The Need for Judicial Diversity Essay

The Need for Judicial Diversity Essay

Length: 1865 words (5.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Term Papers

Open Document

Essay Preview

The given statement suggests that the emphasis on judicial diversity is unnecessary since there is no guarantee that a diverse judiciary would arrive at a different decision than that of a conservative judiciary. This essay attempts to argue that although there is no evidence that a diverse bench would radically change the outcome of a given case, the quality of justice will be substantially enhanced by the inclusion of a range of perspectives from which are currently not represented by the English judiciary.

John Griffith’s thesis asserted that the English judiciary comprises of judges who as a whole are of ‘a unifying attitude of mind, a political position, to protect and conserve certain values and institutions’. Before the Judicial Appointment Commission was established conservatism was sometimes facilitated by various policies put in place by the Lord Chancellor . ‘Conservatism’ here is used to denote conformity to traditional values as opposed to political ideals. Lord Hailsham, the Conservative Lord Chancellor until 1987 had implemented a policy to appoint only married candidates. Professor Leslie Moran notes that this was clearly a measure to avoid a ‘homosexual controversy’. Only in 1991 was there an official announcement declaring that homosexuality will not be a bar to judicial office.

Kate Malleson remarks that even the current recruitment pool which is dominated by middle aged successful barristers does seem to evoke John Griffith's theory of judicial conservatism. However, the apparently conservative composition of the judiciary does not necessarily mean that it gives preference to traditional views. In contrast to the US Supreme Court, there is little concern whether a UK judge’s social and political views a...


... middle of paper ...


...ion
• Rackley, E (2010). In Conversation with Lord Justice Etherton: Revisiting the Case for a More Diverse Judiciary. Public Law
• The Report of the Advisory Panel on Judicial Diversity 2010 (Ministry of Justice)
http://www.justice.gov.uk/publications/docs/advisory-panel-judicial-diversity-2010.pdf
• Professor Martin Partington’s blog ‘Spotlight on the Justice System’
http://martinpartington.com/2010/03/18/developing-judicial-diversity/
• HJ (Iran) and HT (Cameroon) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2010] UKSC 31
http://www.supremecourt.gov.uk/decided-cases/docs/UKSC_2009_0057_Judgment.pdf
• Secretary of State for the Home Department (Respondent) v. K (FC) (Appellant) Fornah (FC) (Appellant) v. Secretary of State for the Home Department (Respondent) [2006] UKHL 46
http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld200506/ldjudgmt/jd061018/sshd.pdf

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Lack of Diversity in the Judiciary Essay

- It is widely acknowledged that the judiciary within England and Wales is not representative of the wider society. The composition of the judiciary is regularly subject to criticism on its apparent homogenous identity’ being largely comprised of elderly, white male barristers educated at Oxford or Cambridge. This ethos has prevented diversity within the judiciary, particularly the upper echelons of the judiciary. Academics such as John Griffith have suggested that the narrow range of the judiciary threatens to undermine public confidence in the judicial system....   [tags: Society Representation, Reforms, Constitution]

Term Papers
1091 words (3.1 pages)

The Judicial Branch Of Government Essay

- As justices of the Supreme Court sit on the bench for as long as they deem themselves capable and passing rulings on issues that are not their responsibility, America is threatened by the reality of being ruled by an oligarchy. Supreme Court justices are given their appointments to the bench by the President of the United States and then must be approved by the Senate. Once appointed to the Supreme Court, justices tend to serve for the rest of their lives. Technically, this is not unconstitutional since according to Article III of the Constitution a justice “shall hold their offices during good behavior.” Justices were given life-tenure in order to make the federal courts and lower courts i...   [tags: Supreme Court of the United States, United States]

Term Papers
1164 words (3.3 pages)

Diversity Is Recognized And Highly Encouraged Essay

- We have come to a point in our evolution where diversity is recognized and highly encouraged. Segregation has nearly reached its demise and other forms of discrimination will always exist in some individuals however other open minded, peace seeking communities have eradicated it from their their dictionary. Although we as a species are incredibly diverse, whether it be by age, gender, ethnicity or social class, the flaws and the beauty that make us human is found in every single one of us. This repetition of behaviour throughout history is what is referred to as our intellectual heritage....   [tags: Epic of Gilgamesh, Enkidu, Humbaba, Cedar Forest]

