Essay about National Deconstruction: Violence, Identity and Justice in Bosnia

Essay about National Deconstruction: Violence, Identity and Justice in Bosnia

Length: 929 words (2.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

David Campbell’s book National Deconstruction: Violence, Identity and Justice in Bosnia is concerned with the conflict in Bosnia, and how constructions of identity affected the reporting and resolution of conflict.
The idea of National Deconstruction here not only refers to the deconstruction of Yugoslavia as a state, but primarily to deconstruction: the philosophical school of thought, originally described by Derrida. Campbell applies deconstruction to identity politics, whereby thinking in this way is to see identity as being ‘the effect of a contingent set of relations’ [20]. This school of thought places identity and difference, the sense of ‘other’ at the centre of its understanding, where ‘claims about secure identities, traditionally authorised grounds, and the political necessities said to flow them are met with critical scepticism’ [23]. While this theory does involve constructivist thinking about identity: that it is socially constructed, Campbell distinguishes between the two. He states that ‘to argue for the centrality of the performative constitution of identity is different from maintaining that some form of constructivism... needs to be accounted for’ [24]. The key difference relates to deconstruction placing emphasis on construction being a conscious choice of the agent [25].
Campbell asserts that an ‘ethos of political criticism’ [5] is required: an examination not of what the Bosnian identity means, or why it is that way, but rather how it is. What Campbell is concerned with is not the origins of Bosnian identity, but how the construction of this identity has effected representations of the conflict, and the results of this in a political context. He states “rather than assuming a pregiven, externally existing...


... middle of paper ...


...s for a multi-ethnic state solution, while explaining how that could be possible, through his ethos of democracy discourse [201-207].
Campbell’s work National Deconstruction: Violence, Identity and Justice in Bosnia is effective in bringing to the readers’ attention a different way of thinking about violence and identity in Bosnia. However, a few flaws in his methodology have been noted. Furthermore, while the possibility of a multi-ethnic solution is an interesting one, and deserves further academic discourse, the reality may not match up to his thinking, for example other issues in the former Yugoslavia, including the Kosovan separatist movement, could be seen to cast doubt on the effectiveness of large multi-ethnic states with pockets of different ethnic majorities.



Works Cited

David Campbell National Deconstruction: Violence, Identity and Justice in Bosnia

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

National and European Identity Essay

- Scholars of the European Union (EU) have a strong interest in the concept of European Union identity (Cram, 2009). The ‘European union’ identity can be identified nowadays, although there are still conflicts between national identities and a shared European identity which can be illustrated by the data from Eurobarameter and other sources. Most people perceive themselves as Europeans, as Anderson (1991) state, there is no contradictory between Europe and nation-state, ‘country first, but Europe, too’ is the main feeling of the public....   [tags: European Interaction, Identity]

Better Essays
1284 words (3.7 pages)

The National Institute Of Justice Essay

- What Works Movement The National Institute of Justice tells us that Community Corrections are programs to oversee offenders outside jail or prison, and are administered by agencies or courts with the legal authority to enforce sanctions. A group of Canadian psychologists examined why some programs reduced re-offending while others did not. After many years of study these psychologists discovered that working intervention programs shared some common features and was developed into the Principles of Effective Intervention....   [tags: Crime, Criminal justice, Prison, Corrections]

Better Essays
1062 words (3 pages)

Essay about Preserving a Country's National Identity

- One of the main issues that has become a major concern in many countries all over the globe is the issue of national identity. This concern has been intensified by the spread of globalization with all its effects. In today’s globalized era, the traits of national identity have been eroded in favor of a more global character. Technological developments in all fields, and especially in mass-communication technology, have transformed the world into a global village. Consequently, preserving a country’s national identity has become a dilemma for many governments....   [tags: government dilemmas, national symbols]

Better Essays
654 words (1.9 pages)

