Obedience Kills in Hamlet, The Lottery, and A&P Essay examples

Obedience Kills in Hamlet, The Lottery, and A&P Essay examples

Length: 1249 words (3.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

People are raised to obey. They are taught to follow orders; they are punished if they don’t. They are shown the rewarding benefits, such as success, a well-paying job and happiness that come along with being loyal, almost sheeplike followers of the law-like structure that their parents, teachers and other superiors set for them. But people aren’t usually shown the consequences that can arise when obedience is taken too far. I mean, look at the character Ophelia in Shakespeare’s “Hamlet.” She tried to be as obedient as possible and that just drove her insane. But like long-bodied dogs trying to catch their short tails, people who know nothing other than the obedient ways of which they were raised by are often driven into the same state of madness that Ophelia entered. And like those poor dogs, overly obedient people usually aren’t capable of understanding why they are in such a state, so they can never leave it, or even realize that they are in it.
Most people view obedience as a positive thing. Some say that being obedient can instill the proper values into a person. “It builds character,” others might say, “It helps a person grow, you know, in the ‘right’ sort of way.” Now, surely, one must wonder if that’s necessarily true.
It’s said that obedience can be both a sin and a virtue, but it would make sense to think that obedience can only be a sin when it’s inspired and carried on by sinful people. Likewise, obedience should bring forth virtues, only when there are virtuous people to follow. But can the two become intertwined? Can obedience result in sin if the intentions are holy? Can sinful obedience sometimes have good outcomes?

The answer really depends on what the circumstances are, and what peopl...

... middle of paper ...

...-for tidal wave / Of justice can rise up / And hope and history rhyme” (10-12), just as being obedient can sometimes result in rewarding outcomes, and hope and history can indeed rhyme— hopefully, however, one’s hope in obedience won’t rhyme with someone like George Gearson’s history, but it might.

Works Cited
Heaney, Seamus. “ A Chorus.” Handout. 7-12.
Howells, William D. “Editha.” Connections: Literature for Composition. Ed. Carrie Brandon. Boston, MA:
Patricia Coryell, 2008. 217-218. Print
Jackson, Shirley. “The Lottery.” Connections: Literature for Composition. Ed. Carrie Brandon. Boston,
MA: Patricia Coryell, 2008. 225-226. Print.
Updike, John. “A&P.” Connections: Literature for Composition. Ed. Carrie Brandon. Boston, MA: Patricia
Coryell, 2008. 249. Print

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Blind Obedience in Shirley Jackson's The Lottery Essay

- The author of “The Lottery” wrote this story “to shock the story’s readers with a graphic demonstration of the pointless violence and general inhumanity in their own lives” (Jackson 211). This story reflects human behavior in society to show how although rules, laws or traditions do not make sense, people follow them. Throughout the story the three main symbols of how people blindly follow senseless traditions were the lottery itself, the color black, and the hesitation that people had towards the prize....   [tags: Shirley Jackson Lottery 2014]

Better Essays
1070 words (3.1 pages)

Essay about Obedience And Violence And The Lottery

- Obedience And Violence To “The Lottery” Through my research and findings of obedience to authority this ancient dilemma is somewhat confusing but needs understanding. Problem with obedience to authority has raised a question to why people obey or disobey and if there are any right time to obey or not to obey. Through observation of many standpoints on obedience and disobedience to authority, and determined through detailed examination conducted by Milgram “The Perils Of Obedience,” Doris Lessing “Group Minds” and Shirley Jackson “The Lottery”....   [tags: Milgram experiment, Stanford prison experiment]

Better Essays
1485 words (4.2 pages)

Essay on Shirley Jackson's The Lottery - Blind Obedience Exposed

- Blind Obedience Exposed in The Lottery   The annual ritualistic stoning of a villager in Shirley Jackson's "The Lottery" parallels tradition in American culture.  This paper will inform the reader of the effect tradition has on characters in the short story "The Lottery" and how traditions still strongly influence people's lives in america.               Christian weddings hold many traditions and superstitions that seemingly defy logic.  Although most couples no longer have arranged marriages or dowries, fathers still give their daughters away during the services.  The bride and groom do not see each other before the ceremony, fearing that bad luck might come their way.  A friend scolde...   [tags: Shirley Jackson Lottery Essays]