Term Papers
2268 words (6.5 pages)

Diversity And Cultural Competence Within The Workplace Essay

- DIVERSITY AND CULTURAL COMPETENCE This Cultural Competency Section is designed to outline my practicum agency “BUILD”, policies on Sexual Harassment, Equal Opportunity, and Affirmative Action. In order to clearly report these policies the agency’s documents will be used, information from the supervisor will be used, and all other relevant data will be gathered to complete this tasks. Sexual Harassment BUILD’s policy regarding Sexual Harassment is covered in BUILD’s employee handbook under policy 703 (Sexual Harassment and Other Unlawful Harassment) has been effective since 01/1/2009....   [tags: Discrimination, Affirmative action]

Term Papers
1507 words (4.3 pages)

Essay Non-Dominant Voices on Difference and Diversity

- Non-Dominant Voices on Difference and Diversity Chapter one of Multiculturalism from the Margins: Non-Dominant Voices on Difference and Diversity is "Social Movements and the Politics of Difference" by Cheryl Zarlenga Kerchis and Iris Marion Young. This chapter examines the idea of assimilation versus acceptance of group differences. The chapter begins by explaining the historical acceptance of assimilation especially in the United States with its ideals of the American melting pot. However, as Kerchis and Young explained each social group evolved and eventually began to embrace the idea of a politics of difference....   [tags: Multiculturalism Cultural Culture Politics Essays]

Free Essays
999 words (2.9 pages)

We Do NOT Need Affirmative Action Essay example

-   Affirmative Action is steps that are taken to ensure that the opportunities are equal between minorities and others. There have been many heated debates over this issue, and maybe the worst is yet to come. Some might feel it is necessary because they feel opportunities are not equal for minorities. Many people believe that gaps need to be closed between minorities and others, but there is a difference in the method. I feel the current method is not constitutional, lawful, and not proven to be an adequate solution....   [tags: Affirmative Action Not Necessary 2014]

Term Papers
539 words (1.5 pages)

Essay on The Cost of Human Cloning: A Threat to Individuality and Diversity

- The Cost of Human Cloning: A Threat to Individuality and Diversity Have we as a society come too far too fast. This is a very applicable question recently asked by senator Roger Bennett, from Michigan, before the Senate on the topic of human cloning. It is speculated that we as a human race have the technology to make a clone of any given human (Jackson 2). If this is done, at what cost is it done. If cloning is allowed it will come at the cost of misguided effort, the creation of a process known as gene selection, and loss of individuality and diversity....   [tags: Cloning]

Term Papers
700 words (2 pages)

We Need Same-sex Marriage Now Essay

- We Need Same-sex Marriage Now Known to some people as a lifetime commitment of devotion, to others a promise to reside with a stranger, and even to some people as a union arranged by their parents, marriage is a widely varying ritual practiced all over the world. In the United States, marriage is a freedom of choice and an act of love, supported with benefits and privileges from the government. It has traditionally been the union of a woman and a man, made with the expectation of permanence and the aim of producing and raising offspring....   [tags: Gay and Lesbian Issues]

Term Papers
1355 words (3.9 pages)

Judicial Diversity And Lack Of Diversity Essay example

- Introduction Judicial diversity has been a continuous topic of discussion in both society and in the English legal system. Currently, the process of the merit system causes a lack of diversity in the English bench, which is highly due to the undiverse characters of the upper reaches of the legal profession. There have been numerous unsuccessful attempts to promote diversity within the judiciary. The Constitution Reform Act 2005 (CRA 2005) was then introduced to ensure selection is based on merit and to promote judicial diversity....   [tags: Judge, Law, Affirmative action, Court]

Term Papers
1057 words (3 pages)

We Need Diversity in the Workplace Essay

- Today's workplace is more diverse than it has ever been in history. While the workforce has made strides in the direction of equality, it is still far from attaining total equality in the workplace. A company must value diversity. The main objectives of valuing diversity include awareness, education, and positive recognition of the differences among people in the workforce. Organizations are increasingly emphasizing group work or teamwork as a source of competitive advantage in a diverse workforce....   [tags: Multiculturalism, Racial Diversity ]

Term Papers
1490 words (4.3 pages)