Nation And State Building By Paul Collier Essay

Nation And State Building By Paul Collier Essay

Length: 926 words (2.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Nation and State-Building
In Paul Collier’s book Wars, Guns, and Votes he devotes a chapter in which he discusses the need to build a nation before building a state. His article describes the hardships of becoming a leader and changing government within nations within Africa. The biggest problem they must first overcome is their own ethnic principles. Many leaders struggled with becoming leader and not conducting themselves in the name of their ethnicity. Later in his chapter he describes ways in which the ethnic identity grew into politics to provide growth. The major issue is that he states was that ethnic identity usually trumps nationally identity, (Collier, p.51). Nations are struggling to build nations because their ethnical identity is interrupting their political stability. Constant influences from ethnic identity to make their identity known in politics was trumping that of building nations that are struggling. What might have been good for that politicians background might not have been for the country. This is leading into the nation losing their identity.
A politician is set in place in order to build or manage a nation and relate that the state level. If we fail to recognize the problems within the nation and never build the nation to the status quo than we have failed. The main reason nations are having the trouble of being built within Africa are based off the ethnical politics that is occurring. Collier described that where the board was diverse, management was worse: specifically, the members of the board were not prepared to criticize people from their own ethnic group who were failing to make contributions, (p.59). A group that wants to work together to build a state would have to be ethnically t...


... middle of paper ...


...’s work on the nation struggle in Africa proves to be a mixture of contractarian and predatory views of state. This is due to the ethnic identity struggles that are occurring with the nations. Each political leader is trying to lead, but encounters the struggle to make their tribe more powerful in order to maintain their rights within their tribes. This prevents a struggle in building a state because they are focused on the national identity first. Power struggle within government entities will provide guidance or hinder growth, but it will depend on the strategy of the political leader. Social contracts can be made, but then the power is dispersed between groups or the political leader can maintain the power and focus on the citizens in their own points. A political leader focus needs build a national identity that is seen as powerful before building a state.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Book Review: The Bottom Billion by Paul Collier Essay

- Paul Collier’s book is about the future of the world. Most of the world is on the positive trajectory set by growth and prosperity. The 21st Century is the age of the middle class. For most of the world, things are looking up. However, Collier is concerned with a group of countries that are not part of this trajectory. Collier is concerned with approximately 58 countries that constitute about one billion people, or 20 percent of the earth’s population (Collier 7). This “bottom billion” group belongs to countries that are not progressing with the rest of the world’s pace; in fact, they seem to be diverging and falling apart when everyone else around them are growing....   [tags: bottom billion, world trade, state sovereighty]

Better Essays
1817 words (5.2 pages)

Essay on The State Of Nation State

- Nation-State The nation-state has developed quite recently, prior to the 1500s in Europe the nation-state did exist because they didn’t know much else other than the village in which they came from. The term nation-state means a form of political origination in which a group of people who share the same history, traditions or language line in a particular are under one government. But the term the nation-state is much more than that, the hyphen in the middle of the term is what links them. The nation-state has four components which are territory which can also mean land and area....   [tags: Nation, Nationalism, Nation state, Sovereignty]

Better Essays
1072 words (3.1 pages)

A Nation State Is A Term Composed Of Two Key Notions Essay

- A Nation State is a term composed of two key notions: “nation” and “state”. A nation is defined as a community of people with comparable cultural, ethnic and historical backgrounds who domicile in defined international borders and have some form of recognised governing body which overseas the nation. It is important to note that the word “nation” refers only to a socio-cultural entity, a group of people that share culture, language and traditions. The concept doesn’t necessarily embody the formal political organisations, such as countries....   [tags: Nation, Nationalism, Sovereignty, Nation state]

Better Essays
1413 words (4 pages)

Essay on A Nation State

- A "nation-state" is one type of structure in which a country (nation), organizes itself politically under one government. To begin, a "nation" refers to the people or private lives of citizens. Nations are uniform in their demography and culture ( language, race, culture, ethnicity, etc.) and have a strong sense of community. Nations also politically control themselves (autonomous self-governance) and establish institutions (government, economy, education, labor, health). A nation promotes nationalism, the ideology that the nation 's geographic and demographic interests should be the primary political identity of its individuals (sum of all parts)....   [tags: United States, Russia, Nation, Nationalism]

Better Essays
1370 words (3.9 pages)

Globalization And Its Impact On Nation State Essay

- Despite the fact that globalization has existed for centuries, it appears for many as a threat to the concept of nation-state. However, according to others, globalization has greatly benefit nation-states, and should therefore be conceived as a helpful phenomenon rather than a drawback. But if globalization is not more recent than nation-states, it has however been on the rise for the last decades. Thus it has taken more and more importance at domestic and global scale. This explains the concerns raised by many scholars who see in this expansion the end of nation-states....   [tags: Globalization, Culture, Nation, Nationalism]

Better Essays
972 words (2.8 pages)

Why People Sacrifice Their Life For A Nation? Essay

- “Imagined communities,” a book by Benedict Anderson, attempts to answer the question on why people sacrifice their life for a nation. Why people become very nationalist and ready to be killed in the bloodshed of a war for their nation. Anderson (1991, p. 5) argues that nationality is a cultural object of particular things. Nationality may have a compound intersection with historical powers, capable of being transferred with some changeable degree of perceptions, and may amalgamate congruently with political and ideological assemblages....   [tags: Nationalism, Nation, Nationality, Nation state]

Better Essays
1125 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on Difference Between A Nation And State

- To explain the difference between a nation and state, a definition is necessary. A state is government with supreme authority to make laws over a defined territory or population. For some American citizens, this might be hard to understand, but “American state” is not the state that is defined above. State government, such as West Virginian government, can make laws, but it is not the government with supreme authority; therefore, West Virginia is not a state but the United States is a state. Yet, a nation is a different concept....   [tags: City, Suburb, Urban area, Sovereign state]

Better Essays
723 words (2.1 pages)

Globalization Has Undermined The Power Of The Nation State Essay

- In recent decades, globalization has become a trend though hundreds nations around the world. Generally, globalization refers to trend of countries joining together in alliances or unions to support each other in many aspects such as politics, economy, education, and even military (Burbules & Torres, n.d.). While globalization brings a huge package of advantages to many nations and states, it would be fair to recognize a long list of disadvantages from this trend. In my opinion, one of the most significant problem is globalization has undermined the power of the nation state....   [tags: Globalization, United Nations, Nation]

Better Essays
900 words (2.6 pages)

Essay on Dialect in D. H. Lawrence's A Sick Collier

- Dialect in D. H. Lawrence's A Sick Collier How much can one tell from the dialogue and dialect from a piece of literature. "A Sick Collier" by D. H. Lawrence is a short story that exemplifies how important dialect can be to the understanding of a story. This story's dialect is key to many elements of the story. Through the dialect, the reader gets a full picture of the setting, understanding of the collier's social class, and shows the difference in intelligence between the collier and the other speaking characters....   [tags: Lawrence Sick Collier Essays]

Better Essays
878 words (2.5 pages)

Paul Robeson Essay

- Paul Robeson was a famous African American athlete, singer, actor and advocate for the civil rights of people around the world.  He rose to prominence in a time when segregation was legal in America and black people were being lynched by white mobs, especially in the South. Born on April 9, 1898 in Princeton, New Jersey, Paul Robeson was the youngest of five children.  His father was a runaway slave who went on to graduate from Lincoln University, and his mother came from a family of Quakers who worked for the abolition of slavery....   [tags: Biography Paul Robeson]

Better Essays
922 words (2.6 pages)