The Norfolk Four : False Confessions A Miscarriage Of Justice Essay

The Norfolk Four : False Confessions A Miscarriage Of Justice Essay

Length: 879 words (2.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The Norfolk Four: False Confessions a Miscarriage of Justice
The Frontline documentary, The Confessions (2010), tells the story of the Norfolk Four; four innocent men who were ultimately convicted of the rape and murder of Michelle Bosko. As horrendous and appalling as Michelle Bosko’s murder was, that was not the most shocking point of the film. More astonishing is the fact that four innocent men were convicted of the crime with the help false confessions obtained by the police investigating the case. This despite the fact that police and prosecutors had physical evidence and testimony from the real murderer that pointed to the innocence of the Norfolk four.
Although, the documentary primarily focuses on the coercive police interrogation methods used by Detective Maureen Evans and Detective Robert Glenn Ford, some responsibility has to also be placed on the court system. The tactics used by the police while investigating the murder and rape of Michelle Bosko were coercive; the men claim they were interrogated for hours, threatened with the death penalty, and lied to in order to obtain the confessions. One of the men, Derek Tice, claims that while being questioned by the police he asked to speak to a lawyer only to have his request ignored a clear violation of his rights. Original suspect, Danial Williams, describes being questioned for eight hours by Detective Evans only to have Detective Ford brought in when Evans attempts to obtain a confession fail. With the use of such interrogating tactics each of the men confesses to the crime. When inaccuracies in their statements were found, such was the case in Danial Williams’ original confession when he claims that he beat Ms. Bosko with a shoe, the police interrogate him again nudg...

... middle of paper ...

...ction.” (Leo, 2009) Leo also concludes by offering several suggestions in order to help minimize false confessions. Some of the suggestions outlined included: mandatory electronic recording of police interrogations, time limits on interrogations, prohibiting certain interrogation methods, pretrial reliability hearings, and “…providing safeguards for vulnerable populations such as the developmentally disabled and juveniles.” (Leo, 2009) In all likelihood if these precautions had been taken while interrogating the Norfolk Four would not have been convicted. Had a time limit and mandatory recordings for the entirety of the interrogations it’s likely that they would have never elicited false confessions from these men. As such more such cases come to light perhaps suggestions such as this will be implemented and stopping future miscarriages of justice such as this one.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on False Confessions and the Norfolk Four Case

- ``In criminal law, confession evidence is a prosecutor’s most potent weapon’’ (Kassin, 1997)—“the ‘queen of proofs’ in the law” (Brooks, 2000). Regardless of when in the legal process they occur, statements of confession often provide the most incriminating form of evidence and have been shown to significantly increase the rate of conviction. Legal scholars even argue that a defendant’s confession may be the sole piece of evidence considered during a trial and often guides jurors’ perception of the case (McCormick, 1972)....   [tags: confession evidence]

Better Essays
2738 words (7.8 pages)

Essay on The Death Of A Miscarriage

- A miscarriage is defined as, “spontaneous abortion terminates pregnancy before the fetus is viable” (White & Bouvier, p.18, 2005). In the United States, 10 to 20 percent of pregnancies end in miscarriage (White & Bouvier, 2005). The risk increases to 75 percent for woman over 45 years (Ockhuijsen, van den Hoogen, Boivin, Macklon, & de Boer, 2014). In fact, spontaneous abortions are a fairly common occurrence among women in their child bearing years (Shreffler, Greil, & McQuillan, 2011). A study by Lang and Nuevo-Chiquero (2012), shows white women experience miscarriages at higher rates than Black and Hispanic women....   [tags: Pregnancy, Abortion, Miscarriage]

Better Essays
759 words (2.2 pages)

Essay on Norfolk Southern : Health And Wellness

- Norfolk Southern: Health and Wellness 1. Background Norfolk Southern Railway Corporation was formed in 1982. This company has been around under many other names throughout the history of the United States, with the constant mergers and acquisitions in railroading history. In northern Indiana the railroads were originally New York Central and Pennsylvania Railroad, these two lines merged to become Penn Central. Penn Central went bankrupt and the United States government merged them with other railroads to form Conrail....   [tags: Health, Nutrition, Norfolk Southern Railway]

