... middle of paper ...
...born in, but at the same time, it aspects some principles of each and rejects others. On the other hand, Civic nationalism tries to be inclusive and yet it is skeptical about universalism through the issue of citizenship. Not to mention France and Germany as representations of the classical division in nationalism, where France represents civic nationalism and Germany ethnic nationalism. Nevertheless, I think that society as a whole should not concentrate heavily on the claims of nationalism; civil and ethnic, eastern and western, political and cultural. However, we should rather seek to find ways in which these individual components can be accomplished and fulfilled with an open eye towards improving the conditions of a nation state. Because at the end of the day without the elements of civic and ethnic nationalism there would not be a nationalism presently.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Reading Jerry Muller’s "Us and them: The enduring power of ethnic nationalism" Foreign Affairs 2008, against Michael Ignatieff’s "A cosmopolitan among the true believers" Harpers March 1994. Made me think who is really right about nationalism, the wanting to belong how it affects the world as a whole. So before we can get to whose wrong whose right, or if there is a definitive distinction really, I have to give you an idea of what the articles are about. So you can understand my comparison. Jerry Muller’s "Us and them: The enduring power of ethnic nationalism" Foreign Affairs was an interesting article.... [tags: Ethnic group, Nation, Race, Ethnic nationalism]
1206 words (3.4 pages)
- When we speak of nationalism, we adhere to an umbrella that covers various elements such as; national identity, cultural and national consciousness not to mention individual’s loyalty to a nation state. Furthermore, to grasp the content of the term Nationalism systematically and how its different forms and routes; Civic and Ethnic nationalism came about, I will firstly review the definition of Nationalism discussed by the political theorist Benedict Anderson. In the reading, Imagined Communities, he defines the nation as: ‘’ It is an imagined political community- and imagined as both inherently limited and sovereign’’) (Anderson 2006 ).... [tags: Nationalism, Nation, Self-determination]
1266 words (3.6 pages)
- After Suharto ended his long dictatorial reign in 1998 there was a substantial increase in religious and ethnic conflict in Indonesia. Author Jacques Bertrand claims religious and ethnic conflict defined Indonesia’s national model. This resulted in three critical junctures during Suharto’s retirement of his sovereign rule. The three critical junctures defined Indonesia’s “terms of citizenship, and give meaning to the structure and procedures of an institution” (Bertrand, 20). When Suharto left as dictator, major political and social changes consumed Indonesia, which threatened the Indonesian realm.... [tags: Book Analysis, Indonesian Politics]
1452 words (4.1 pages)
- “The existing nationalism literature is a conceptual labyrinth characterized by questionable instruments, lack of empirical data, and poor explanatory power” Compare and contrast the nature and meaning of nationalism by focusing on the main theoretical approaches that define the literature on nationalism: Primordialist, Situationalist, Constructivist. The nature and meaning of the term ‘nationalism’ has many different facets and dimensions. At times, deconstructing the different theoretical literature can become confusing and complicated process.... [tags: Nationalism, Nation, Ethnic group, Race]
1995 words (5.7 pages)
- The definition of nationalism, according to Anderson, is an “imagined impersonal community, defined by common history and perceived by distinctiveness, that is believed to exercise the collective right to sovereign control over a given territory.” Over the last 200 years, the United States has grown larger and stronger with every change, and with that, the understanding of nationhood and nationalism in the US has changed within the constraints of this definition. In the beginning, nationhood was very different.... [tags: Ethnic group, Nation, Race, Nationalism]
1018 words (2.9 pages)
- Literature Review The main concept of this literature review is to analyse the conceptions of nationalism. By doing so, one can gain an insight on the different concepts that have helped or hindered with the creation, and development of nations. In order to do so, it is important to consider several factors. For example, the different nationalist theories, national identity, the role of ethnic societies, the concept of a historical territory, social factors, economic factors, as well as, political factors.... [tags: Nation, Nationalism, Ethnic group, Race]
2120 words (6.1 pages)
- Elie Kedourie’s discussion of nationalism, its causes and its relationship to modernization, and its overall evolution is grounded in historiographical evaluation of ideas emanating from a Kantian notion of human beings as having a sense of autonomous tendencies. Elie goes on to describe certain concepts such as nationalism, patriotism, the primordial basis for these concepts and nationalism as whole. Kedourie believes the overarching and unifying factor for nationalism to flourish is a set of ideas that cause homogenization among a group.... [tags: Nation, Nationalism, Ethnic group, Race]
1320 words (3.8 pages)
- The Primordialist approach depicts the nation as based upon a natural, organic community, which defines the identity of its members, who feel an innate and emotionally powerful attachment to it. (5) (Brown 2000) This means that to primordialists the meaning of nationalism correlates with an inherent or instinctual loyalty to the nation. This loyalty to the nation arises from strong kinship bonds which manifest into unified national identity drawn from an ethnic core. Through the primordialist framework there is a one-to-one link between ethnicity and national identity; giving identity the characteristic of being fixed.... [tags: Nationalism, Nation, Ethnic group, Race]
1622 words (4.6 pages)
- In order to understand the concept of national integration, one must first look at the definition of state and nation building. The creation of a single territorial unit’s infrastructure and its economy is the concept of state building, while nation building differs in that it relates to the creation of a community within the state. To expand on this broad definition of nation building, it can be described as the politic surrounding the national integration of two significant processes that occur within a state and are important in its creation.... [tags: Nation, Nationalism, Ethnic group, Race]
968 words (2.8 pages)
- Nationalism is most often characterized as an overbearing pride in ones country, or it could be a movement to protect ones homeland. To begin, nationalism prompted racism to transpire between different nations and ethnic groups. Furthermore, this domineering pride in ones country led to conflict including war to engage between nations. Lastly, Mr. Kozlov in the period rising up to this heightened time of nationalism, small countries were flourishing with new ideas and philosophies; during these nationalist times however, many of these old standards were destroyed.... [tags: Nationalism]
965 words (2.8 pages)