NASA Management Failure and the Columbia Space Shuttle Disaster Essays

NASA Management Failure and the Columbia Space Shuttle Disaster Essays

Length: 709 words (2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The Columbia space shuttle disintegrated on re-entry into the Earth's atmosphere in February of 2003. The astronauts on board had completed a two week mission and were returning home. The program was halted for the next couple of years while the disaster was investigated. The Columbia Accident Investigation Board reported on what if found to be the cause of the tragedy. After take-off a piece of insulation foam fell off and hit the external fuel tank and left wing. The damage to the wing's thermal protection was unknown. On re-entry the heat caused the aluminum airframe structure to melt, causing the explosion. The report listed other factors contributing to this accident including organizational problems. How NASA presented technical information in its briefings was found to be ineffective even damaging.
For a shuttle mission to succeed it depends on a team of planners, engineers and support staff. Planning and rehearsing every detail of the schedule is a must. Risk is assessed for every possible problem and backup plans created. NASA's space centers organize, monitor and control each mission with military precision. But reduction of personnel and internal pressure to launch on time caused safety issues to be neglected.
Absence of Success
A video clip and report was sent to Boeing engineers when the foam tile strike occurred during the launch. Boeing requested a satellite image of the wing, but never received it. Without pictures, they created a computer modeling tool, 'Crater', to predict how the damage would affect Columbia during re-entry. In January, the team presented its findings. Had NASA taken the view that the damaged left wing threatened re-entry, it could' have used either of two fallback plans to sa...

... middle of paper ... concerns are addressed.
NASA allowed itself to evolve into an organization with inconsistent authority and responsibility in its safety structure, exhibiting differences between and even within its centers. Over time NASA left the responsibility for safety to contractors and was unaware of critical details. The safety structure is vital, especially in organizations like NASA. Safety managers must have authority and voice in decision making. Issues regarding safety should be brought to management without fear. Unexpected events occur and solutions come from line workers, not senior management. (Disaster, 2008)

Works Cited

Stillman, R.J., (2010), Public Administration Concepts and Cases, Boston, Wadsworth Cengage Learning.
The Columbia Disaster - Death By PowerPoint (2008), BBC, The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

NASA's Incompetence: The Challenger and Columbia Shuttle Disasters Essay

- On an unusually cool Florida morning in January 1986, the space shuttle Challenger exploded 50,000 feet above ground just moments after liftoff killing seven crew members onboard (Palmer, Dunford, and Akin, 2009). A presidential commission, dubbed “the Rogers Commission” (hereafter, the Commission) after former Secretary of State William Rogers, was appointed to investigate the cause of the disaster. Although mechanical failure of an O-ring seal in one of the rocket boosters was identified as the physical cause, the investigation revealed something much more disheartening; organizational deficiencies at NASA had allowed potential safety hazards to be disregarded....   [tags: Incompetence Of NASA]

Better Essays
1532 words (4.4 pages)

The Challenger and Columbia Shuttle Disaster: NASA Essay

- NASA Shuttle Case Study Introduction For this assignment we will discuss some theories on organizational change learned during this class and how they relate to the case study of NASA (The Challenger and Columbia Shuttle Disaster). First we will look the images of managing change used by NASA in the case study. Then we will discuss the types of change(s) NASA under took. Next we will look at some of the challenges of change that NASA faced. Next we will discuss some of the resistance to change that NASA dealt with....   [tags: change, safety, quality assurance]

Better Essays
1402 words (4 pages)

Challenger and Columbia Case Study Essay

- For those of us old enough to remember, the Challenger and Discovery shuttle disasters will be forever embedded in our memories. These tragic events were a part of my childhood that unfailingly dictate my thinking and feelings toward the space program, space exploration, and failed organizational initiatives. These events serve as a reminder of the profound results failed management techniques and change processes can have on an organization and the public around them. The Challenger and Discovery disasters may directly affect me more than others because they serve as examples of what happens when closed-minded thinking, refusal to change, and poor communication are part of the norms and fou...   [tags: shuttle disasters, space exploration]

Better Essays
1706 words (4.9 pages)