The Country Of Bosnia Herzigovina Essay

- Dictionary.com defines culture as “the behaviors and beliefs characteristic of a particular social, ethnic, or age group. (dictionary.reference.com) Culture can be characterized by five characteristics that all cultures have in common. They are learned, shared, symbol, integrated, and dynamic. Simply put, Learned means culture is learned from others. Shared means it is shared among each other. Symbol can consist of hand gestures or holy symbols that are recognized throughout the culture. Interconnected means different parts of the culture are interconnected....   [tags: Bosnia and Herzegovina]

Better Essays
995 words (2.8 pages)

Essay on Expo 67 and National Identity

- Research Assignment: Expo 67 and National Identity What does it mean to be Canadian. What is Canada’s national identity. These are questions which are difficult to answer. The International and Universal Exposition in 1967, or otherwise known as Expo 67, was an exhibition held in Montreal, Quebec from April to October, which was celebrating Canada’s centennial. I found many primary and secondary sources that recognize how Canadians perceive national identity through the exhibition. The theme for the Expo was ‘Man and his World’ and this raised the sense of national pride for Canadians....   [tags: Canada, exhibition, 1967, sources, national pride]

Better Essays
2116 words (6 pages)

The Deceptive Killings : The 1992 Bosnian Genocide Essay

- The Deceptive Killings: The 1992 Bosnian Genocide The killings in Bosnia are less famous than other genocides despite the fact that it was the second largest Genocide in Europe. More than 100,000 people were killed and as many as two million where displaced. The height of the killing took place three years after its beginning in 1995 when 8,000 Bosniaks were killed all at once. It was this event which later became known as the Srebrenica genocide that finally got the attention of the UN and the US (Wallenberg, 1999)....   [tags: Bosnia and Herzegovina]

Better Essays
1002 words (2.9 pages)

Essay National Identity Cards and Citizens' Right to Privacy

- The article, “National Identity Cards Strange Liberty, Banish Privacy” by Charles Levendosky, implies that Identity Cards give us a false sense of security. The system would not prevent terrorists from using fake documents to get a national identity card and all citizens’ private information would be shared with government agencies and commercial organizations, therefore all personal information can be easily accessed through a computer system. This would result in a surveillance society with many obstacles due to human errors and leaving citizens with no privacy and freedom to be themselves....   [tags: Identity Cards, privacy]

Better Essays
791 words (2.3 pages)

Ethnic Identity And National Identity Essay

- It seems necessary to begin this essay by discussing the differences between a nation and a state before one can analyze what Collier meant when he declared, “leaders must build a nation before they can build a state” (Collier, 2009, pg. 52). A nation represents a collection of people that are united by the sharing of similar cultures, decent, history, and/or languages within a particular region. In contrast, a state represents a region that is considered to have an organized political structure beneath a single government....   [tags: Nation, Ethnic group, Race, Ethnicity]

Better Essays
736 words (2.1 pages)

Essay on National Identity Cards

- NATIONAL ID CARD EXECUTIVE SUMMARY After the September 11th attacks, the issue of making national ID card in the United States, Canada and other countries has restarted. After reading many articles, magazines, and skipping through lots of frequently ask question about nation General confirmed the black market in phony driver’s licenses exist in that state.” National ID card, I myself believe that national ID card will not only not stop terrorism, illegal immigrants but also create a form of discrimination and increase ID fraud....   [tags: National ID Cards]

Better Essays
609 words (1.7 pages)

Identity Essay

- Identity is a state of mind in which someone recognizes/identifies their character traits that leads to finding out who they are and what they do and not that of someone else. In other words it's basically who you are and what you define yourself as being. The theme of identity is often expressed in books/novels or basically any other piece of literature so that the reader can intrigue themselves and relate to the characters and their emotions. It's useful in helping readers understand that a person's state of mind is full of arduous thoughts about who they are and what they want to be....   [tags: Identity character literature self]

Better Essays
1453 words (4.2 pages)