Better Essays
938 words (2.7 pages)

Essays on Jackson's Lottery: Dangers of Blind Obedience Exposed

- Dangers of Blind Obedience Exposed in The Lottery        Most of us obey every day without a thought. People follow company dress code, state and federal laws and the assumed rules of courtesy. Those who do disobey are usually frowned upon or possibly even reprimanded. But has it even occurred to you that in some cases, disobedience may be the better course to choose. In her speech "Group Minds," Doris Lessing discusses these dangers of obedience, which are demonstrated in Shirley Jackson's short story "The Lottery."   In "The Lottery," the villagers portray Lessing's observation that "it is the hardest thing in the world to maintain an individual dissident opinion, as a member of a...   [tags: Shirley Jackson Lottery Essays]

Better Essays
679 words (1.9 pages)

Blind Obedience in Shirley Jackson's The Lottery Essay

- When Shirley Jackson’s “The Lottery” was first published in The New Yorker in 1948, it struck a nerve with readers. “The story was incendiary; readers acted as if a bomb had blown up in their faces . . . Shirley struck a nerve in mid-twentieth-century America . . . She had told people a painful truth about themselves” (Oppenheimer 129). Interestingly, the story strikes that same nerve with readers today. When my English class recently viewed the video, those students who had not previously read the story reacted quite strongly to the ending....   [tags: Shirley Jackson Lottery 2014]

Better Essays
2500 words (7.1 pages)

Unchecked Obedience Essay

- Machiavelli declares that whatever you do, be it just or evil, if you know your actions will bring favorable results then you are not responsible for the manner, corrupt or blameless, in which they were obtained. This reasoning defines a timeless question: do the ends really justify the means. R. J. Herrnstein, author of “Measuring Evil”, believes they do, “A small, temporary loss of a few peoples comfort and privacy seems a bearable price for a large reduction in ignorance” (88). But is it not harsh to allow few to be terrorized for the benefit of many....   [tags: Obedience]

Better Essays
1475 words (4.2 pages)

The Lottery, by Shirley Jackson Essay

- The Lottery is a short story about a town who still participates in the annual "Lottery" drawing. Everyone is laughing and conversing like any other day. Children and adults alike are collecting stones. At last the time comes for the drawing and Mr. Summers pulls out the black box with the papers in it. The head of the household, the men, all must pull out a piece of paper. The townsfolk talk about how the lottery is done for in nearby towns but others such as Old Man Warner scoff at the idea and say that is not possible young people don't know what they are talking about, the lottery will continue in this town....   [tags: The Lottery Essays]

Better Essays
486 words (1.4 pages)

Essay on Obedience and Social Pressure

- Most of our lives are spent pleasing people, whether they are our parents when we are young, our teachers when we go to school, our friends and peers in everyday life, or our bosses when we go to work. We grow up at home being told what to do by our parents and that we have to listen to adults. In school we are told to listen to our teachers and do what they tell us. When we have a job we’re told to listen to our boss and do our jobs the way they tell us. We do what our friends ask us to because it makes them happy and makes us feel as though we belong....   [tags: Obedience Essays]

Better Essays
1689 words (4.8 pages)

Obedience Essay

- Obedience is the process by which individuals comply with the instructions given by an authority figure not to be confused with conformity. There is one similarity between obedience and conformity which is that both involved a renunciation Of personal responsibility. There is three differences between Obedience and Conformity. The first one is that in Obedience an order or an instruction is given whereas no instructions or order is given in conformity. The second one is that in obedience there will be a difference of status e.g : a doctor and a nurse whereas in conformity the group followed will have the same equal status....   [tags: Obedience]

Better Essays
742 words (2.1 pages)

The Lottery by Shirley Jackson Essay

- Shirley Jackson, born on December 14, 1916, devotes much of her life to the writing of short stories and novels. Some of these include The Sundial, The Haunting of Hill House, and We Have Always Lived in the Castle. Jackson's stories, inspiring and influential to most, are also controversial to some. Her most controversial story, published in 1948 in The New Yorker, is "The Lottery." The purpose for the writing of the story varies depending upon the reader, but some might say that it "expresses Shirley Jackson's abysmal opinion of her fellow creatures" (Coulthard 228)....   [tags: The Lottery Essays]

Better Essays
1715 words (4.9 pages)