Nozick 's The Principle Of Self Ownership Essay

Nozick 's The Principle Of Self Ownership Essay

Length: 1929 words (5.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In this paper, I will examine Nozick’s ‘whatever arises from a just situation by just steps is itself just’ formula. By this formula, Nozick protects individuals’ absolute property rights. To examine its validity, first, I will show that Nozick’s entitlement theory relies on Kantian principle, which demands treating everyone as persons having individual rights with dignity. However, it will be clear that Kantian theory does not necessarily yield the concept of absolute property rights. Second, I will explain the principle of self-ownership, which will clarify that persons have rights over their bodies and powers. I will find the principle of self-ownership is compatible with Kantian principle. Third, I will examine Nozick’s proviso, which guides legitimate initial acquisition. However, finally, I will show that the appropriation that passes Nozick’s proviso violates the idea of respecting people as persons with dignity. In other words, Nozick’s proviso is inconsistent with Kantian principle. Therefore, Nozick’s formula fails.
Nozick (1974) formulates the entitlement theory, which strongly defends individuals’ absolute property rights as long as the process of their holdings is legitimate, where legitimate means there is no historical injustice such as using force or carrying a fraud in acquisition. According to the theory, without violating individuals’ rights, no individual or group, including any government, can enforce redistributive taxation for the purpose of making others better off. Therefore, Nozick only admits minimal states, where almost all kinds of coercive taxation are unjust and illegitimate because they violate individuals’ rights ‘not to be forced to do certain things’, even if the purpose is providing public educ...


... middle of paper ...


...o improve their situation.
However, this appropriation is objectionable from two reasons (Otsuka 1998: 78). First, it condemns others to ‘meager hand-to-mouth existence. Indeed, Bob no longer pursues his conceptions of a good life, even though his goals should be equally respected with dignity. Second, the first-come, first-served doctrine of appropriation that Nozick accepts is unfair. As a fair procedure of appropriation, the system which equalises chances for appropriation is better than a first-come, first-served doctrine of appropriation. However, Nozick’s proviso permits a first-come, first-served doctrine of appropriation even when chances are unequal. Due to this counterexample, Nozick’s proviso is inconsistent with the idea of treating people as persons with dignity. Therefore, Nozick’s formula is inconsistent with Kantian principle. Nozick’s formula fails.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Nozick 's Right Of Self Ownership Essay

- Nozick contends that people own themselves and their talents and therefore they own what they produce with these talents. By mixing their labour with the material world, they tend to increase the value of it. Consequently, people’s self-ownership, and by extension their labour, allows them to stake a claim to parts of the external material world. (Kymlicka, 2002, 109; Nozick, 1974, 149–182) Hence, one’s rights of ownership over one’s means of production can be grounded wholly in one’s libertarian right of self-ownership....   [tags: Property, John Locke, Capitalism, Property law]

Strong Essays
1708 words (4.9 pages)

Robert Nozick's Libertarian Views of Justice in "Anarchy, Stat, And Utopia"

- Robert Nozick uses the example of Wilt Chamberlain to develop his theories on entitlement and distribution by establishing his libertarian view of justice in chapter 7 of his book "Anarchy, Stat, And Utopia" . Wilt Chamberlain, the basketball star, charges fans twenty-five cents to watch him play. Nozick creates a world in which we are to assume that the actions leading to this point, for all people, are just. Chamberlain simply offers his services to those who wish to attend the event. Assuming that he continues his show for some time, and people continue to pay the twenty-five cent fee, Chamberlain could generate a great deal of revenue....   [tags: philosophical, ownership, inequality]

Strong Essays
895 words (2.6 pages)

Essay about The Distribution Of Wealth By Robert Nozick

- The distribution of wealth is a basically the view on wealth, and the various members or groups in a society. Of course, it differs from the distribution of income in that it looks at the distribution of ownership of the assets in a society, rather that the current income of members of that society. Wealth is the amount of liabilities being taken away from the amount of assets. The world always calculates wealth base off ones’ income, but the do relates with a simple factor of expenses. Distribution of wealth can also be a luck factor, it can be based off family income and family inheritance things of that nature....   [tags: Political philosophy, Liberalism, John Rawls]

Strong Essays
1003 words (2.9 pages)