Better Essays
1377 words (3.9 pages)

Impact of Miscarriage on Women, Their Partners, and Marital Relationships

- Introduction For centuries there has been a medical epidemic that has plagued expecting mothers around the world. Considered for so long to be simply a woman’s issue, men remained unconcerned and distant—if they even knew as often they were never told. Most everyone has heard whispers of it, but until recent years the medical and psychological communities did not recognize the lasting implications of this occurrence. Now as couples break historical norms and become more egalitarian-based, this issue is one that not only affects women, but their partners also....   [tags: Pregnancy, Women, Miscarriage, Historical Norms]

Better Essays
1891 words (5.4 pages)

Pregnancy Complications: Miscarriage Essay

- Pregnancy Complications Pregnancy can be an exciting and sometimes frightening experience for many women. It was a snowy Sunday afternoon, and I was not feeling very well. I remember all week long, every morning I felt nauseated. I was craving odd foods, and foods I normally would not eat together. I was on the phone with my best friend explaining to her how I was feeling. She said “It sounds like you are pregnant.” That thought never even crossed my mind until that moment. Sure enough she was right, I was pregnant for the first time....   [tags: miscarriage, down syndrome, breech]

Better Essays
619 words (1.8 pages)

Contributions to teh Miscarriages of Justice Essay

- What causes contributed to the miscarriages of justice. The main causes that contributed to the miscarriages of justice were perjury or false accusations from jailhouse informants, and prosecutorial misconduct. Jailhouse Informants/False Accusation: Jailhouse informants are inmates who provide incriminating information or testimony during criminal proceeding against another inmate. The prevalence of jailhouse informants is quite high because competition among informants is tough, information gathering techniques are quickly being modified, many inmates want to manipulate cell sharing or transfers in exchange for their testimony, many inmates have made careers out becoming informants, loss o...   [tags: False Accusations, Prosecutorial Misconduct]

Better Essays
1425 words (4.1 pages)

Essay about False Confessions By Richard Leo

- False confessions are receiving more public attention now that people are speaking out about having to serve jail time for a crime they did not commit. 2015 was a year to remember for false confessions starting in January when a man was released after serving 21 years in prison. The protocols that interrogators are trained to follow are dangerous because they allow investigators to have complete influence on innocent people to make false confessions. Most people believe that all interrogators are trained to use mental and physical abusive tactics because it appears on the media and news so often, therefore making it believable to blame them for false confessions....   [tags: Interrogation, False confession, Police]

Better Essays
1761 words (5 pages)

Essay about The Experience of a Miscarriage: Eowyn Ivey's The Snow Child

- “She had withered and shrunk in on herself, and it began when they lost that baby,” (Ivey 20). “She should have allowed herself that grief,” (Ivey 4). The novel The Snow Child explores the reactions, guilt and grief corresponding to the experience of a miscarriage. The relationship between miscarriage and grief has been given sparse attention over the years. People vary in the way they respond to a miscarriage; anywhere from age to gender or even a child that was conceived after the previous miscarriage....   [tags: grief, miscarriage, women, men]

Better Essays
1209 words (3.5 pages)

Essay False Confessions And Coerced Confessions

- There are two types of false confessions, voluntary false confessions and involuntary false confessions. In a voluntary false confession, a person claims to be responsible for a crime they know they did not commit without any coercion or interference. With this type of false confession, mental health comes into play. These people feel a need for attention or punishment that can only be explained psychologically. In some cases of voluntary false confessions, those who wish to protect the true guilty party confess in the hopes of saving that person at the risk of themselves....   [tags: Interrogation, False confession]

Better Essays
1192 words (3.4 pages)

Essay on The False Memory Task

- ... A new list begins when participants believe they have all of the correct words from the matrix. The cycle begins again. A list of twelve words are presented, a matrix appears after the twelfth word, and participants select words according to their memory of what was on the list. There are six lists in total, with no practice trials, however there are breaks in between to express the differences in each list. I chose this task because I was rather skeptical and unsure if the task would accomplish its goal in just fifteen minutes....   [tags: false information, ZAP experiments]

Better Essays
703 words (2 pages)