Obedience to Authority Essays

Obedience to Authority Essays

Length: 1321 words (3.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Most people would like to think that they would never do anything to intentionally hurt another human being. However history has shown that human nature does not always prevail with the best outcomes. The following experiments and real life events all reflect that human beings succumb to obedience even when common sense tells them that what they are doing is wrong. Zimbardo’s Stanford Prison experiment, Milgram’s electric shock study, and the scandal surrounding Abu Ghraib are reflections on the outcome of obeying a command regardless of the results and why someone would do so.
An experiment by Zimbardo provided insight on how a regular person changes roles when placed within a specific social setting. The Stanford Prison Experiment was conducted by Zimbardo strictly on a volunteer basis “to study the process by which prisoners and guards ”learn” to become compliant and authoritarian (732).” The study was intended to be done over a two week period however the volunteers became so caught up in being a prisoner or a guard that it was actually cut short. Both prisoners and guards jumped immediately into the roles given. The guards set out to prove their superiority and the prisoners after a brief attempt to overthrow the guards fell into obedience. Guard A originally states that he is a “pacifist and nonaggressive”, but by day three he portrays just the characteristics he claims to have none of (Zimbardo 741). The guards in the experiment were told to keep the prisoners in-line, they did so to their own accord. The prisoners in the experiment also in the end gave in to the rules of the authoritarian figures. Both the guards and the prisoners did what they felt they needed to do to survive throughout the experiment. So even though t...


... middle of paper ...


...ing position gives the orders? Where will we stop and make the decision that those in charge have gone too far? What would you do?




Works Cited

Barone, Paul T. “The Need for Positive Meaning in Military Operations: Reflections on Abu Ghraib.” Military Psychology, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc. 2005, 17(4), 315-324.
Jones, Anthony R. “AR 15-6 Investigation of the Abu Ghraib Prison and 205th Military Intelligence Brigade.” United States Dept. of the Army. 2004. https://www-hsdl-org.jvlapps.nsuok.edu/?view&did=451656.
Milgram, Stanley. “The Perils of Obedience.” Writing And Reading Across The Curriculum. 11th Ed. Laurence Behrens and Leonard J. Rosen. Longman, 2011. 692-704. Print.
Zimbardo, Philip G. “The Stanford Prison Experiment.” Writing And Reading Across The Curriculum. 11th Ed. Laurence Behrens and Leonard J. Rosen. Longman, 2011. 732-743. Print.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Stanley Milgrim's Obedience to Authority Experiment

- The experiment performed by Stanley Milgrim at Yale University was both fascinating and thought provoking. Milgrim’s famous experiment explored “Obedience to authority.” In his experiment Milgrim explained to his students what was going to happen. He told his students that they would be the “teacher” who was going to administer a volunteered “student “a word-pairing test. Milgrim told them for every incorrect answer the “student” gave they would give a shock to the “student”. Each shock would increase in voltage after every incorrect answer....   [tags: Stanley Milgrim, Obedience to Authority, Experimen]

Strong Essays
765 words (2.2 pages)

Essay on Obedience to Authority

- Authority cannot exist without obedience. Society is built on this small, but important concept. Without authority and its required obedience, there would only be anarchy and chaos. But how much is too much, or too little. There is a fine line between following blindly and irrational refusal to obey those in a meaningful position of authority. Obedience to authority is a real and powerful force that should be understood and respected in order to handle each situation in the best possible manner....   [tags: Authority]

Strong Essays
1815 words (5.2 pages)

Obedience to Authority Essay

- The presence of an authoritative figure is present in nearly even human being’s life; along with this, is the expectation of obedience to that authority. Through this obedience, many great things have been accomplished, as well as many instances of cruel and immoral acts. Defiance of the established authority, though, has also lead to great things, such as the creation and founding of the United States of America. In his writing, Obedience to Authority, Stanley Milgram examines the obedience to authority without questioning or taking responsibility and the problems that lie in it....   [tags: Philosophy]

Strong Essays
837 words (2.4 pages)

