist - there can be no “blissful ignorance” - and without relief, said disasters do not repair themselves. Global warming, a worldwide disaster, poses a dangerous threat. Large portions of coastal cities will need to relocate, harsh droughts and heat waves will strike, and strong weather systems will develop. These effects will occur globally and affect everyone....   [tags: environmental issues/concerns]

Better Essays
1901 words (5.4 pages)

The Effects of Global Warming Essay

- The Effects of Global Warming Some of the most drastic effects of global warming contain: rising global temperatures which are expected to raise sea level and change precipitation and other local climate conditions. Changing regional climate could alter forests, crop yields, and water supplies. It also could possibly affect human health, animals, and many types of ecosystems. Deserts may expand into existing rangelands, and features of some of our National Parks may be permanently altered....   [tags: Environmental Global Climate Change]

Better Essays
675 words (1.9 pages)

Essay on Global Warming is a Disgrace

- Research shows that global warming has affected our environment for the worst. Global warming occurs when the temperature rises in the atmosphere. Researchers show the many causes and effects this issue brings to our environment. They take place due to natural and human occurrences. Has the environment been horribly affected by global warming. Studies show this question to be true, while providing statistics and evidence. More people should be aware of global warming and all the unconstructiveness that it brings to our world....   [tags: Climate Change, Argumentative Essay]

Better Essays
1429 words (4.1 pages)

The Great Debate on Global Warming Essay

- The cause of global warming has been a debate between scientists and experts for numerous years. In fact, Svante August Arrhenius, a Swedish chemist, first predicted global warming would occur in 1896 (Harris 16). Researchers who agree it is naturally caused insist the greenhouse effect has many natural causes. Others agree that the cause of the Earth’s increase in temperature is just part of a continuous cycle. These researchers argue that solar activity plays a huge role in the issue of global warming....   [tags: Environmental Issues, Climate Change]

Better Essays
1496 words (4.3 pages)

Solutions to Global Warming Essay

- You hear about it from television news broadcasts. You read about it in newspapers and magazines. You talk about it with friends and co-workers. There have even been movies made about it. The “it” is global warming. “Global warming refers to the global-average temperature increase that has been observed over the last one hundred years or more” (Spencer). Some experts argue that global warming is a result of human activities, while others believe the warming and cooling of the Earth’s atmosphere is a natural cycle....   [tags: Climate Change, Synthesis Essays]

Better Essays
1511 words (4.3 pages)

Effects of Global Warming Essay

- Catastrophic weather changes, the disappearance of islands, melting of Arctic ice, and a new ice age are all in store because of the carelessness of mankind’s tremendous amount of greenhouse gas emissions.“Human-generated greenhouse gas emissions have reversed a 2000-year cooling trend of the arctic” says environmental expert, James E. Hansen (Eilperin). There are those who believe that “the Earth’s peculiar wobble has set it on the Milankovich cycle which has warmed the planet due to its upheavals in our weather every 22,000, 41,000, and 100,000 years” (Bloom)....   [tags: climate change, greenhouse effect, environment]

Better Essays
1380 words (3.9 pages)

Essay on A Historical Perspective of Global Warming

- A Historical Perspective of Global Warming Global warming is a problem that has just recently come to the forefront of world affairs. Within the last fifteen to twenty years, we have known that this problem was not only possible, but likely; but nothing has really gotten done. The origin of global warming is often disputed, and is being debated all over the world today. Whatever the cause may be, historians believe this is a problem at least 100 years in the making. Since the Industrial Revolution, we have been on a fast track to pollute Earth to a way-of-life-altering extent....   [tags: History Environment Ecology Essays Papers]

Better Essays
2493 words (7.1 pages)

Global Warming Essay

- Global Warming Abstract The world's scientific experts agree that industrial and land use activities are having an adverse impact on our climate. Burning of fossil fuels such as coal, oil, and gasoline creates global warming pollution that acts as the glass in a greenhouse, reflecting heat back toward the Earth and warming our climate. If we do not take steps now to reduce our emissions of global warming pollution, we will suffer serious environmental, public health, and economic repercussions....   [tags: Greenhouse Effect, Climate Change]

Free Essays
5580 words (15.9 pages)

Global Warming Essay

- Global Warming One of the hottest topics being discussed now a days is the effects of global warming on the environment and the efforts being made in order to combat the potential effects. Simply put, global warming refers to the environmental effects caused by the constant emission of carbon dioxide from carbon based fuels. These effects are supposedly widespread; the temperature of the earth will rise, the land becomes less conducive to, vegetation, and various ecosystems become extinct. There is no common consensus on how to control the problem and through out the paper it discusses the issues of global warming....   [tags: Environmental Global Climate Change]

Better Essays
1102 words (3.1 pages)