Reciprocity : The Principle Of Justice Essay

- Leading to his discussion based on reciprocity, which Rawls argues is contained in his difference principle of justice. The concept of reciprocity can be closely related to rationality, claiming that gains are not made at the expense of others, which orders the maximization of liberty and minimizes inequalities. The view of fairness of ones self and others as equal moral beings. He explained that someone was incapable of gaining from the labor of another person, without doing his or her own fair share of labor....   [tags: Political philosophy, John Rawls]

Strong Essays
1225 words (3.5 pages)

Essay about Ownership of Self and Property

- Ownership has long affected our sense of self and worth. It has changed with the times but still affects us the same way as before. The famous philosopher, Plato, thought that “owning objects is detrimental to a person's character”. By examining the different types of ownership and evidence from historical to contemporary society, ownership correlates with one’s sense of self by either improving or diminishing it. . It is impossible for any living organism to survive without owning anything. From insects to mankind, owning some sort of property, whether tangible or intangible, is our way of surviving....   [tags: financial system, economy, self-ownership]

Strong Essays
1233 words (3.5 pages)

Rawls Vs. Nozick : John Rawls And Nozick Essay

- Rawls vs Nozick John Rawls and Robert Nozick both provide compelling and thought provoking theories regarding the values of liberty and equality. Rawls focuses on both liberty and equality while Nozick theorizes exclusively on liberty. The ideas of Rawls and Nozick have multiple strengths as well as weaknesses which allow for debate and comparison between the two theories. John Rawls was more in agreement with the works of Locke and Rousseau; however, Rawls disagreed with the notion that the State of Nature was a historical situation as opposed to something hypothetical; Rawls instead believed an original position of equality which I agree with (917)....   [tags: Political philosophy, John Rawls, Liberalism]

Strong Essays
792 words (2.3 pages)

Essay on The Principle of Beneficence in Biomedicine

- INTRODUCTION Munyaradzi (2012) critically explores the in-depth weaknesses of beneficence and certain points where it becomes a principle under scrutiny. He begins by blaming ethicists for not exploring the depth of the principle of beneficence in several fields especially in biomedicine. Further, it provides the layman with an introduction to the principle and to how it is used by various health practitioners throughout the world, along with discussing the history of the idea. He then sheds light numerous cases where it becomes highly problematic for physicians to decide upon the issue....   [tags: critical relfections, the utilitarian principle]

Strong Essays
898 words (2.6 pages)

Essay about Anarchy, State and Utopia by Nozick

- In his book “Anarchy, State and Utopia”, Nozick asserts that all humans have certain fundamental rights, such as life, health, liberty, and property. And these rights cannot be taken away from the citizens. The state, he claims, as no moral authority over someone's property which has been justly acquired. He claims that if a person has justly claimed his property than the state does not have any jurisdiction to take that away from him. The problem with all distributive principles of justice, he believes, is that they violate some of the basic human rights and are therefore inherently unjust....   [tags: rawls, liberty and power]

Strong Essays
1235 words (3.5 pages)

Ownership And Self And Identity Essay

- Ownership and self (identity) are commonly joined together under one thought: ownership can very well define a person’s identity. I believe that is to be true. It is possible to own something physically whether that is a phone, a computer, a car etc., or something that simply exists within our minds such as a thought (idea), a concept or whatever it may be. However, “To own” – a verb – doesn’t necessarily mean to own or have something, it also means to know something or that it is a part of you or “admit or acknowledge that something is the case or that one feels a certain way”- Google....   [tags: Mind, Thought, Human, Identity]

Strong Essays
1056 words (3 pages)

Essay on Robert Nozick’s Experience Machine

- In his 1975 book Anarchy, State, and Utopia, Robert Nozick introduced a now famous thought experiment he entitled "The Experience Machine." Nozick believes that this intuition pump successfully demonstrates that hedonism is false and that human beings do value things other than happiness and pleasure as goods in themselves, namely "authenticity" and the like. In this paper, I will offer a thorough exegesis of the Experience Machine thought experiment and attempt to show that it fails to establish that something like authenticity could serve as a potential normative foundation....   [tags: Robert Nozick Anarchy State and Utopia]

Strong Essays
3406 words (9.7 pages)