Obedience to Authority Essays

- During the Vietnam War, a unit of American Army soldiers invaded My Lai a South Vietnamese hamlet resources contended was the enemy Viet Cong stronghold. That day in May 1968 an estimated 347 unarmed civilians “including women and children” died as a result (Cantrell, 2007). My Lai became one of the most controversial situations of the long Viet Nam War. When the truth came out due to letters to the government describing the horror, two questions resulted. Understanding why some of the young American soldiers that day killed so many innocent civilians and why did so few in the unit try to save the lives of as many as they could require moral clarity....   [tags: Psychology]

Strong Essays
944 words (2.7 pages)

Essay on The Obedience And Authority : Milgram Experiment

- The Obedience to Authority: Milgram Experiment Starting in 1961, Stanley Milgram, a professor of psychology at Yale University began conducting one of the most “infamous” psychology experiments in history. The tests are “infamous” because of not only the results they revealed, but also because the manner in which the tests were performed is considered unethical by today’s standards of testing. The experiment, which was mentioned in the New Haven Register newspaper as a “scientific study of memory and learning,” was actually an effort to investigate obedience to authority....   [tags: Stanford prison experiment, Psychology]

Strong Essays
707 words (2 pages)

Bystander Effect And Obedience On Authority Essay

- Bystander effect and obedience to authority are theories that can be compared and contrasted. Bystander effect is, for example, when someone is publicly in need and even though there are many people passing by or in the area, no one stops to help because they’ve seen no one else stop to help. In a video called The Bystander Effect they did an experiment to test the theory by having an actor lay by the steps of a busy area in Liverpool and moan “Help me”. The actor, Peter, was passed by many people who glanced his way, but didn’t stop to help even after 20 minutes of him yelling for help....   [tags: Milgram experiment, Stanford prison experiment]

Strong Essays
701 words (2 pages)

Relationship Between Obedience And Authority Essay

- Frequently in health care you hear of stories where nurses follow a questionable directive from a physician. At the hospital recently, a scenario like this occurred in the emergency room. After performing an exam, the doctor felt the patient was stable enough to go home, although the nurse disagreed and felt the patient needed additional monitoring. The nurse followed the doctor’s order and sent the patient home. It was not until later that the nurse spoke up to a supervisor to discuss her uneasiness over the care of the patient....   [tags: Health care, Medicine, Health care provider]

Strong Essays
713 words (2 pages)

Obedience to Authority Essays

- Most people would like to think that they would never do anything to intentionally hurt another human being. However history has shown that human nature does not always prevail with the best outcomes. The following experiments and real life events all reflect that human beings succumb to obedience even when common sense tells them that what they are doing is wrong. Zimbardo’s Stanford Prison experiment, Milgram’s electric shock study, and the scandal surrounding Abu Ghraib are reflections on the outcome of obeying a command regardless of the results and why someone would do so....   [tags: Psychology ]

Strong Essays
1321 words (3.8 pages)

Essay about Obedience to Authority

- Obedience to Authority Today our society raises us to believe that obedience is good and disobedience is bad. We are taught that we should all do what we’re told and that the people that are disobedient are almost always bad people. Society tells us this, but it is not true. Most people will even be obedient to the point of causing harm to others, because to be disobedient requires the courage to be alone against authority. In Stanley Milgram’s "Perils of Obedience" experiment, his studies showed that sixty percent of ordinary people would agree to obey an authority figure even to the point of severely hurting another human being....   [tags: Papers Stanley Milgram]

Strong Essays
576 words (1.6 pages)

Essay about Negative Consequences of Obedience to Authority

- Negative Consequences of Obedience to Authority Obedience is one of the most basic tenants of social life. It is a requirement of any form of communal living (Milgram, 1963). Society itself is predicted upon existence. All political purpose is linked to individual action through way of obedience. Theory and observations of social interaction has led researchers to believe that obedience is, for many people, a deeply ingrained trait (Milgram 1963). While having the potential for educative purpose and promoting acts of charity, it can also cause the most ethical and moralistic to abandon their core values and seemingly close their eyes while following an unjustified authority....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
869 words (2.5 pages)