The Space Shuttle Challenger Disaster Essay examples

- 1.0 Introduction Seventy three seconds into its 10th flight, on January 28, 1986, the Space Shuttle Challenger broke apart over the Atlantic Ocean, killing the seven crew members on board [1]. The Challenger was the second space shuttle constructed by NASA and had completed nine successful missions prior to the disaster. Following the accident, the shuttle program was suspended for 32 months as President Ronald Regan appointed a Commission, chaired by William P. Rogers and known as the Rogers Commission, to investigate the cause of the accident [1]....   [tags: Management]

Better Essays
3177 words (9.1 pages)

End of the Space Shuttle Program: An American Financial Voyage Essays

- NASA’s Shuttle Program also known as the Space Transportation System, was the first winged manned spacecraft operation to have achieved orbit and land, also the first to use reusable spacecrafts and make multiple flights into various orbits. Although the shuttle program took America to a heighten achievement of orbital transportation, recent closure of the program has baffled many Americans and left questions about the future of the American space missions. The closure of the program by the Obama administration is a short-term allocation of government funds that should be better understood as a strategic move to improve the future stability of the American economy....   [tags: Space Exploration ]

Better Essays
1428 words (4.1 pages)

Analysis of Columbia’s Final Mission Essay

- Putting yourself in the shoes of the managers or engineers in the case (Ron Dittemore, Linda Ham, Don McCormack, Rodney Rocha, Pamela Madera, Calvin Schomburg), consider the following questions. • What prior assumptions and beliefs shaped the way that you thought and behaved during the Columbia mission. • What pressures affected your behavior. Where did these pressures originate. • In what ways did the culture impact your actions. • If you were in that person’s shoes during the Columbia mission, would you have behaved differently....   [tags: Case Study, Case Analysis, Mission Analysis]

Better Essays
975 words (2.8 pages)

Costs and Benefits of Humans and Space Technologies, Exploration and Innovation

- ... Independent space technologies, such as rovers and satellites, are flexible, proven to be highly productive in missions to outer space; these technologies are also less expensive to launch than shuttles for human space travel (Van Allen). Corporations Corporations support space exploration because of its marketing power and potential financial gains that can come from discoveries. The corporate management arena is known to support any technological innovation that soothes their economic thirst....   [tags: NASA funding]

Better Essays
1617 words (4.6 pages)

The Final Flight of the Space Shuttle Columbia Essay example

- At 9 a.m. on February 1st, 2003, disaster struck the space shuttle program: Columbia had disintegrated upon re-entry into Earth’s atmosphere just 16 minutes before it was supposed to land at Kennedy Space Center (National Geographic News par 2-3). The shuttle had been damaged by little more than foam from the external tank but it was enough to make it susceptible to the high temperatures it faced as it descended through the atmosphere. The idea that a space shuttle can endure damage that is unforeseen or unavoidable is well within reason....   [tags: NASA, Disaster]

Free Essays
1043 words (3 pages)

Essay on Columbia Space Shuttle- Final Mission

- Columbia Final Mission Wayne Hale, Deputy Shuttle Manager Wrote: "Last year we dropped the torch through our complacency, our arrogance, self assurance, sheer stupidity and through our continuing attempt to please everyone". "Seven of our friends and colleagues paid the ultimate price for our failure. Yet the nation is giving us another chance…..We must not Fail" More then three years ago the Space Shuttle Columbia went down in flames, due to the damage caused but not limited to, a piece of insulating foam that broke off the external tank and struck the wing's leading edge....   [tags: American History, NASA]

Free Essays
964 words (2.8 pages)

Nasa Essay

- For nasa,the sixties had ended in triumph. Human had walked on the moon and nasa had put them there. For the space agency, the success of the first lunar landing was an invitation to dream even bigger dreams.Nasa admistrador Tom Painne and hios deputies planned a stunning array of space activities so extensive that they would live up to the vision presented.GOLDEN, Colo -- Explorers eager to trek across the Moon's battered surface or Mars' dusty plains may be stranded here on Earth but our planet offers an array of locations that, in varying degrees, mimic those otherworldly landscapes....   [tags: NASA Space Technology Astronaut]

Free Essays
1361 words (3.9 pages)